Everly

2701 Monroe St, Madison
(608) 416-5242

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Greg H

Had the burger here. Quite good. The kale salad however was tough and chewy. I’ll get fries or something else next time.

Emily and Jay Pink

What happened Everly? It has been a go to for a number of years now. I was there on Tuesday for lunch and first of all the restaurant was filthy. There was stuff all over the floor under our booth and the tiles were so dirty, it was also only 2 o’clock in the afternoon. I ordered a salmon, BLT and it was so fishy and dry that I took about four bites, the fries were also lukewarm. I had raved about Everly to my husband for a long time, and his food Was better than mine, but not as good as I had bragged. Was it just an off day? Service was very meh. Don’t worry, we still tipped well- but will think twice before going again.

Judith Harackiewicz

So loud! The restaurant was crowded, but we were in the corner and still couldn't hear each other. The server was great, I forget his name, but it was a very long wait for the food.

jc urbs

Food was phenomenal. Absolutely appreciated the variety in the menu vegan and gluten free options. Waiting times were a little long but I think that speaks to how good the food was and how busy they were. Despite the long wait, service was great. Warm and friendly. Our server Jessica was great.

Sarah Jefferds

My first visit to Everly and it was awesome! Our server Kat (sp?) was wonderful and very attentive. The food was delicious and the portions were very generous. We'll be back!

Ross Hubbard

Stopped for lunch. Good was excellent. Great gluten free options. Service was good. Food took a tad longer than expected for lunch.

Chris Jewell

The staff was very friendly and the food was amazing.

D

Outdoor patio is so nice with excellent heaters. Food was great! Thai chicken and cauliflower app was the best. Great drinks too! Try the nightmare on monroe st.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Robert Badman

Our food was good, the service was great, and they treated us very well because it was our anniversary. The outdoor seating was perfect for the end of the summer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kai Wolfe

Exceptional food!! We had a great time! We got a selection of vegetarian appetizers and each one was fantastic. The veggie burger was delicious and had what seemed like a house-made patty. My wife got a drink which was pretty strong, a little too strong for her at first, so they were super accommodating in sweetening it to her preference. We also got the chocolate mousse for dessert which was divine especially with the raspberry sauce.

A breakdown of what we ordered in case anyone is interested:
1) Fried artichoke: delicious, somewhat small order but for the happy hour price it was perfect
2) hummus toast: fantastic and decent portion to split between 2 people.
3) cauliflower cheese fondue, which was exceptional, decent portion for the price
4) veggie burger: as noted above, fresh and delicious
5) chocolate mousse: divine (very small portion but still worth it)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julia Jaegersberg

We love Everly! It was our son's birthday so we came to celebrate. We adore the Thai chicken, the drinks - and our waitress - all so great! Thanks for a great time once again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

graphite matrix

This is an interesting place, some dinner vibe, some neighborhood vibe, I'll give the food a 4

Mark Dunning

I have enjoyed going to Everly for many years and have never had a dish I didn't enjoy. However, recently, the speed of service has been getting very slow. We ordered an appetizer with our meal (simple truffle fries), which took about 35 min to make it to our table and which was delivered only about 5 min before the rest of the meal. Sort of defeated the purpose of the appetizer. Also, I specifically ordered my salad with the dressing on the side and it was delivered fully dressed. The food and atmosphere are great, but the service and wait times are starting to drive me away.

Vegetarian options: Many dishes are either prepared vegetarian or can be ordered vegetarian.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Butternut Squash & Forbidden Rice Curry, Loaded Truffle Fries, So-Cal Grain Bowl Brunch

Nanette Kember

Brunch Saturday was great - we had a delightful and patient waitress. We had 2 toddlers and a 9 month old in tow and it isn't always the most organized situation. Food was delicious as usual. With some of us having celiac, we know the kitchen staff is always in tune with the GF items. Thanks!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amelia Cook

It was amazing coming to a restaurant with so many gluten sensitive options. I recommend the Thai style crispy chicken and the chocolate mousse terrine, super yummy! ? Their selection of Halloween inspired drinks are also lovely! Jasmin was very attentive and sweet!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Loaded Truffle Fries

Loading...