The Wonder Bar

222 E Olin Ave, Madison
(608) 256-9430

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Patti Ferrell

Always a favorite. Great ambiance. Great service. Great tasty food. It's a historic place.

Aaron Eicher

Whatever I write, I won't be able to do this place justice. One of the last remaining Madison gems is the Wonder Bar, and what a wondrous place it is. Want delicious food? Wonder Bar. Wanna take a step back in time? Wonder Bar. This is your go to Steakhouse in Madison, truly a hidden gem that I have had the pleasure of dining at.

Kim Wieczorek

Food was good, service was a little slow!

Erika R

Over the past 10 years we visit here each year for a special occasion. This past visit was not the same. For having very few people in there (limited capacity) the service was not great and the food was very disappointing. Not sure if they have a new chef but the food was not at all what it was on our previous visits. I loved the crab bisque in the past and it was not even close to what it was. The dressing on the wedge salad was chunky and overly sweet. The fish I ordered was not great either. The rolls were dense and bland. The best part of the meal was the asparagus. Overall, the food is unfortunately not what it used to be.

pat mcnamar

Chilean Seabass was pure gold tonight!

Jarod Richter

This place is a gem in the current day and age we live in. You get this sense of nostalgia and out-of-bodiness upon entering the place, like "what year is it!?"The food was superb, best oyster Rockefeller I've had in a while (it's the bacon), medium rare steak on point, the whole 9, yall.Overall, this place is a fore runner on my return list. We had a great time!

Ryan Zagrodnik

Steak brah. Steak.

Jamie Adams

Great food and very friendly, efficient staff!! Well run establishment!

Bruce Larson

It was one of the worst steaks i have ever had

Chris Angell

Great steaks, loved the scallops and BBQ prawns

Patrick Depies

Great atmosphere and great food. Really hope they make it through this pandemic!

Emily Sobiek

As always, everything was perfect. Even with this present, crazy world.

Graham H

The place serves large dishes and for reasonable rates. kind staff. 5 stars from me.

Brian Witsaman

top quality food, historic building, great meeting place and to have dinner. one of my "go to" restaurants when in town. must try filet and blackened scallops.

Amber Ring

I've been to Wonder Bar several times and I always enjoy the atmosphere and food!A few months ago I actually had a small wedding dinner at the Wonder Bar and it was perfect! The manager / head bartender (I believe Brian was his name), was so great to work with. I had made some changes to the number of people attending and he made it work! Additionally, we had 5 small children there and they even offered to get food from The Coliseum next door - so the kids could have their chicken fingers, pizza, etc. So please with the experience we had at Wonder Bar!

Loading...