The food was first rate anywhere in the world. I had the locally sourced Whitefish which was terrific. The Trout Cake Salad was exquisite. I had some of my wife's beef tenderloin and the best most naturally tender beef I have had in many many years. The dishes let the quality of the main ingredients speak. The sauces and presentation were balanced and done tastefully.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
richard baker
Delicious food Welcoming cozy atmosphere Don't miss it while on Madeline!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jonathan Manschot
Food was tasty and do greatly appreciate the vegan option. Portions were way too small for cost, staff was friendly however not as accommodating or as professional as should have been, service was slow, no seating window service only so not exactly sure how to rate atmosphere but some indoor seating would have been
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Julie Pizarro
Just a forewarning if you're visiting Madeline Island during low season...this place is only available for dinner, ordering is walk-up only, and no inside seating available (very chilly to eat on the picnic table).My experience here was strange and negative.My partner and I were the FIRST to get in line and make an order at the window. He got a vegan entrée and I only ordered a cup of their "soup of the day." Since I wasn't getting much, I asked if a bowl-size is available or if they could give me more than a cup. The cashier checked if that can be done and asked one of the employees in the back. I overheard them say they no and they need to make the soup last for the NEXT TWO WEEKS...? Like excuse me? What???The cashier said it will be ready in 25 minutes. We waited 40 minutes to be given the tiniest portion of lukewarm soup in the cup. I was super disappointed to find it was filled half way... As if they were rationing the soup. My partner who ordered a vegan entrée, had a small shallow bowl of lentils and the laziest "salad" which was just leaves of spinach...very disappointing. He said it wasn't that filling.We were given our order last despite being first to order. People behind us were receiving their orders first..and that was annoying and frustrating. The food was tasty but was over priced for what portions we were given. This place was unprofessional and not customer service oriented. They seem to believe they can get away with this type of service due to the limited restaurant availability on the island.Would not recommend coming here, specifically during the off-season. You're better off packing a pbj and hand-warmers.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Ignacio Rosales
Cafe Seiche is da' place to go... food was thoughtfully prepared and delicious! And the staff was fantastic and friendly. Without a doubt, I will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Troy Cushman
Great service. Friendly!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doug B
Food was cold, service was poor. Our phone request for a reservation was not returned (so we didn't know if we had one). We were told, brusquely, when we arrived that the website indicated they didn't take reservations. That was no reason for not returning the call. The dish I had was whitefish--served sitting on a cold pasta. My wife's dish was equally disappointing. The lemon dessert was tasty. It's clear this restaurant is understaffed and the customers suffer for that.
The best takeout dinner we’ve ever had! Don’t skip the soup nor desserts because those were both phenomenal as well.
Kaushal Kalyan (Kash)
Food was Bland, and uninteresting
Amy Bromberg Funk
Did take out from Cafe Seiche last night. Had a fantastic wonderful dinner last night (smoked trout appetizer, steak, trout with polenta, stuffed tomato, panna cotta and key lime) we shared everything. It was fabulous. Thank you for existing and for still being open! Love the take out option. Everything was excellent. Love them.
Amy Bromberg Funk
Did take out from Cafe Seiche last night. Had a fantastic wonderful dinner last night (smoked trout appetizer, steak, trout with polenta, stuffed tomato, panna cotta and key lime) we shared everything. It was fabulous. Thank you for existing and for still being open! Love the take out option. Everything was excellent. Love them.
Bruce Golob
Excellent excellent food.Patience required during Covid-19 times.
Always superb. My favorite restaurant anywhere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was first rate anywhere in the world. I had the locally sourced Whitefish which was terrific. The Trout Cake Salad was exquisite. I had some of my wife's beef tenderloin and the best most naturally tender beef I have had in many many years. The dishes let the quality of the main ingredients speak. The sauces and presentation were balanced and done tastefully.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious food
Welcoming cozy atmosphere
Don't miss it while on Madeline!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was tasty and do greatly appreciate the vegan option. Portions were way too small for cost, staff was friendly however not as accommodating or as professional as should have been, service was slow, no seating window service only so not exactly sure how to rate atmosphere but some indoor seating would have been
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Just a forewarning if you're visiting Madeline Island during low season...this place is only available for dinner, ordering is walk-up only, and no inside seating available (very chilly to eat on the picnic table).My experience here was strange and negative.My partner and I were the FIRST to get in line and make an order at the window. He got a vegan entrée and I only ordered a cup of their "soup of the day." Since I wasn't getting much, I asked if a bowl-size is available or if they could give me more than a cup. The cashier checked if that can be done and asked one of the employees in the back. I overheard them say they no and they need to make the soup last for the NEXT TWO WEEKS...? Like excuse me? What???The cashier said it will be ready in 25 minutes. We waited 40 minutes to be given the tiniest portion of lukewarm soup in the cup. I was super disappointed to find it was filled half way... As if they were rationing the soup. My partner who ordered a vegan entrée, had a small shallow bowl of lentils and the laziest "salad" which was just leaves of spinach...very disappointing. He said it wasn't that filling.We were given our order last despite being first to order. People behind us were receiving their orders first..and that was annoying and frustrating. The food was tasty but was over priced for what portions we were given. This place was unprofessional and not customer service oriented. They seem to believe they can get away with this type of service due to the limited restaurant availability on the island.Would not recommend coming here, specifically during the off-season. You're better off packing a pbj and hand-warmers.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Cafe Seiche is da' place to go... food was thoughtfully prepared and delicious! And the staff was fantastic and friendly. Without a doubt, I will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service. Friendly!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was cold, service was poor. Our phone request for a reservation was not returned (so we didn't know if we had one). We were told, brusquely, when we arrived that the website indicated they didn't take reservations. That was no reason for not returning the call. The dish I had was whitefish--served sitting on a cold pasta. My wife's dish was equally disappointing. The lemon dessert was tasty. It's clear this restaurant is understaffed and the customers suffer for that.
Absolutely delicious food.
Loved it. Best food on the island.
Restaurantji Recommends
The best takeout dinner we’ve ever had! Don’t skip the soup nor desserts because those were both phenomenal as well.
Food was Bland, and uninteresting
Did take out from Cafe Seiche last night. Had a fantastic wonderful dinner last night (smoked trout appetizer, steak, trout with polenta, stuffed tomato, panna cotta and key lime) we shared everything. It was fabulous. Thank you for existing and for still being open! Love the take out option. Everything was excellent. Love them.
Did take out from Cafe Seiche last night. Had a fantastic wonderful dinner last night (smoked trout appetizer, steak, trout with polenta, stuffed tomato, panna cotta and key lime) we shared everything. It was fabulous. Thank you for existing and for still being open! Love the take out option. Everything was excellent. Love them.
Excellent excellent food.Patience required during Covid-19 times.
Loading...