Came up for our anniversary. Loved the trout, and appetizers prior (seafood stack and oysters). Service was excellent until the end when we had another customer’s charges added to ours and we had to catch the error. Overall great food and atmosphere and we would return.
Sea Williams
My favorite place in town I hope everyone gets the best waitress there I don't remember her name but she is always singing and full of life
Alex Dinh
Great service and ambiance. Oysters were delicious and so was the cod that I had.
Jade Jhocson
Did a large party of 7 and loved the whole thing
Carlos Orozco
I wish I could leave a much higher review. I came here for my rehearsal dinner for a reservation at 7:15 PM and we weren’t seated until 8:15 PM. Some of my family ended up leaving before we were seated because they had to go and take care of their child. I was very disappointed with the little acknowledgment that we were given when we brought up our concern that we needed to wait an hour for a reservation that we had made. The manager never spoke to us about this, even though we spoke to our waitress about this. I know I’m posting this a a little late, but I thought it would be good for others to know that if you have a reservation on a Friday night that you will most likely have to wait a really long time. I had made my reservation weeks in advance, and I even called the restaurant ahead of time to let them know that this was my wedding rehearsal dinner. I am very disappointed with the lack of service.
Monyka L
Food was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!! Service was spectacular too. The happy hour price on oysters was such a steal ($2 per oyster).
Pictured below is their daily special for Monday, April 14th 2025 which are the black cod (dish with the red fish roe on top and broth on bottom), corvina (dish with the yellow purée and the orange colored fish), and rainbow trout (has sage brown butter sauce and vegetables on the side).
Jacob Marty
This is my go to spot as an out of towner, every birthday my wife and I have a tradition of getting oysters. Happy hour is a great deal as well. They’ve also been very supportive of local initiatives and charity events so I can’t recommend supporting them enough!
Carly Epping
A Madison FAVORITE for us. Every time we go we get amazing service, excellent food, and the cutest table for two. They have a great selection of N/A beverages on top of a killer bar menu. Happy hour deals are also excellent.
July B
Tempest Oyster Bar offers a truly exceptional dining experience in the heart of Madison. From the moment we walked in, the service was attentive, friendly, and professional. The atmosphere is welcoming, with just the right balance of elegance and comfort.
The food was outstanding. I ordered the 8 oz tenderloin steak, and it was cooked to perfection—tender, juicy, and exactly as requested. The side dish of asparagus was equally impressive—neither dry nor overcooked, but vibrant and flavorful.
Michael Pritchard
We had a wonderful dinner here with Eva taking exceptional care of us. The Crème Caramel, Conch Fritters, and my Navy Pea Coat cocktail were a particular highlight for us. We will definitely be back!! Thanks
Fantastic service!!! Bartenders have been the same for years and our the best! A must stop in Madison! Love being in the shell just better keep your voice down🤔🤣
Andy Marquardt
Another nice upscale Madison establishment.
Alvin Chen
Must try the key lime pie! Omg it’s so good
Robert Snider
Excellent oysters!
Amanda Leggett
I enjoyed the scallops, shrimp, and grits. It was delicious and the ambience was very nice.
Came up for our anniversary. Loved the trout, and appetizers prior (seafood stack and oysters). Service was excellent until the end when we had another customer’s charges added to ours and we had to catch the error. Overall great food and atmosphere and we would return.
My favorite place in town I hope everyone gets the best waitress there I don't remember her name but she is always singing and full of life
Great service and ambiance. Oysters were delicious and so was the cod that I had.
Did a large party of 7 and loved the whole thing
I wish I could leave a much higher review. I came here for my rehearsal dinner for a reservation at 7:15 PM and we weren’t seated until 8:15 PM. Some of my family ended up leaving before we were seated because they had to go and take care of their child. I was very disappointed with the little acknowledgment that we were given when we brought up our concern that we needed to wait an hour for a reservation that we had made. The manager never spoke to us about this, even though we spoke to our waitress about this. I know I’m posting this a a little late, but I thought it would be good for others to know that if you have a reservation on a Friday night that you will most likely have to wait a really long time. I had made my reservation weeks in advance, and I even called the restaurant ahead of time to let them know that this was my wedding rehearsal dinner. I am very disappointed with the lack of service.
Food was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!! Service was spectacular too. The happy hour price on oysters was such a steal ($2 per oyster).
Pictured below is their daily special for Monday, April 14th 2025 which are the black cod (dish with the red fish roe on top and broth on bottom), corvina (dish with the yellow purée and the orange colored fish), and rainbow trout (has sage brown butter sauce and vegetables on the side).
This is my go to spot as an out of towner, every birthday my wife and I have a tradition of getting oysters. Happy hour is a great deal as well. They’ve also been very supportive of local initiatives and charity events so I can’t recommend supporting them enough!
A Madison FAVORITE for us. Every time we go we get amazing service, excellent food, and the cutest table for two. They have a great selection of N/A beverages on top of a killer bar menu. Happy hour deals are also excellent.
Tempest Oyster Bar offers a truly exceptional dining experience in the heart of Madison. From the moment we walked in, the service was attentive, friendly, and professional. The atmosphere is welcoming, with just the right balance of elegance and comfort.
The food was outstanding. I ordered the 8 oz tenderloin steak, and it was cooked to perfection—tender, juicy, and exactly as requested. The side dish of asparagus was equally impressive—neither dry nor overcooked, but vibrant and flavorful.
We had a wonderful dinner here with Eva taking exceptional care of us. The Crème Caramel, Conch Fritters, and my Navy Pea Coat cocktail were a particular highlight for us. We will definitely be back!! Thanks
Restaurantji Recommends
Fantastic service!!! Bartenders have been the same for years and our the best! A must stop in Madison! Love being in the shell just better keep your voice down🤔🤣
Another nice upscale Madison establishment.
Must try the key lime pie! Omg it’s so good
Excellent oysters!
I enjoyed the scallops, shrimp, and grits. It was delicious and the ambience was very nice.
Loading...