Kind servers and bar tenders, great salad bar, excellent menu I have NEVER had a single complaint. The food is five stars!⭐️
Kurtis Schroeder
Me and my wife’s first time here. Great food, wonderful, friendly service and chill atmosphere. We will be back!
lori schmidt
Old Fashioned was weak and not muddled. Prime rib ordered med rare and was tough and cold. Server was good. Salad bar was decent soups were delicious.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Anne Regan
Marty’s definitely has that classic supper club vibe. All staff was attentive, efficient, and friendly. We had a large table, and our waitress handled everything perfectly. Food was excellent, nice selection on the salad bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad from the Salad Bar, Warm Bread
Heath Martinson
Was disappointed by the owner being very rude. Food was good but the staff and owner trying to explain Thursday special was horrible. I'm not used to going for discounted food but I thought what the heck and try it. They said it had to be 27.95 and dummy me of course was thinking minimum price and that's on me but as rude as owner was that was just not a friendly customer focused response. I said could we do something with the mix up, the server knew I was asking for the 2 for 44 dollars and when I ordered why didn't they help me understand those were the wrong price points. But it didn't happen until the bill came out. I still tipped the server but I will never go there again. They don't have anything displayed or on a simple piece of paper to include with the menu to say 27.95 or less. For me, I am used to buying more than two things there is minimum price, not maximum price. I said to the owner at the register I didn't hear him or the servers say 27.95 or less and he snapped back, that if it was the minimum then everyone would order 2 lobster tails and I wouldn't have a restaurant. I said fine, paid and tipped and said I will not come here again. I would rather spend more and go to Mark's Eastside, Victoria's, even Cinder's is so much friendlier, even if some of those have a higher price for excellent food. Being rude to first time customers is not a way to keep a business going either. I have worked in food services, retail, bartender, and professionally and I would be fired being so rude, I guess one perk of being owner there are no consequences for your rudeness.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Ruth M
We arrived 1st in our group of 5 at around 4:30pm on a SAT with no reservations. You could add your name on the list in the bar up to 4:30pm - afterwards you needed to set reservations at the host/hostess stand in the diningroom area. Our waitress Michel was OUTSTANDING! Personable, efficient and fun - [no milk with ice BUT we have ice ??]. My hubby had the SAT special Prime Rib, roasted red potatoes - he ate it all! I had the Lisa Tenderloin - moist steak with ooey gooey melted cheese, big bacon chunks with roasted garlic absolutely delicious. My brother had the lasagna and finished his too. Each came with a trip to the salad bar and soups. Head lettuce with mixed greens - I added cottage cheese, peas, blue cheese crumbles with shredded cheddar cheese then drizzled French Dressing. A wonderful evening for all of us there. 1st time, but we will be back ~ to try the ribs ??❤️?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad from the Salad Bar, French Onion Soup
Kathleen Friebel
I love Marty's perfect for any occasion.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad from the Salad Bar, Tenderloin Oscar and Twice Baked Potato, Warm Bread, French Onion Soup, Fried Chicken, Stuffed Haddock, Applewood Smoked Prime Rib
Lori Gossen
The food was great, and I loved the salad bar, bartenders, and Waitresses, are all very friendly.
Service: 5
Misty *
Great service Salad bar was good Fresh baked bread
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Greg Jones
This restaurant is 2 miles from my house and I’ve lived here for 9 years. No one talks about it, until someone I work with told me it is really good. Went on Saturday night and order the smoked prime rib with a side of hash browns. The salad bar was basic, but my dinner was awesome. This could be one of the best supper clubs in the Appleton area. Going back next weekend ?
I think it's weird when people leave good reviews about everything and give 4 stars...I was at Marty's last Sunday. I haven't been there in 20 years. We moved to a different town. I forgot how good this place is! Tenderloin and scallops were perfect. Great soup and salad bar, drinks were good. The prices were better than other local supper clubs and the food was great. I will make the drive more often now. I was there with a party of 12 and put bar staff and wait staff were spot on.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Hardy
Absolutely love this place! Drinks are great and the food is better!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Haddock
Brad Arft
Good food good employees
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad from the Salad Bar, Warm Bread, Smothered Tenderloin
Dan Coppens
Very good food. Old fashonds were the best part. Suggest try it out
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Chicken
Tom Wilson
As Wisconsin supper clubs so, this is a good one. Very traditional with good food and friendly service. A party of 7 of us enjoyed it and we will return.
