Food was quite good and can definitely see myself going back. Price for what you get (portion) is a little on the higher end, but the quality was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Nancy Dugan
It's a very cool environment ... make sure to check this place out when in Madison. The food was delicious. Our server could have been more attentive, but it appeared other servers were more attentive, and just ours didn't ever check back with us. We were there on a Sunday night ... will have to go back when it's busier to see it in all its glory.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Richard Young
Awesome little European style pub in sun prarie. The corned beef reuben was outstanding and the service was really good. I'll definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Reuben Sandwich
Joshua Allen
We love visiting Erin's, but had a bad experience last time. Our waitress wasn't responsive too us which led to it taking 20+ minutes to get our drinks. The waitress was sitting down talking to her friends while we were there. She ended up bringing us the check (much more expensive) for her friend's table and I had to track her down to get the correct check.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Daily News Fish & Chips
Michael Riese
Mac n cheese with pork was delicious and the redbreast 12 year was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff Nicolai
Excellent restaurant with delicious food and a great atmosphere. The Shepard's Pie was fantastic as well as the Pecan cheesecake after. The wait staff was attentive and the food came out quickly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kasey Hoffman
We just went in for the fish fry tonight as we have previously really enjoyed their food. We went in late February for fish fry on Friday and left stuffed. The pieces of cod were huge.We came tonight and the fish fry was awful. The fish pieces were basically full pieces they’d cut into thirds (see picture below-the yellow item is a lemon wedge). Each piece of the fish was barely bigger than a lemon wedge. We asked the server as we were super confused. The only answer we got was that it was a “different” cut. The fish itself was also very over done, as it seemed like they had been cooked for the normal size we’ve had before rather than accommodating for size. All in all this was a horrible experience and we will likely not return. Word to the wise, DO NOT GO FOR THE FRIDAY FISH FRY! You will be disappointed.Additionally, we had an issue with our bill. We needed assistance with getting it adjusted and the manager, Erin, was incredibly rude to us. She spoke to us in a very loud voice, sighed at us a number of times, and spoke to us rudely the entire time. We will not be returning to this establishment.If you want great food and a good staff this is not the place for you.
Nice place. The fish and chips were decent, but the fish battery was a bit soggy. The Scotch eggs were delicious though! Other than that it was pretty good. Service was very good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Sherri Bell
Corned Beef and cabbage was HORRIBLE!!!! I know they just quickly threw together a slice of ham and a few very very tiny "pieces" of carrots and a couple small potatoes onto a plate and then poured salt water on top of it. It had no flavor at all ... except for salt!!! It was Wretched!!!!
Always our favorite place to eat in Madison. Food never disappoints.Staff is usually friendly and nice.The decor is fun and comfortable.Kid-friendliness: Plenty of room to spread out and it's not busy in off hours usually.Wheelchair accessibility: Heavy front door. The tables aren't close together which is nice. But if you have to use the bathroom take a friend to open the door, it's heavy and closes quickly.
We just went in for the fish fry tonight as we have previously really enjoyed their food. We went in late February for fish fry on Friday and left stuffed. The pieces of cod were huge.
We came tonight and the fish fry was awful. The fish pieces were basically full pieces they’d cut into thirds (see picture below-the yellow item is a lemon wedge). Each piece of the fish was barely bigger than a lemon wedge. We asked the server as we were super confused. The only answer we got was that it was a “different” cut. The fish itself was also very over done, as it seemed like they had been cooked for the normal size we’ve had before rather than accommodating for size. All in all this was a horrible experience and we will likely not return. Word to the wise, DO NOT GO FOR THE FRIDAY FISH FRY! You will be disappointed.
Additionally, we had an issue with our bill. We needed assistance with getting it adjusted and the manager was incredibly rude to us. She spoke to us in a very loud voice, sighed at us a number of times, and spoke to us rudely the entire time. We will not be returning to this establishment.
If you want great food and a good staff this is not the place for you.
Jeremy
Had a great environment and everyone was so friendly. Such a great spot to hang on St Patrick's Day with the live music and festivities. Don't miss it next year!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Michael Durkin
Was fantastic!!! Bartender was superb!!! Owner and a few friends were next to me. Great time, will definitely be back on every work trip!!!!
