El Pastor Mexican Restaurant & Catering

2010 S Park St, Madison
(608) 280-8898

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Zu Ekpunobi (Dr. Zu)

3.5 - 4 out of 5 doesn't mean bad but it's appropriate for the level of quality here.

Food/service is fast, comes with starter nachos, and portion sizes are good. That said, mango margarita was unfortunately bitter, food presentation was very basic and ambience of the place was lacking. Food was good, not great and items in my order were wrong (asked for flour tortillas specifically, got corn). The lack of attention to detail is PayPal not it's ok for a quick bite.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Reba Zaidi

Gordita with chicken and avocado REALLY good. Ready in 15 minutes for pick up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Javier Ramirez

I ordered online and was amazed on my order when it came it was fast and made with care authentic, flavorfull definitely recommend this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

peter

Came in here around 8:30 and asked if they were still taking orders. They said yes and were very nice, gave me recommendations and made my food in short time. Giving 5 stars in all categories and hope to come back and eat inside sometime.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Raul Reyes

Customer service was awesome. The food I ordered was very authentic. I was very pleased.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ed Blomstrom

Without question, the best Flan I've ever had.
The food was good, and the service was excellent. Their attitude seemed genuinely caring.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Flan

russel Johnson

Had a craving for huevos rancheros, ordered through door dash, very good! 😋

Food: 5

Jacob Sturm

The single best Mexican restaurant in a hundred mile radius as well as the single best tres leches this mortal earth has been graced with. Taste the leche. Milky goodness tastes as if straight from the source.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sandra Michelle

Delicious! Ordered delivery, and it was so good. The tamales, chile relleno, burrito, and salsas were excellent. I find it ignorant when customers write bad reviews based on a delivery service. Expect the food not to be as warm as it would be if you ordered it in a restaurant when it arrives via delivery. It's common sense, don't blame the establishment.

Matthew Szlasa

This is the epitome a local no frills gem. Food is incredibly tasty and very reasonable priced. The people are always very nice and it’s clearly a family place that cares about the community. In particular, their tacos, quesadillas, and soups are worth a try.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Island Girl

Excellent catering experience from start to finish ! Lino, the manager, was friendly clear, helpful & timely with answers to my questions and offered a fair price for excellent food ! My whole family loved all the food . Would absolutely recommend !

Sharon Lundholm-Nielson

Delicious food! Clean, small restaurant. A hidden gem!

Alishan Mustafazade

Rude staff, awful owner, management!
Picked up order, saw very disrespectfulness from owner who was trying to teach me my job. Nevertheless, he tries to convince you that he is 25 years here and saw a lot of people like me. No need to try food seeing this service. I wish him to learn what is service.

alishanm2025

Awful service, awful management. When I have problem, calling manager. But the manager worse than employees. Tried to convince you every time.

Kara

Good food, good service. Rice and beans were fantastic. Also recomend the fried tilapia, and if you like spice in your life - try the pollo ranchero. 😋

Loading...

El Pastor Mexican Restaurant & Catering

2010 S Park St, Madison, WI 53713
(608) 280-8898