Upper Crust Pizzeria
$ • Pizza, Vegetarian, Pet Friendly
Hours:
N1070 Co Trunk H, Pell Lake
(262) 279-2233
About Upper Crust Pizzeria
Customers' Favorites
Upper Crust Pizzeria Reviews
Share your opinion about Upper Crust Pizzeria
Upper Crust used to be so good, but not so much anymore 😢 Italian beef was blah & the mozzarella cheese was missing (even though it was asked & paid for) The fried ravioli was overcooked & definitely did not have jalapeños as stated on the menu. The chicken tenders were over cooked & hard. All fried food was overcooked, but then the pizza barely had melted cheese. The pizza had no flavor. Frozen pizza tastes better than what we were served tonight. We keep trying to give Upper...read full review
The Sicilian sausage pizza is the best! Great crust, complimented by gooey cheese and an ample amount of sausage.
Just experienced the worst customer service of my life. Lake Geneva has been in a power outage, our house specifically for the last 2 days so we decided to order carry out from here. We’ve ordered many times and had no issues. We live less than 15 minutes away. My husband called at 430 and was told pick up time was in 45 minutes. He showed up at 515 on the dot, and the pizza was already out which is fine. But halfway home he opened the pizzas and they were cold. He called when...read full review
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4 - 8PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 8PM |
| Friday | 4 - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 8PM |
People in Pell Lake Also Viewed
Upper Crust Pizzeria offers delicious pizzas, including the popular Sicilian style with a thick and flavorful crust. The restaurant has a fun and quirky atmosphere, decorated with license plates, old sport banners, and colorful items on the walls and ceiling, creating a nostalgic vibe. It is not fancy or stuffy, making it a comfortable place to enjoy a meal. The staff are friendly and attentive, providing quick service, especially during less busy times. Customers appreciate the friendly service and the lively environment, which includes TVs showing football games and a scrolling menu so diners can see what they are ordering. The pizza itself is consistently impressive, and the thick crust is a highlight, reminiscent of New York-style pizza. The menu includes other items like onion rings and chicken Drummies, though some reviews mention that the chicken was mostly fat and breading. The restaurant is cash-only, so guests should come prepared. Overall, it’s a great spot for a tasty, filling meal in a fun setting.