Ok! This place is really cool!!! If you are looking for a fun spot with great cocktails and awesome pizza near the captiol, this is it!! The Detroit/Wisconsin deep dish was so light and airy with great savory sauce and melty, stretchy cheese is some if not the best around. All the apps and even the neopolitain pizzas were just so good. This place knows food and the unique drinks, just give it an overall fun experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pan, Fried Cedar Grove Cheese Curds
9 Wu
Overpriced. Pizza is dry and too vegetarian focused.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Lisa N.
This place is really cool. Anna C was our server and she was fantastic! She was very accommodating and attentive. We had the pork nachos, a wood fired pizza and flourless brownie. All very tasty but the brownie was excellent. The cocktail menu was really cool but we were here for lunch and didn't have anything this time around. Next time for sure. The place is an old bank and just has a cool vibe with the different levels. Make sure to check out the vault in the basement. We definitely recommend Lucille.
Sydney L.
One of the best date nights spots in Madison! Such a cute vibe in the restaurant & the service never disappoints. The pizza is SO GOOD & so are the various cocktail options.
Evan Liddell
The food here was fantastic, rarely do we see a menu with so many things we would like to try. We settled on the cheese curds and the al pastor pizza which both turned out to be everything we had hoped for and more. Please note that as described this is a Wisconsin take on Detroit style pizza, so if you're expecting a fluffy light crust you will be disappointed. It was however incredibly reminiscent of something you would get at pequods. The cheese curds are not your basic curds and I appreciate that both team ranch and marinara get equal representation here.The cocktail list was another really interesting list, my girlfriend got the special cocktail which was excellent, it had some lingo around rum on it which was a little confusing and even more confusingly was clipped to the mocktail sheet.The beer list wasn't exactly as local as I was hoping (a lot of founders on it...) but I ended up with the barleywine and a truly wonderful and refreshing cyser.We can't wait to go back and try the stromboli, the bruschetta or a red sauce pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Hannah Mountford
This was an awesome place to go for a Friday night dinner as a young couple. Great vibe. They have an awesome beer list and make great cocktails. Portions are also great for sharing. Their take on the Detroit style pizza was very good. Will be going back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Fried Cedar Grove Cheese Curds, Steel Pan
Mike Rhodes
Great pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ally McIntyre
I had read online that this was a good place to go for kids (?) , but my three girls (2, 5, 7) had a tougher time than I expected- they eat okay most of the time when we’re out. But there is no kids menu, they will do a kids pizza only- the complimentary “play dough” is super sweet ! We sat at a community table, beer & pizza was good. We had the massive guac, cheese curds, & pizza. Service was great ? would be much better for a date night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Luke Vander Meer
My wife and I had a great time at the date night! Anna C was a fantastic server - she was attentive, kind, and overall a joy to talk to! The food was delicious, and the date night made it easy for us to try a lot of the menu for a great price. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Guacamole and Chips, Fried Cedar Grove Cheese Curds, Steel Pan
Jordan Gravlin (JGSeliot)
First bite of the Grilled Shrimp Skewer was extremely spicy, but then every bite after that wasn't spicy enough. Wood-fired pizza was pretty good, but the wood smell/taste was very strong on it, making it almost all I could taste on a few bites. The Steel Pan pizzas are better. The cookie dessert I'd one of the best pan cookies I've had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookie, Steel Pan
Service was absolutely the worst! We were the first patrons in the restaurant for lunch, 11am. Didn’t finish our food because we never got refills on drinks to wash it down with. We left 2 hours later! Food was bland but hot at least. Will not be back! Bill was over $124 for 2 people. Outrageous!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
Wesley O.
This place has a lot of promise. The ambiance was fantastic, the servers were wonderful, and the food was conditionally great. Let me expand. I have celiac and must eat gluten free. Our group saw that Lucille offers gluten free crust and decided to go for dinner. We ordered appetizers and a bottle of wine. Everything was great so far. Then comes the pizza. I have to emphasize that there is nothing more disappointing than seeing your friends get a delicious looking pizza while simultaneously being served toppings on a piece of cardboard. The gluten free crust was atrocious. At a seemingly nice establishment such as this, I was expecting more. Lucille, you have missed the mark in one critical way for those of us who must eat gluten free. Please try and find (or make) a better gluten free crust.
Tara Z.
Visited Lucille for "Date Night " with a friend. when scheduling the reservation asked for the table with a video of the capitol as I wanted my friend to have a super awesome view to lift her spirits. We were sat next to it while the table there kept mentioning what a spectacular view and how they hadn't requested it. Live music was playing. We had a great night. Our service was pretty great. The food was tasty. The pizza and strawberry blueberry crisp cooked perfectly. I would recommend on a friends night or date night with partner.
Caiya C.
Very good food with a killer ambiance. Pizza and nachos are good and HUGE and the servers are all attractive, somehow. Eat in!! The food is fresher and the nachos aren't soggy and enjoy that sweet, sweet vibe.