Vegetarian options: Limited
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad from the Salad Bar, Warm Bread, French Onion Soup
Kind servers and bar tenders, great salad bar, excellent menu I have NEVER had a single complaint. The food is five stars!⭐️
Me and my wife’s first time here. Great food, wonderful, friendly service and chill atmosphere. We will be back!
Old Fashioned was weak and not muddled. Prime rib ordered med rare and was tough and cold. Server was good. Salad bar was decent soups were delicious.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Marty’s definitely has that classic supper club vibe. All staff was attentive, efficient, and friendly. We had a large table, and our waitress handled everything perfectly.
Food was excellent, nice selection on the salad bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad from the Salad Bar, Warm Bread
Was disappointed by the owner being very rude. Food was good but the staff and owner trying to explain Thursday special was horrible. I'm not used to going for discounted food but I thought what the heck and try it. They said it had to be 27.95 and dummy me of course was thinking minimum price and that's on me but as rude as owner was that was just not a friendly customer focused response. I said could we do something with the mix up, the server knew I was asking for the 2 for 44 dollars and when I ordered why didn't they help me understand those were the wrong price points. But it didn't happen until the bill came out. I still tipped the server but I will never go there again. They don't have anything displayed or on a simple piece of paper to include with the menu to say 27.95 or less. For me, I am used to buying more than two things there is minimum price, not maximum price. I said to the owner at the register I didn't hear him or the servers say 27.95 or less and he snapped back, that if it was the minimum then everyone would order 2 lobster tails and I wouldn't have a restaurant. I said fine, paid and tipped and said I will not come here again. I would rather spend more and go to Mark's Eastside, Victoria's, even Cinder's is so much friendlier, even if some of those have a higher price for excellent food. Being rude to first time customers is not a way to keep a business going either. I have worked in food services, retail, bartender, and professionally and I would be fired being so rude, I guess one perk of being owner there are no consequences for your rudeness.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
We arrived 1st in our group of 5 at around 4:30pm on a SAT with no reservations. You could add your name on the list in the bar up to 4:30pm - afterwards you needed to set reservations at the host/hostess stand in the diningroom area. Our waitress Michel was OUTSTANDING! Personable, efficient and fun - [no milk with ice BUT we have ice ??]. My hubby had the SAT special Prime Rib, roasted red potatoes - he ate it all! I had the Lisa Tenderloin - moist steak with ooey gooey melted cheese, big bacon chunks with roasted garlic absolutely delicious. My brother had the lasagna and finished his too. Each came with a trip to the salad bar and soups. Head lettuce with mixed greens - I added cottage cheese, peas, blue cheese crumbles with shredded cheddar cheese then drizzled French Dressing. A wonderful evening for all of us there. 1st time, but we will be back ~ to try the ribs ??❤️?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad from the Salad Bar, French Onion Soup
I love Marty's perfect for any occasion.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad from the Salad Bar, Tenderloin Oscar and Twice Baked Potato, Warm Bread, French Onion Soup, Fried Chicken, Stuffed Haddock, Applewood Smoked Prime Rib
The food was great, and I loved the salad bar, bartenders, and Waitresses, are all very friendly.
Service: 5
Great service
Salad bar was good
Fresh baked bread
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This restaurant is 2 miles from my house and I’ve lived here for 9 years. No one talks about it, until someone I work with told me it is really good. Went on Saturday night and order the smoked prime rib with a side of hash browns. The salad bar was basic, but my dinner was awesome. This could be one of the best supper clubs in the Appleton area. Going back next weekend ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I think it's weird when people leave good reviews about everything and give 4 stars...I was at Marty's last Sunday. I haven't been there in 20 years. We moved to a different town. I forgot how good this place is! Tenderloin and scallops were perfect. Great soup and salad bar, drinks were good. The prices were better than other local supper clubs and the food was great. I will make the drive more often now. I was there with a party of 12 and put bar staff and wait staff were spot on.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely love this place! Drinks are great and the food is better!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Haddock
Good food good employees
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad from the Salad Bar, Warm Bread, Smothered Tenderloin
Very good food. Old fashonds were the best part. Suggest try it out
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Chicken
As Wisconsin supper clubs so, this is a good one. Very traditional with good food and friendly service. A party of 7 of us enjoyed it and we will return.
Vegetarian options: Limited
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad from the Salad Bar, Warm Bread, French Onion Soup
Loading...