Very good ice cream with huge portions. Everyone working there was nice and helpful.
Joe Gracyalny
Visited here after Cranfest in Stone Lake. Great customer service and the ice cream was phenomenal! Worth a stop after dinner downtown
Ivy Berg
Eight dairy-free ice cream flavors!!!!! We are stopping here every time we pass through Hayward!!! So good!
Ivonne Benitez
I wish this were a nationwide chain, there are soooo many yummy flavors!!! We were blown away by the amount of vegan options. It is amazing to see water-based and oatmilk based options with no nuts. The employees were also very kind and attentive. Thank you Sundaes with Annabell and Charlotte, thank you for providing a safe place for my son with food allergies!
D L H
Good icecream friendly staff even with a few Karen's complaints about that leaving low reviews. Popcorn flavors make the whole place smell great.
d arek
Good icecream friendly staff even with a few Karen's complaints about that leaving low reviews. Popcorn flavors make the whole place smell great.
Megan Johnson
Much appreciate the multiple options for dairy free icecream! 8 to chose from for my little one—our new favorite icecream store because of this! ❤️
Jeffrey Mast
Homely clean place with good flavors and friendly staff.
Midwest Mom Travels–Miles \u0026 Mayhem
If you’re looking for a next-level ice cream experience, this is the spot. From the moment you walk in, you’re hit with the rich scent of fresh waffle cones and—you guessed it—popcorn! It’s not your average ice cream shop. They’ve mastered the art of combining sweet and salty, creamy and crunchy.
The star of the show? A flavor boldly (and accurately) named “This Sh*t Just Got Serious.” It’s everything you want in a dessert: silky smooth chocolate ice cream swirled with caramel, loaded with fudge pieces, and topped off with bits of salty popcorn. It’s wild. It’s indulgent. And yes, it’s serious.
Every bite is a perfect balance of textures and flavors. The popcorn adds just the right crunch without overpowering the creaminess of the ice cream. It’s weird in the best possible way.
Whether you’re a traditional vanilla lover or someone chasing the most unique flavor combos around, this place delivers. Friendly staff, fun vibe, and unforgettable ice cream. 100% worth the trip—and the calories.
Friendly atmosphere & wonderful selection of flavors including Dairy Free options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tina Brettingen
The 2 young people at the counter were great. However, the owner came in and disciplined them about a toilet paper in bathroom in front of customers. So unprofessional!!!! He should have done this in another room.
J & R H
Clean, bright and friendly. Delicious ice cream!!! Will be back for sure.
Dietary restrictions: Have gluten free, vegan, etc lists
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe
Stopped in Hayward on the way through to Bayfield and decided to look for ice cream. Was not aware the muskie festival was going on! Watched the parade for a bit, then snuck in here before it was over, so it wasn't too busy yet.
Great selection of ice cream. Yippy Skippy was a favorite, and Superman and Cotton Candy. Did the 2 scoop bowl for everyone even though it was kind of expensive at like $8 per bowl. However, when I saw the kids walking out with their bowls (I was waiting on the sidewalk with the dogs), I was shocked that my wife would let them get that much ice cream. Then she informed me it was the 2 scoop bowl??? Maybe it was more 'a bowl filled with 2 kinds of ice cream'? The serving size was generous, and it's the first time I have seen our kids complain about having to finish their ice cream.
So, while expensive, it was worthwhile, servings are good size and dozens of flavors to choose from, but my recommendation is to stick with the 1 scoop unless you just cannot decide between 2 flavors. Also, they do have a nutrition sign out front if you need it. A quick overview of it- if you need to know that information, just keep walking.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 2 Scoop Sundae
Christi Forbes
They have an entire freezer filled with nondairy ice cream, and it's all delicious. Everyone has been nice every time I visit.
Amazing customer serivce!
Very good ice cream with huge portions. Everyone working there was nice and helpful.
Visited here after Cranfest in Stone Lake. Great customer service and the ice cream was phenomenal! Worth a stop after dinner downtown
Eight dairy-free ice cream flavors!!!!! We are stopping here every time we pass through Hayward!!! So good!
I wish this were a nationwide chain, there are soooo many yummy flavors!!! We were blown away by the amount of vegan options. It is amazing to see water-based and oatmilk based options with no nuts. The employees were also very kind and attentive. Thank you
Sundaes with Annabell and Charlotte, thank you for providing a safe place for my son with food allergies!
Good icecream friendly staff even with a few Karen's complaints about that leaving low reviews. Popcorn flavors make the whole place smell great.
Good icecream friendly staff even with a few Karen's complaints about that leaving low reviews. Popcorn flavors make the whole place smell great.
Much appreciate the multiple options for dairy free icecream! 8 to chose from for my little one—our new favorite icecream store because of this! ❤️
Homely clean place with good flavors and friendly staff.
If you’re looking for a next-level ice cream experience, this is the spot. From the moment you walk in, you’re hit with the rich scent of fresh waffle cones and—you guessed it—popcorn! It’s not your average ice cream shop. They’ve mastered the art of combining sweet and salty, creamy and crunchy.
The star of the show? A flavor boldly (and accurately) named “This Sh*t Just Got Serious.” It’s everything you want in a dessert: silky smooth chocolate ice cream swirled with caramel, loaded with fudge pieces, and topped off with bits of salty popcorn. It’s wild. It’s indulgent. And yes, it’s serious.
Every bite is a perfect balance of textures and flavors. The popcorn adds just the right crunch without overpowering the creaminess of the ice cream. It’s weird in the best possible way.
Whether you’re a traditional vanilla lover or someone chasing the most unique flavor combos around, this place delivers. Friendly staff, fun vibe, and unforgettable ice cream. 100% worth the trip—and the calories.
Restaurantji Recommends
Friendly atmosphere & wonderful selection of flavors including Dairy Free options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The 2 young people at the counter were great. However, the owner came in and disciplined them about a toilet paper in bathroom in front of customers. So unprofessional!!!! He should have done this in another room.
Clean, bright and friendly. Delicious ice cream!!! Will be back for sure.
Dietary restrictions: Have gluten free, vegan, etc lists
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in Hayward on the way through to Bayfield and decided to look for ice cream. Was not aware the muskie festival was going on! Watched the parade for a bit, then snuck in here before it was over, so it wasn't too busy yet.
Great selection of ice cream. Yippy Skippy was a favorite, and Superman and Cotton Candy. Did the 2 scoop bowl for everyone even though it was kind of expensive at like $8 per bowl. However, when I saw the kids walking out with their bowls (I was waiting on the sidewalk with the dogs), I was shocked that my wife would let them get that much ice cream. Then she informed me it was the 2 scoop bowl??? Maybe it was more 'a bowl filled with 2 kinds of ice cream'? The serving size was generous, and it's the first time I have seen our kids complain about having to finish their ice cream.
So, while expensive, it was worthwhile, servings are good size and dozens of flavors to choose from, but my recommendation is to stick with the 1 scoop unless you just cannot decide between 2 flavors. Also, they do have a nutrition sign out front if you need it. A quick overview of it- if you need to know that information, just keep walking.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 2 Scoop Sundae
They have an entire freezer filled with nondairy ice cream, and it's all delicious. Everyone has been nice every time I visit.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...