Greg Gersbach (Gersh)
Enjoyed pizza on a Saturday afternoon. Food & service was very good ?.
Ok! This place is really cool!!! If you are looking for a fun spot with great cocktails and awesome pizza near the captiol, this is it!! The Detroit/Wisconsin deep dish was so light and airy with great savory sauce and melty, stretchy cheese is some if not the best around. All the apps and even the neopolitain pizzas were just so good. This place knows food and the unique drinks, just give it an overall fun experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pan, Fried Cedar Grove Cheese Curds
Overpriced. Pizza is dry and too vegetarian focused.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
This place is really cool. Anna C was our server and she was fantastic! She was very accommodating and attentive. We had the pork nachos, a wood fired pizza and flourless brownie. All very tasty but the brownie was excellent. The cocktail menu was really cool but we were here for lunch and didn't have anything this time around. Next time for sure. The place is an old bank and just has a cool vibe with the different levels. Make sure to check out the vault in the basement. We definitely recommend Lucille.
One of the best date nights spots in Madison! Such a cute vibe in the restaurant & the service never disappoints. The pizza is SO GOOD & so are the various cocktail options.
The food here was fantastic, rarely do we see a menu with so many things we would like to try. We settled on the cheese curds and the al pastor pizza which both turned out to be everything we had hoped for and more. Please note that as described this is a Wisconsin take on Detroit style pizza, so if you're expecting a fluffy light crust you will be disappointed. It was however incredibly reminiscent of something you would get at pequods. The cheese curds are not your basic curds and I appreciate that both team ranch and marinara get equal representation here.The cocktail list was another really interesting list, my girlfriend got the special cocktail which was excellent, it had some lingo around rum on it which was a little confusing and even more confusingly was clipped to the mocktail sheet.The beer list wasn't exactly as local as I was hoping (a lot of founders on it...) but I ended up with the barleywine and a truly wonderful and refreshing cyser.We can't wait to go back and try the stromboli, the bruschetta or a red sauce pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
This was an awesome place to go for a Friday night dinner as a young couple. Great vibe. They have an awesome beer list and make great cocktails. Portions are also great for sharing. Their take on the Detroit style pizza was very good. Will be going back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Fried Cedar Grove Cheese Curds, Steel Pan
Great pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had read online that this was a good place to go for kids (?) , but my three girls (2, 5, 7) had a tougher time than I expected- they eat okay most of the time when we’re out. But there is no kids menu, they will do a kids pizza only- the complimentary “play dough” is super sweet ! We sat at a community table, beer & pizza was good. We had the massive guac, cheese curds, & pizza. Service was great ? would be much better for a date night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I had a great time at the date night! Anna C was a fantastic server - she was attentive, kind, and overall a joy to talk to! The food was delicious, and the date night made it easy for us to try a lot of the menu for a great price. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Guacamole and Chips, Fried Cedar Grove Cheese Curds, Steel Pan
First bite of the Grilled Shrimp Skewer was extremely spicy, but then every bite after that wasn't spicy enough. Wood-fired pizza was pretty good, but the wood smell/taste was very strong on it, making it almost all I could taste on a few bites. The Steel Pan pizzas are better. The cookie dessert I'd one of the best pan cookies I've had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookie, Steel Pan
Restaurantji Recommends
Service was absolutely the worst! We were the first patrons in the restaurant for lunch, 11am. Didn’t finish our food because we never got refills on drinks to wash it down with. We left 2 hours later! Food was bland but hot at least. Will not be back! Bill was over $124 for 2 people. Outrageous!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
This place has a lot of promise. The ambiance was fantastic, the servers were wonderful, and the food was conditionally great. Let me expand. I have celiac and must eat gluten free. Our group saw that Lucille offers gluten free crust and decided to go for dinner. We ordered appetizers and a bottle of wine. Everything was great so far. Then comes the pizza. I have to emphasize that there is nothing more disappointing than seeing your friends get a delicious looking pizza while simultaneously being served toppings on a piece of cardboard. The gluten free crust was atrocious. At a seemingly nice establishment such as this, I was expecting more. Lucille, you have missed the mark in one critical way for those of us who must eat gluten free. Please try and find (or make) a better gluten free crust.
Visited Lucille for "Date Night " with a friend. when scheduling the reservation asked for the table with a video of the capitol as I wanted my friend to have a super awesome view to lift her spirits. We were sat next to it while the table there kept mentioning what a spectacular view and how they hadn't requested it. Live music was playing. We had a great night. Our service was pretty great. The food was tasty. The pizza and strawberry blueberry crisp cooked perfectly. I would recommend on a friends night or date night with partner.
Very good food with a killer ambiance. Pizza and nachos are good and HUGE and the servers are all attractive, somehow. Eat in!! The food is fresher and the nachos aren't soggy and enjoy that sweet, sweet vibe.
Enjoyed pizza on a Saturday afternoon. Food & service was very good ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5