Tally Ho Supper Club
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$$$ •
10432 WI-77, Hayward
(715) 462-3646
About Tally Ho Supper Club
Tally Ho Supper Club Reviews
Over the top amazing as always! Such a treat to visit a classic “supper club” style restaurant in the Hayward area.
We visited The Tally Ho supper club this New Years Eve, I ordered the rib eye and lobster. First of all the shrimp cocktail appetizer, the shrimp were large but the cocktail sauce was like a paste. We both had the House made Italian dressing, both of our dressings had a clump of gooey mass, not sure what that was. I ordered my steak medium rare, it was so thin there was no way they could cook it medium rare, it was 1/4” thick. The lobster was big but very chewy, not sure what...read full review
Service was above and beyond. Definitely recommend.
Menu
People in Hayward Also Viewed
.jpg)
Tally Ho Supper Club, established in 1944, offers a delightful dining experience reminiscent of the past. The service is exceptional, with friendly staff making guests feel like family. The food receives high praise, with standout dishes including duck and supper club fare, and the prime rib is especially popular. The atmosphere is pleasant and entertaining, making it a great evening event. Guests enjoy the drinks, which are described as phenomenal, and appreciate the efforts to make everything in-house, including ranch and relish tray items. The restaurant features a varied menu, offering options like lobster tails, red snapper, steaks, duck, seafood pasta, and more. The chef's attention to detail shines through in dishes like the red snapper with lime risotto, which is highly recommended. Appetizers such as a large butter-flyed shrimp with excellent seasoning are also popular. The staff is friendly and relaxed, creating a welcoming environment. The owner, known for being personable and friendly, makes guests feel very welcomed in this historic Supper club that dates back to the 1940s. Overall, Tally Ho Supper Club is a wonderful place to create memorable experiences and is highly recommended for those seeking a higher-end dining experience in the Northwoods.