Otto's Restaurant & Bar

6405 Mineral Point Rd, Madison
(608) 274-4044

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Stefanie

Otto's is always consistently good. The menu doesn't change so you know what to expect. The service is always exceptional.

Cris

We enjoyed our dinner. The sea bass was delicious. Our waitress was friendly. Will definitely return.

Nita

We have always enjoyed our meals at Otto's, and our dinner last night did not disappoint. If I had to nitpick, I would love for there to be another vegetarian option on the menu. I love the pasta, but we limit our visits to Otto's so as not to burn out on the one vegetarian option (excluding salads, of course). Our server was delightful... helpful but not intrusive. Thanks for a thoroughly enjoyable meal.

Pam

I miss the strawberry napoleon that used to be on the dessert menu. Food was great as was service.

Tim

Early 5:30 dinner on New Year's Eve. Service was outstanding, A imited menu night. but the food was tasty and resaonably priced. Only issue was a party of 10 near our table in which two women tried to loudly out talk each other from opposite ends of the table. Once they left, ambience was excellent.

Janice

There were 5 of us and we all loved our meals. The lamb chops, salmon, and other beef and fish dishes were all excellent. We will definitely eat there again.

David

Much of the downside of this review has to do with the location of our table: by the entrance, check-in, kitchen, stairs. Very busy, noisy and distracting. Our service was very good. Our food was delicious: soup, seafood trio, lambchops, pasta, but over salted. One of our party has celiac, and the menu was very well labeled. The wine was excellent. We will be back, but will request a quieter table, and ask for no-salt-added to the food.

Glenn

Familiar local place we've been going to for decades. Food, drinks and service were excellent. Great place to go for its welcoming atmosphere and good food.

Thomas

This survey is annoying because initially I wrote 49 characters and it requires 50 or more. So instead of writing about my experience at the restaurant I'm writing to complain about this silly survey requirement.

Charles

We enjoyed the Chef's tasting menu with the wine pairing. The food and wine pairing were excellent.

Kate

We love Otto's. We probably go two or three times a year for special dinners, and it's always fantastic. Everything we've ever ordered has been excellent--the lamb and duck are both favorites of ours, but the mussels, Mediterranean platter, salads, risotto, and others are also excellent.

J

Our entrees were delicious and service was excellent. This restaurant chef and the team knows how to make and serve great meals.

KELLEY

We have been to the restaurant several times and it is our favorite restaurant! The food and service is terrific and the ambiance is perfect. We will continue to be a repeat customer.

Barbara

All of us love this special restaurant. It is well-established and is located in a remodeled vintage house that has several separate rooms for dining. We chose to celebrate our three birthdays there this year. The menu selections never disappoint. The food choices are high-quality and presented very beautifully. My friends had the seafood platter and I had scallops on risotto. The menu changes regularly which reflects local seasonal options. Everything about our server was a delight. She was well-versed in the details of each dish, she was attentive to our requests and was thoroughly enjoyable to talk with. For dessert we all chose the crème brûlée, which was deliciously rich and just the right size! I would recommend this restaurant for any occasion!

joe

We had three appetizers. My wife had the calamari half cooked perfectly other half not so much. Shrimp appetizer was great. Seared scallops salad really good except the two scallops got lost in the salad,for $31 needs more scallops. Little pricey Don't live in the area but nothing here would bring me back

Loading...