We enjoyed our dinner here. We had originally made our reservation for outside seating. When we arrived we found out they had closed this due to heat. That was a bummer but we still enjoyed. Recommend making a reservation. We sat outside while we waited for our food. We were told To follow the path along building which was by the overflowing dumpsters. Not a great first impression but thankfully once seated food was very good. We all loved our food and drinks. Our waitress did great and had a large area to cover so we did have to wait for things but they were pretty busy this evening. Sad to hear they are closing this August
Bonnie
Wish the place wasn't closing, maybe another hotel and restaurant in the works we were told.
Patricia Ruble
The food is always great. We will be sad when they close, we've been going here for many years.
Janet Hanson
Perfect evening outdoors.
Elizabeth E
The waitress was really nice, and we were seated quickly. The menu for seafood limited. They are supposed to be known for their steaks but their pricing was more for a steakhouse. When they say they’ve been around since ‘66, nothing looks like it has changed since then. This is not lakeside dining. Felt more like stuff put together not cooking. Not bad, but not good. Certainly not like the photos.
Elizabeth
The waitress was really nice, and we were seated quickly. The menu for seafood limited. They are supposed to be known for their steaks but their pricing was more for a steakhouse. When they say they've been around since ‘66, nothing looks like it has changed since then. This is not lakeside dining. Felt more like stuff put together not cooking. Not bad, but not good.
Joel Fugere
Very good menu, the front of the house bar is a little in the way but not terrible, the interior is older but good old and well maintained, unfortunately we were told that it will be closing soon, to be turned into some apartments, a marina and a bar.
Donna
One of the greats! Sad that they are retiring after 8/30. Make sure you take advantage of the time left that they are open. My Dad enjoyed his Father's Day meal immensely. We all did and Hailey was great! I recommend the Stuffed Mushroom Combo, Mariner's Shrimp, Steer Tenderloin, and an ice cream drink for dessert.
Paul Herford
Chose this place as an early Father’s Day dinner with the parents and grandma. Service was punctual, having us seated within a couple minutes of our reservation time. Waitresses were pleasant and attentive, and the food- incredible. (These pumpernickel steakhouse rolls are on another level!)
Great experience with the parents, perfect atmosphere, and quality establishment all around.
This Madison Supper Club never disappoints. Our meals were excellent as always, and our servers at the bar and at our table were very friendly and attentive. Thank you for another wonderful meal, Mariner's!
craig
I was dissapointed to say the least. Best part of the meal was the Brandy old fashioned. Who came up with the menu, should be let go. This place was once highly thought of. It is now a memory for most. Had I known , I would have never spent my hard earned money here. Two out of 5 meals were cold , they should of at least been warm. Do not waste your money on the overpriced au gratin potatoes. They were basically lumpy mashed potatoes covered in cheese. Upon walking in ,the place had a funky musty smell. Save your money and eat anywhere else. Never again, even for free.
Peter Liu
I just came today for hope class from gateway middleton church for the boat ride in memory of the passing of erin light our long time hope class attendee
Ken
Old WI supper club style restaurant next to small boat marina. Drinks were great but food was pricey and not exceptional. Good service and nice staff. If the dinners were worth the price it would have 4 stars, but they were not.
Great Shrimp 🍤 dinner
We enjoyed our dinner here. We had originally made our reservation for outside seating. When we arrived we found out they had closed this due to heat. That was a bummer but we still enjoyed. Recommend making a reservation. We sat outside while we waited for our food. We were told To follow the path along building which was by the overflowing dumpsters. Not a great first impression but thankfully once seated food was very good. We all loved our food and drinks. Our waitress did great and had a large area to cover so we did have to wait for things but they were pretty busy this evening. Sad to hear they are closing this August
Wish the place wasn't closing, maybe another hotel and restaurant in the works we were told.
The food is always great. We will be sad when they close, we've been going here for many years.
Perfect evening outdoors.
The waitress was really nice, and we were seated quickly. The menu for seafood limited. They are supposed to be known for their steaks but their pricing was more for a steakhouse. When they say they’ve been around since ‘66, nothing looks like it has changed since then. This is not lakeside dining. Felt more like stuff put together not cooking. Not bad, but not good. Certainly not like the photos.
The waitress was really nice, and we were seated quickly. The menu for seafood limited. They are supposed to be known for their steaks but their pricing was more for a steakhouse. When they say they've been around since ‘66, nothing looks like it has changed since then. This is not lakeside dining. Felt more like stuff put together not cooking. Not bad, but not good.
Very good menu, the front of the house bar is a little in the way but not terrible, the interior is older but good old and well maintained, unfortunately we were told that it will be closing soon, to be turned into some apartments, a marina and a bar.
One of the greats! Sad that they are retiring after 8/30. Make sure you take advantage of the time left that they are open. My Dad enjoyed his Father's Day meal immensely. We all did and Hailey was great! I recommend the Stuffed Mushroom Combo, Mariner's Shrimp, Steer Tenderloin, and an ice cream drink for dessert.
Chose this place as an early Father’s Day dinner with the parents and grandma. Service was punctual, having us seated within a couple minutes of our reservation time. Waitresses were pleasant and attentive, and the food- incredible. (These pumpernickel steakhouse rolls are on another level!)
Great experience with the parents, perfect atmosphere, and quality establishment all around.
Restaurantji Recommends
This Madison Supper Club never disappoints. Our meals were excellent as always, and our servers at the bar and at our table were very friendly and attentive. Thank you for another wonderful meal, Mariner's!
I was dissapointed to say the least. Best part of the meal was the Brandy old fashioned. Who came up with the menu, should be let go. This place was once highly thought of. It is now a memory for most. Had I known , I would have never spent my hard earned money here. Two out of 5 meals were cold , they should of at least been warm. Do not waste your money on the overpriced au gratin potatoes. They were basically lumpy mashed potatoes covered in cheese. Upon walking in ,the place had a funky musty smell. Save your money and eat anywhere else. Never again, even for free.
I just came today for hope class from gateway middleton church for the boat ride in memory of the passing of erin light our long time hope class attendee
Old WI supper club style restaurant next to small boat marina. Drinks were great but food was pricey and not exceptional. Good service and nice staff. If the dinners were worth the price it would have 4 stars, but they were not.
Sad to hear they are closing late this fall.😒
Loading...