Farmers market in lake mills. I usually never eat Pie crust But this pie was so delicious I ate Bite And the rice flour cookies were phenomenal.
Ted Pollari
The pies may be good but do not trust them for pre-orders. They made a big deal about a Mother’s Day promotion with pickups at local farmers markets and despite happily taking our money, they had no pies for us. This is a real let down for Mother’s Day - don’t trust them when it matters, I guess.
Dawn
Amazing pies! I love their blueberry banana cream pie. The French silk is the best French silk pie I have ever had. The crust is what makes all their pies stand out. They also have very good customer service.
David Sandoval
Please don't go here we went here and they told us that it was a place where they only sell cookies which I was very disappointed about and they ended up telling us to go order pie to another place that we had to order it online and we ended up not getting any pie so it's not true they got any pies their a cookie shop and if you want a pie you have to order it from a another bakery
Patti Schnetz Ruffolo
Bought multiple mini pies at the Kenosha Harbor Market, very disappointing. The owner was offended when asked what type of flour was used for the pies. There was not an ingredient listing on the package. The question was asked due to dietary limitations! Would not recommend to anyone else. The chosen mini pies were disappointing, not just in taste but appearance. If you’re going to charge so much for mini pies, could you at least make them appealing to the eye?
E. H.
We love these pies. We were getting them from the harbor market on weekends when the storefront closed but I also like the little red pie wagon. It’s such a cute concept. The pies are absolutely delicious. My favorite is the mermaid pie which I never would have tried on my own but it’s amazing.
Jenn Raclaw
Excellent home made pies and treats. No longer a store front in downtown. The little red pie wagon is the new location, located across from La Fogata.
lo go
Before covid, I went to get pies every Friday. The pies are consistent and tasted great. I got pies for Thanksgiving and they were ok. We actually didn't finish them. A couple of them were smashed but that's just cosmetic. This is just my review for this one time. I will probably try them again on a non busy day.
Nima Oftadeh
The name and photos in this listing are misleading. There is no pie shop here, but a grocery store called Tenuta's that carries a few varieties of Elsie Mae's pies (some fresh, some frozen). The pie I had (strawberry rhubarb, a staff favorite) was very good, but selection was very limited. The owner of this listing might consider changing it to \\\"Elsie Mae's at Tenuta's\\\" and removing pics of a storefront that doesn't exist.
Sam Scharenbroch
Got a couple pies at Taco Fest. One of the few pies I've had where the crust is mandatory, not just needless excess.
Most of the fruit pies are great; made with fresh fruit and not overly sweetened. Today I had a blueberry pie. Worst I have ever had. Filling was a sugary, congealed mess that tasted straight from a can. Avoid this pie but most other fruit pies topped with pie crust are great. Crumble toppings not very good.
Michael Dorsett
Don't expect a pie shop at the address given. It's actually a deli that sells 2 flavors of the small pies that are made at the actual shop located somewhere downtown we were told. We had already circled the block a couple times, so were not in for another wild goose chase to the pie shop.
Willis Champions
This is not a bakery. It is an Italian grocery store that is so busy, you are lucky to get any type of bakery choices. Misleading marketing and lack of options.
80 Bucks
All the pies are great! Delicious down to the last bite.
Becky Windberg
Ordered the Holiday Dinner and it was amazing! Who knew a pie shop could make THE MOST flavorful turkey ever?!?! Thanks for making our holiday easy and delicious!
Farmers market in lake mills. I usually never eat Pie crust But this pie was so delicious I ate Bite And the rice flour cookies were phenomenal.
The pies may be good but do not trust them for pre-orders. They made a big deal about a Mother’s Day promotion with pickups at local farmers markets and despite happily taking our money, they had no pies for us. This is a real let down for Mother’s Day - don’t trust them when it matters, I guess.
Amazing pies! I love their blueberry banana cream pie. The French silk is the best French silk pie I have ever had. The crust is what makes all their pies stand out. They also have very good customer service.
Please don't go here we went here and they told us that it was a place where they only sell cookies which I was very disappointed about and they ended up telling us to go order pie to another place that we had to order it online and we ended up not getting any pie so it's not true they got any pies their a cookie shop and if you want a pie you have to order it from a another bakery
Bought multiple mini pies at the Kenosha Harbor Market, very disappointing. The owner was offended when asked what type of flour was used for the pies. There was not an ingredient listing on the package. The question was asked due to dietary limitations! Would not recommend to anyone else. The chosen mini pies were disappointing, not just in taste but appearance. If you’re going to charge so much for mini pies, could you at least make them appealing to the eye?
We love these pies. We were getting them from the harbor market on weekends when the storefront closed but I also like the little red pie wagon. It’s such a cute concept. The pies are absolutely delicious. My favorite is the mermaid pie which I never would have tried on my own but it’s amazing.
Excellent home made pies and treats. No longer a store front in downtown. The little red pie wagon is the new location, located across from La Fogata.
Before covid, I went to get pies every Friday. The pies are consistent and tasted great. I got pies for Thanksgiving and they were ok. We actually didn't finish them. A couple of them were smashed but that's just cosmetic. This is just my review for this one time. I will probably try them again on a non busy day.
The name and photos in this listing are misleading. There is no pie shop here, but a grocery store called Tenuta's that carries a few varieties of Elsie Mae's pies (some fresh, some frozen). The pie I had (strawberry rhubarb, a staff favorite) was very good, but selection was very limited. The owner of this listing might consider changing it to \\\"Elsie Mae's at Tenuta's\\\" and removing pics of a storefront that doesn't exist.
Got a couple pies at Taco Fest. One of the few pies I've had where the crust is mandatory, not just needless excess.
Restaurantji Recommends
Most of the fruit pies are great; made with fresh fruit and not overly sweetened. Today I had a blueberry pie. Worst I have ever had. Filling was a sugary, congealed mess that tasted straight from a can. Avoid this pie but most other fruit pies topped with pie crust are great. Crumble toppings not very good.
Don't expect a pie shop at the address given. It's actually a deli that sells 2 flavors of the small pies that are made at the actual shop located somewhere downtown we were told. We had already circled the block a couple times, so were not in for another wild goose chase to the pie shop.
This is not a bakery. It is an Italian grocery store that is so busy, you are lucky to get any type of bakery choices. Misleading marketing and lack of options.
All the pies are great! Delicious down to the last bite.
Ordered the Holiday Dinner and it was amazing! Who knew a pie shop could make THE MOST flavorful turkey ever?!?! Thanks for making our holiday easy and delicious!
Loading...