We had an unusual Monday evening dinner. It was our first time at 1844. The dining room was nearly empty, only one table was occupied when we were seated. 4 other tables filled in as the evening went on ... so it was slow, but not a ghost town. The waitress was perfectly nice. Everything was rather slow, weirdly slow, so slow it was a bit awkward. Food and drink was good, but far from awesome. I'm really easy to please so that says something. The place looks really nice ... outside and inside. One minor annoyance was a group chatting very loudly in the bar nearby. The menu was limited compared to some other restaurants. One surprise was dinner did not include a salad. We ordered the cheese curds for an appetizer and it was super. I'd go back, but I'd hope to hit a better night service wise.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Roman Budek
Excellent food and atmosphere
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeanne George
Everything we had was delicious. Service was fantastic. Drinks amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jacqueline Dallas
The staff is very friendly. It's a great place to have night out with your spouse or friends.
Steven Brown
The prime rib was the best I have had in a long time it was perfect. The medallions with the cowboy butter was excellent. And let's talk about dessert WOW! The butterscotch budino was the most amazing thing I have had (mic drop)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jane
Little disappointed when we went here because I wanted to order food in the Crow's nest in the bartender told us we would have to order it to go and go downstairs and pick it up and then bring it back upstairs to eat it. Then 10 minutes later we saw a server bringing up food to a table so it was a little bit confusing and disappointing. We ended up leaving and going and eating somewhere else. Hopefully they get this figured out because they do have a menu just for the crows nest which doesn't make sense if they're not serving up there
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Rachel Twist
We have THE BEST server tonight. She was amazing in every aspect. Great experience. The food and drinks were perfect! Will be back soon.
David Price
When we arrived at the restaurant there was nobody at the counter to greet us and another couple waiting in the lobby for the host. So we decided to go to the bar and sit at a table. They were busy and nobody acknowledged us so we sat for 10 minutes got up and went back to the lobby and still no host. Couple minutes later the host arrives and sits us in the dining room. We sat there for 20 minutes and nobody came to our table. Inside the dining room there are approximately 15 tables and approximately 5 tables had customers at them and we noticed 3 or 4 waiters/waitresses working. Not one person bothered to say anything or make a jester that we were there. There was a table two down from us that were sat after us and were waited on. So I got up to see the hostess and again nobody at the counter to assist, so we got up and left. My opinion is there is no leadership and the staff appear to be somewhat missable. I’ll bet the hostess did not tell someone that she sat us and the waitress thought she didn’t do her job so pretend I didn’t see them. Again it was dead in the dining room. I noticed the staff in the dining room were not smiling for the twenty minutes we sat there making me believe it most be a miserable place to work. We ate there before the service is slow, but the food we had was good and the environment is pleasant. I hope someone gets control of the dining room and turns it around.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Shannon Pryse
Celebrating my birthday. We were sat and noone came to take our order. Two other tables were sat after us and received water. We finally got up and left . I was very disappointed because l love there fish.
Olivia Connor
Monday night dinner not busy and no one ever brought out our drinks. They never even made them. They stated they were short staffed and got busy just 5 other tables with couples. Other than that the food was delicious. Horrible service. We had to go to the bar to cancel our drink order. No one even came to fill our water.
1st visit. Maybe last. Service was horrible, see my glass in photo. I also asked for water. She walked by twice and checked our table. Experienced is what is needed here. The food was as average. Salmon was not well done. Chicken Parmesan was good portion. Had to again ask for cheese. We made reservations on open table 7pm was earliest they had. This is how busy it was at 715pm.
This place is inside an old hotel. The hotel is amazing view and decor.
Atmosphere was good, but a lingering smell of broken perfume bottle was in the dinning area. If you are sensitive to smells. Maybe it was a customer. Overall it was average to below experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
sandra miller
Super place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish
Edgar Triana
Best ribeye in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nathaniel Erickson
Kenny is fantastic! The food and atmosphere is top notch; I feel like this place isn’t talked about enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Becca Nelson
Gourmet cuisine and a bougie atmosphere. Our waitress was amazing. My husband and I will definitely return.
