Timber Creek Pizza Co
134 E Lake St, Lake Mills
(920) 648-4277
Customers' Favorites
Spinach Alfredo Pizza
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Meat Lover's Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Supreme Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Macaroni
Menu
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
By far, the best salads in town. They are always friendly and accommodating even if they are closing soon. I love coming here. I can wait to try the ice cream! Suggestion: put your chips where people ordering can see them. I guarantee you will sell more. Works with your pop.
I wanted to love this place. The pizza was good, but grossly undercooked. Had to cook it more at home. The people working the counter seemed to preoccupied. The front door was wide open and it was a really cold night so it made it uncomfortable to sit in the store. The soda machine puts out very warm soda and it’s very dirty.
UPDATE - Went in today at owners invitation. He was very gracious and made us delicious beef and cheddar melts on fresh baked Italian bread. Not sure how the mix-up with the hot dog buns happened last time, but we will be back! Thank you!
Been here many times for pizza. Recently ordered some hot beef and cheddar subs, description said they were on Italian bread. They were on hot dog buns, so tiny, so disappointing. Wonder if they would have pulled this trick if we were...
Been here many times for pizza. Recently ordered some hot beef and cheddar subs, description said they were on Italian bread. They were on hot dog buns, so tiny, so disappointing. Wonder if they would have pulled this trick if we were...
You May Also Like
The Grist Bar and Table - 103 S Main St
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Bar
Doyle's Dogs "Downtown on Lake" - 109 W Lake St
![]()
American, Hot Dogs