Food was quite good and can definitely see myself going back. Price for what you get (portion) is a little on the higher end, but the quality was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
It's a very cool environment ... make sure to check this place out when in Madison. The food was delicious. Our server could have been more attentive, but it appeared other servers were more attentive, and just ours didn't ever check back with us. We were there on a Sunday night ... will have to go back when it's busier to see it in all its glory.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Awesome little European style pub in sun prarie. The corned beef reuben was outstanding and the service was really good. I'll definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Reuben Sandwich
We love visiting Erin's, but had a bad experience last time. Our waitress wasn't responsive too us which led to it taking 20+ minutes to get our drinks. The waitress was sitting down talking to her friends while we were there. She ended up bringing us the check (much more expensive) for her friend's table and I had to track her down to get the correct check.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Daily News Fish & Chips
Mac n cheese with pork was delicious and the redbreast 12 year was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent restaurant with delicious food and a great atmosphere. The Shepard's Pie was fantastic as well as the Pecan cheesecake after. The wait staff was attentive and the food came out quickly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We just went in for the fish fry tonight as we have previously really enjoyed their food. We went in late February for fish fry on Friday and left stuffed. The pieces of cod were huge.We came tonight and the fish fry was awful. The fish pieces were basically full pieces they’d cut into thirds (see picture below-the yellow item is a lemon wedge). Each piece of the fish was barely bigger than a lemon wedge. We asked the server as we were super confused. The only answer we got was that it was a “different” cut. The fish itself was also very over done, as it seemed like they had been cooked for the normal size we’ve had before rather than accommodating for size. All in all this was a horrible experience and we will likely not return. Word to the wise, DO NOT GO FOR THE FRIDAY FISH FRY! You will be disappointed.Additionally, we had an issue with our bill. We needed assistance with getting it adjusted and the manager, Erin, was incredibly rude to us. She spoke to us in a very loud voice, sighed at us a number of times, and spoke to us rudely the entire time. We will not be returning to this establishment.If you want great food and a good staff this is not the place for you.
Wonderful ethnic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Corned Beef & Cabbage, Cottage Pie, Guinness Stew
Nice place. The fish and chips were decent, but the fish battery was a bit soggy. The Scotch eggs were delicious though! Other than that it was pretty good. Service was very good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Corned Beef and cabbage was HORRIBLE!!!! I know they just quickly threw together a slice of ham and a few very very tiny "pieces" of carrots and a couple small potatoes onto a plate and then poured salt water on top of it. It had no flavor at all ... except for salt!!! It was Wretched!!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Always our favorite place to eat in Madison. Food never disappoints.Staff is usually friendly and nice.The decor is fun and comfortable.Kid-friendliness: Plenty of room to spread out and it's not busy in off hours usually.Wheelchair accessibility: Heavy front door. The tables aren't close together which is nice. But if you have to use the bathroom take a friend to open the door, it's heavy and closes quickly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Corned Beef & Cabbage, Guineas Chocolate Cake, Smothered Fried Chicken, Murphy's Irish Stew, French Onion
We just went in for the fish fry tonight as we have previously really enjoyed their food. We went in late February for fish fry on Friday and left stuffed. The pieces of cod were huge. We came tonight and the fish fry was awful. The fish pieces were basically full pieces they’d cut into thirds (see picture below-the yellow item is a lemon wedge). Each piece of the fish was barely bigger than a lemon wedge. We asked the server as we were super confused. The only answer we got was that it was a “different” cut. The fish itself was also very over done, as it seemed like they had been cooked for the normal size we’ve had before rather than accommodating for size. All in all this was a horrible experience and we will likely not return. Word to the wise, DO NOT GO FOR THE FRIDAY FISH FRY! You will be disappointed. Additionally, we had an issue with our bill. We needed assistance with getting it adjusted and the manager was incredibly rude to us. She spoke to us in a very loud voice, sighed at us a number of times, and spoke to us rudely the entire time. We will not be returning to this establishment. If you want great food and a good staff this is not the place for you.
Had a great environment and everyone was so friendly. Such a great spot to hang on St Patrick's Day with the live music and festivities. Don't miss it next year!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Was fantastic!!! Bartender was superb!!! Owner and a few friends were next to me. Great time, will definitely be back on every work trip!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Daily News Fish & Chips, Erin's Choice Wings, Chicken Wings
Great St Patrick's Day destination!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Corned Beef & Cabbage, Cottage Pie, Guinness Stew