Ian’s Pizza Madison | Garver Feed Mill

Always great pizza (and we love the breadsticks), the Garver location has hands-down the friendliest staff, every time. Every delivery has had our correct order and every driver has been fantastic and kind. You can tell they really care about their customers. Fast, reliable, and consistently excellent; HIGHLY recommend this location 💕

Pizza is the name but SALAD is the game!! Great food, but I really love their salads.

We were lucky to catch the live music. Pizza was amazing and the “dad beer” they had on tap was great and was cheap. Great find!

The food and atmosphere are pretty good. Employees are horrible and have terrible customer service. I’ve been here multiple times and they never fail at being non-personable.

The flavor was good, but the crust was tough and elders beware: it was way too salty. I got up in the middle of the night to drink water and take another blood pressure pill.

It’s a very good pizza. Is it a worth $35 (including tip) for a 16” pizza good? I suppose that’s up for you to decide.

Superb crust, and the service is excellent

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Serene environment 100%
Neatness 100%
Food 100%
Music, I will prefer to be in the background rather because it's very quiet.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ian's House Side Salad

Our favorite Ian's location.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Spinach Feta Pesto

Amazing pizza! Highly recommend the chorizo nacho and ravioli pizza!

It was great the atmosphere is very nice and peaceful, the location was great it's not in downtown Madison on state street like the other one and you can actually find a place to park which is great. The pizza was 10/10. The building is so cool. Don't know why some karen left a 2 star review because they wouldn't give her free pizza that doesn't seem fair at all to the business. Paid $26 for 4 slices of pizza total, and 2 canned sodas for 2 people to eat. The employees we dealt with were friendly.

Parking: Easy to park outside, didn't have to pay for parking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza

just went to ian’s on break to grab a bite. prices raised again so pulled up with 10 and couldn’t afford 2 slices. didn’t know until counter, told the girl i only had 10 and she looked at me like i was stupid. i was like uh okay i guess i’ll just take one. she said ok. I worked at ian’s in milwaukee, we were encouraged to be kind and giving, especially because they throw out almost as much as they sell… I would always give free slices to folks who couldn’t afford them or felt like they had to pick the cheapest piece when they were hungry! That was encouraged by management and acceptable. I figured that was akward and i felt embarassed but they would probably put both my slices out anyway and i was happy to take them cuz that was very embarassing and counter active to their mission / vibe. Nope, miss counter tattled, and miss pizza waited with my slices in her hand. ‘she told me you. only wanted one, which one?’ Again; extremely embarassed i said i don’t care, ‘your get to choose’ she said with a rude look on her face. I asked ‘aren’t you gonna throw this out?’ ‘Nope’ with the deadest look on her face. It was giving a girl from higschool who didn’t like me, spite… why? Extremely unprofessional and i inviting. Ok, maybe if they don’t feed you, i would get wanting to take it if your hungry but ian’s staff get all the pizza they want .. i didn’t even eat pizza by the time i was done at ian’s cuz we got so much. Likely will not return to this location, despite working in the building because of how embarassed i feel and mean spirited that10 min interaction was. should have asked for a name. makes me think management must be mean cuz there’s no reason to treat customers like that. from my expirneces you will be tipped the difference if you give a free slice in this situation. Anyway, horrible expirence on my break just trying to get some food.

Food: 4

Service: 2

Excellent pizza. Love the maui wowie and tomato pesto. But their pickup ordering system (both online and in-person in line) is a mess and employees seem confused about how to handle orders aside from simple slices. If you go to the register to order pizza, they will make you go to the salad line to order a salad separately and nothing comes out together. Tried curbside pickup online after a few disappointments with onsite pickup, and they still made you call 5 minutes before your pickup time and I had to go inside to pickup. Ian’s, we love your pizza but goodness, please work on the user experience of your pickup flow. We should not have to jump through hoops to grab a pizza and salad to go.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Ian's Pizza is great. Good food, plenty of options. Always a fun atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mac N' Cheese, Slice of Pizza

I am not a fan of pizza, but Ian's Pizza is a highlight of trips to Madison.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza