Amazing I’ve cream, definitely the best I’ve had in Madison. They were great at addressing allergen questions. The flavors were the perfect amount of sweet and all the flavor notes came through beautifully. The space is small but cozy and adorable, can’t wait to come back
Laura K
Absolutely 🤩 ADORE this place. I can't eat gluten, so I know I can eat everything here. I come at least every 12 weeks on my way home from a recurring doctor's appt to that myself! 🍨
Caroline Crowley
One of our favorite ice cream places! We check the menu every week — there are always more than enough yummy flavors to order a flight.
Jay Christensen
Great ice cream. Always different flavor combinations. I think it’s the best in Madison. Also, great social ethos.
Andrew Dubowitz
Just the best ice cream place! Great flavors superbly done.
Narendra Singh
I had such a great experience at Ice Cream Social! The flavors are amazing—rich, creative, and full of taste, even with less sugar. It’s the perfect balance of healthy and delicious. A special thank you to Grace for the wonderful service—friendly, helpful, and made the visit even better. I’ll definitely be back!
vivian egan
Got the ice cream flight with 4 different flavors and a chocolate chip topping. Bitter Sweet Symphony was all our favorite! It had a delicious burnt sugar flavor and although very sparse, the chocolate covered potato chip pieces were wonderful when we did get them. Browned Butter did taste like described, but note it was very light compared to the others. Beenut Butter Swirl had a strong swirl of peanut butter through the honey flavored icecream, note that it was very sweet compared to others because of this combo, and the peanut butter did slightly overpower the other flavors in the flight. Chocolate buttermilk was quite tangy as expected from the description, but the cocoa flavor was less pronounced than I would have hoped for. The chocolate topping was very crunchy, but it doesn’t melt once warmed or taste like chocolate. Overall, all were good and our server was quite nice, she even gave us a recommendation for a chocolate and beenut butter combo.
Bianca Baker
The basil peach is 10/10 ✨
Indigo937
Man, this place was great! Great ice cream, nice staff, portions are good. It’s expensive, but it’s worth it for what you get. The public space can get crowded and there’s not a public bathroom, but not too big of a deal.
If I could give this a 10 star I would we love coming here. Every time we come to Madison we make sure to stop here on our way home. It’s just that good!! they have some unique flavors. The lavender honey comb is my favorite 😍
Haily Langston
Some of, if not the best ice cream I've had in Madison. If it was a tiny bit closer, I'd be there every week.
Mary Phillips
Excellent ice cream. I enjoyed the carmelodramatic
Vernon Lyles
Best ice-cream in Madison!!!!
Ericka Stellflue
Adorable shoppe!!! Incredible ice cream… and the cherry on top is the lovely, forward thinking owner and what she does to give back to her community and social causes - win win! 10/10
Great!
Amazing I’ve cream, definitely the best I’ve had in Madison. They were great at addressing allergen questions. The flavors were the perfect amount of sweet and all the flavor notes came through beautifully. The space is small but cozy and adorable, can’t wait to come back
Absolutely 🤩 ADORE this place. I can't eat gluten, so I know I can eat everything here. I come at least every 12 weeks on my way home from a recurring doctor's appt to that myself! 🍨
One of our favorite ice cream places! We check the menu every week — there are always more than enough yummy flavors to order a flight.
Great ice cream. Always different flavor combinations. I think it’s the best in Madison. Also, great social ethos.
Just the best ice cream place! Great flavors superbly done.
I had such a great experience at Ice Cream Social! The flavors are amazing—rich, creative, and full of taste, even with less sugar. It’s the perfect balance of healthy and delicious. A special thank you to Grace for the wonderful service—friendly, helpful, and made the visit even better. I’ll definitely be back!
Got the ice cream flight with 4 different flavors and a chocolate chip topping. Bitter Sweet Symphony was all our favorite! It had a delicious burnt sugar flavor and although very sparse, the chocolate covered potato chip pieces were wonderful when we did get them. Browned Butter did taste like described, but note it was very light compared to the others. Beenut Butter Swirl had a strong swirl of peanut butter through the honey flavored icecream, note that it was very sweet compared to others because of this combo, and the peanut butter did slightly overpower the other flavors in the flight. Chocolate buttermilk was quite tangy as expected from the description, but the cocoa flavor was less pronounced than I would have hoped for. The chocolate topping was very crunchy, but it doesn’t melt once warmed or taste like chocolate. Overall, all were good and our server was quite nice, she even gave us a recommendation for a chocolate and beenut butter combo.
The basil peach is 10/10 ✨
Man, this place was great! Great ice cream, nice staff, portions are good. It’s expensive, but it’s worth it for what you get. The public space can get crowded and there’s not a public bathroom, but not too big of a deal.
Restaurantji Recommends
If I could give this a 10 star I would we love coming here. Every time we come to Madison we make sure to stop here on our way home. It’s just that good!! they have some unique flavors. The lavender honey comb is my favorite 😍
Some of, if not the best ice cream I've had in Madison. If it was a tiny bit closer, I'd be there every week.
Excellent ice cream. I enjoyed the carmelodramatic
Best ice-cream in Madison!!!!
Adorable shoppe!!! Incredible ice cream… and the cherry on top is the lovely, forward thinking owner and what she does to give back to her community and social causes - win win! 10/10
Loading...