Jersey Mike's Subs

434 Gammon Pl Suite 3, Madison
(608) 841-2160

Recent Reviews

Sort by
TRU LUV

This place is so unorganized. They need to focus on the order in stead of trying to work fast. It was a horrible experience. The one on in Fitchburg is wayyyyy better.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

matt severson

Ordered a #43 Chipotle cheesesteak was given a #42 and has chicken instead of steak on it. Brought it to their attention and one of the girls working was EXTREMELY rude about it. Gave me a terrible attitude and told me it was the same sandwich ummm no it’s not one is chicken one is steak. That’s a pretty big difference to me and for her to act like I was out of pocket to complain is absolutely INSANE! Own your mistakes and make things right or find a different job. Was not offered any type of apology I’ve never been treated like this at this location management needs to fire her.

Service: 1

Pirate Academy

Chloe is so rude and disrespectful. Literally, I asked a simple question which prompted her to go crazy and start cursing me out saying she doesn’t care. She’s about to quit soon.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

DhongDhong Thopten

Best subs ever I had with chicken salad. Super customer service. I enjoyed!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Daniel Fogel

The sandwiches are always fantastic. Always Mike’s Way plus CPR and pickles. Super friendly staff at this location

gl4cial

Might be common knowledge but Jersey Mike’s has consistently been the best sandwich chain by a mile; just brought my girlfriend with celiac today and was greeted with very kindly and they made sure her allergy was well accomodated. And of course, our sandwiches were delicious as well!

Sunera Rahman

All I gotta say is wow. First of all, the best customer service ever. When I walked in, an older gentlemen made sure to greet me as a customer, letting me know they will be with me shortly. I took a few minutes and decided on the club sub Mikes way. Another employee took my order (younger, glasses, mixed) and he was 10/10 customer service. Made great convo while making an even greater sub. He did his job and discussed combo options, bringing it up tactfully. Even more, he made the best sub ever. Give this guy employee of the month. Sub was super fresh and delicious. This location was also clean!

Brandon Shelley

DO NOT ORDER ONLINE! The last two times they gave me 45-50 minute waits, I showed up and they still hadn't started making the food.

Gina Marie

Rude employees. Don’t bother going here.

Angela Howell

My husband, daughter and I went to Jersey Mike's, March 1, 2025. This was are first time with Jersey Mike's. We were very pleased with the service as well as the food. We will be back again.
.

Kiki Martin

I recently went in to get a sub in a tub. After ordering I was standing there waiting for my food. The lettuce that goes in it looked old and a little brown to it. Watching the workers make the sandwiches, I watch a girl wipe her nose not once BUT 3 times with her gloves on that she was making ppls food with. Needless to say I walked out without any food bc that was DISGUSTING. To wipe your nose with gloves you’re make and serving food with is not okay at all. I hope that is addressed. I won’t be back.

Nick S

Great staff great food. Can’t get better than that

Michael Krumm

Food tastes great but the staff is constantly making mistakes. Last time I ordered online it wasn’t ready and took ten minutes after I arrived to be ready. They gave me a free sub card for my trouble. Then when I came in and redeemed the card a worker told me I could use it for a “giant” sub even though the card said regular. So instead of getting sides or any more food I just ordered a giant. Turns out after waiting, they handed me a regular and told me the worker was wrong. They told me if I continued to wait they would make me another, but at that point I had to get back to work. It’s just something, every time. 🤷‍♂️

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 1

Kyle Mcwilliams

This location has got to be the best location of Jersey there is.
Staff is all amazing and helpful. I trust them with big to small orders.
Watched them make recommendations to someone who had never been to Jersey before.
Thank you guys.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Club Supreme, Philly Cheese Steak, Club Sub, The Super Sub

Steve Knapp

I eat at this location frequently and sometimes service is good but it has declined. Waited over 20 mins before going to the store and then another 25 mins at the store for an order ahead when I could have walked in and gotten it in 5 mins going through the line. Checked in with the employees 2 times. That makes no sense! Bread was overcooked dark brown.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Loading...