We had an unusual Monday evening dinner. It was our first time at 1844. The dining room was nearly empty, only one table was occupied when we were seated. 4 other tables filled in as the evening went on ... so it was slow, but not a ghost town. The waitress was perfectly nice. Everything was rather slow, weirdly slow, so slow it was a bit awkward. Food and drink was good, but far from awesome. I'm really easy to please so that says something. The place looks really nice ... outside and inside. One minor annoyance was a group chatting very loudly in the bar nearby. The menu was limited compared to some other restaurants. One surprise was dinner did not include a salad. We ordered the cheese curds for an appetizer and it was super. I'd go back, but I'd hope to hit a better night service wise.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Excellent food and atmosphere
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything we had was delicious. Service was fantastic. Drinks amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The staff is very friendly. It's a great place to have night out with your spouse or friends.
The prime rib was the best I have had in a long time it was perfect. The medallions with the cowboy butter was excellent. And let's talk about dessert WOW! The butterscotch budino was the most amazing thing I have had (mic drop)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Little disappointed when we went here because I wanted to order food in the Crow's nest in the bartender told us we would have to order it to go and go downstairs and pick it up and then bring it back upstairs to eat it. Then 10 minutes later we saw a server bringing up food to a table so it was a little bit confusing and disappointing. We ended up leaving and going and eating somewhere else. Hopefully they get this figured out because they do have a menu just for the crows nest which doesn't make sense if they're not serving up there
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
We have THE BEST server tonight. She was amazing in every aspect. Great experience. The food and drinks were perfect! Will be back soon.
When we arrived at the restaurant there was nobody at the counter to greet us and another couple waiting in the lobby for the host. So we decided to go to the bar and sit at a table. They were busy and nobody acknowledged us so we sat for 10 minutes got up and went back to the lobby and still no host. Couple minutes later the host arrives and sits us in the dining room. We sat there for 20 minutes and nobody came to our table. Inside the dining room there are approximately 15 tables and approximately 5 tables had customers at them and we noticed 3 or 4 waiters/waitresses working. Not one person bothered to say anything or make a jester that we were there. There was a table two down from us that were sat after us and were waited on. So I got up to see the hostess and again nobody at the counter to assist, so we got up and left. My opinion is there is no leadership and the staff appear to be somewhat missable. I’ll bet the hostess did not tell someone that she sat us and the waitress thought she didn’t do her job so pretend I didn’t see them. Again it was dead in the dining room. I noticed the staff in the dining room were not smiling for the twenty minutes we sat there making me believe it most be a miserable place to work. We ate there before the service is slow, but the food we had was good and the environment is pleasant. I hope someone gets control of the dining room and turns it around.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Celebrating my birthday. We were sat and noone came to take our order. Two other tables were sat after us and received water. We finally got up and left . I was very disappointed because l love there fish.
Monday night dinner not busy and no one ever brought out our drinks. They never even made them. They stated they were short staffed and got busy just 5 other tables with couples. Other than that the food was delicious. Horrible service. We had to go to the bar to cancel our drink order. No one even came to fill our water.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
1st visit. Maybe last.
Service was horrible, see my glass in photo. I also asked for water. She walked by twice and checked our table.
Experienced is what is needed here.
The food was as average. Salmon was not well done.
Chicken Parmesan was good portion. Had to again ask for cheese.
We made reservations on open table 7pm was earliest they had. This is how busy it was at 715pm.
This place is inside an old hotel. The hotel is amazing view and decor.
Atmosphere was good, but a lingering smell of broken perfume bottle was in the dinning area. If you are sensitive to smells.
Maybe it was a customer.
Overall it was average to below experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Super place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish
Best ribeye in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kenny is fantastic! The food and atmosphere is top notch; I feel like this place isn’t talked about enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gourmet cuisine and a bougie atmosphere. Our waitress was amazing. My husband and I will definitely return.
Loading...