Delaney's Steak Seafood Wine

The ribeye steak was the best I had in Madison. The garlic mashed potatoes amazing as well. Salad with the house dressing really good! I would just suggest trying other bread to start but food was very very delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak and Seafood

I really want to rate higher because the service was amazing, but I find steak quality disappointing for the price. We went for Valentine’s Day and really appreciated the attentive staff, but the food itself did not quite justify the cost.

We arrived about 10 to 15 minutes early and were seated right away since our table was ready. Our server was friendly, helpful with recommendations, and the food came out quickly. We were able to re-cork and take unfinished wine home with no extra fee, and the complimentary chocolate-covered strawberries for Valentine’s Day were a very nice touch.

I ordered the 20 oz ribeye ($68). It was cooked medium rare as requested, but a large portion of the weight was bone, which was disappointing. The texture of the meat was strange. It wasn’t chewy, but it felt mushy and crumbly when cut, almost sandy, which made it less enjoyable. It was also served on a small hot plate set inside another plate, leaving very little room to comfortably cut the steak.

My partner ordered the prime rib. I actually preferred the texture of his over mine, but it was served quite cold. When we asked to pack leftovers to go, our potato sides were not included even though we had quite a lot left. We also ordered Balsamic Bruschetta for appetizer, and it really needed more flavors and basil.

The atmosphere was nice overall, but the bathroom was not very clean.

In the end, while the service stood out, the steak quality did not match the price point. I think there are other steakhouses that offer better value for similar or lower prices.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

What a great experience. Old school dining, professional staff, excellent food. Everything about this place is special. Had the seafood bisque, NY Strip Steak, mashed with garlic, coffee. Go here, bring your family.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A step above, our last family visit.
Our food was fantastic, the service was superb.
Tuesday night we had a quiet and non rushed dining experience.
We celebrated birthday’s and an Anniversary at a favorite spot for years…

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I really wanted to love this place, but my experience was mixed. The steak was disappointing. The cut of meat itself seemed good quality, but it was cooked so heavily charred that the burnt flavor completely overpowered everything else. For a dish that should be a highlight, it missed the mark.

Service also fell short. We were given food menus, but no drink or wine list was offered. Our server returned to take our order without ever mentioning cocktails, beer, or wine, and we had to ask what was available. Considering wine is part of the restaurant’s name and branding, I expected the wine list to be presented upfront and featured more prominently.

On a positive note, our other entrée was absolutely delicious and very well prepared, which shows the kitchen is capable of great execution. Overall, while there were some bright spots, I would likely choose another restaurant if I were specifically craving a steak.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Food was very good. Definately loved the seafood bisque. JC was a wonferful server but Jason brought our food and never came back to check how was everything or have our drinks refilled.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

The atmosphere is top notch. Service is the best you will find. Food is phenomenal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best service and very good food 👌

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We are out of towners who love this traditional steak and seafood restaurant! We have eaten at Delaney's several times in the last 6 months, while visiting Madison, and every time our dinner has been delicious. We had reservations for our first two visits and dined with friends in the dining rooms that are very quiet and private. The service by Peter was wonderful and the food was delicious both times. Everyone at our table was pleased with what they ordered. All steaks were done as requested and the seafood was excellent as well. Some of our visits have been just myself and my husband and we have opted for dining in the bar area and our dinners there were also excellent. Each entree we have ordered there has been perfect, and we have tried a couple of desserts as well. The baked Alaska was the best we have ever had, and the Guinness chocolate cake (recommended by bartender Mike) was to die for. We dine out quite often and we both agree that Delaney's bartenders/servers are the best! All of them have been courteous, knowledgeable at their trade and friendly. The drinks they have made for us are always a hit, from martinis and Manhattans to after dinner ice cream drinks, with the grasshopper being husband Jerry's favorite. Mike's quick wit keeps us laughing and Ben, bar manager, has been helpful in picking a good wine and a pleasant tequila for myself and friends. While dining at the bar a couple of times we have met some of the very nice regulars who have shared good conversation with us. We are looking forward to visiting Delaney's again during the holidays when we are in the Madison area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Seafood Bisque, Steak and Seafood, Caesar Salad, Hash Browns, Baked Potato, Creme Brulee, Soup of the Day

Great place, great steaks and friendly service. Get the ribeye with the truffle butter, it was so savory and delicious. Cooked to a perfect medium rare as well. This is the new birthday spot. Great old school supper club vibe. Also I love a place that will do Bleu cheese stuffed olives in your martini. Make a reservation early in the evening because it gets busy, even on a Wednesday.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Always excellent meal! Outstanding staff— always! A Madison Favorite

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wonderful meal, great menu options. Service was excellent and had a very enjoyable evening.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

A top-tier steakhouse with a gourmet menu and pairing options for wine selections.

Was good food cooked to protection

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Love love LOVE this spot. The atmosphere was very warm and our server Peter was a delight right out the gate. I mentioned possibly upgrading a side to a steak dinner with the tomato bisque even if they have to add an upcharge. And Peter ironically said that he usually always mentions the tomato bisque. His demeanor was fun and playful but at the same time very professional. I love when I can find that in servers, and I should know, as I am one myself. ;) The calamari was delicious and I liked having a choice of two sauces to dip it in. My 6oz filet was a perfect rare temperature,, but the real star of the show was my boyfriends Waygu steak. What a showstopping dish!! Melt in your mouth consistency like I've never had before. Oh yes and the seafood bisque was quite tasty. I would've liked to see more chunks of seafood in the soup but maybe that is not a characteristic of a bisque. All in all I would highly recommend this spot and tell you to ask for Peter. He made my special birthday dinner quite a remarkable occasion.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5