The Nest Eatery, LLC
40 S Main St, Mayville
(920) 644-2020
Customers' Favorites
Hummus Bliss Bowl Salad
Miso Smoked Eggs And
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Bread Board
New BBQ
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Very nice workers who are attentive and helpful. We had a complex order and the guy repeated it back a few times just to make sure it was perfect with no mistakes. The place is very clean, has games, and has a diverse menu. We ordered a supreme pizza, cheese, pepperoni, and the Big Dill. We got both crusts and they were nothing short of amazing and absolute perfection. I will definitely be back. So glad I found this little spot! Best pizza in the dodge county area!
Food was absolutely delicious, we were a party of 6 and not one of our dishes was anything less than amazing. We live an hour and a half away and are already trying to figure out a way we can get back there to get more of their delicious bread. The butter board with curry and raspberry butters was absolutely stunning. Can't recommend highly enough!
In town to golf and a Halloween party (yes, we were tourists in Mayville) and after reading reviews here we tried The Nest Eatery for lunch and so glad we did. Going to put this place in our top three places ever for sandwiches! We did the May-Fuletta and the Bahn-May. Perfect bread, not too dry or chewy, perfect sauces that had amazing flavors, and nice amount of meats. Knocked it out of the park! Staff was helpful and kind. This is a must go-to if you’re looking for delicious...
You May Also Like
The Open Door Coffeehouse - 20 S Main St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Internet Cafe, Coffee
Don Ramon Mexican Restaurant - 39 S Main St
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian
The Natural Way - 35 S Main St
![]()
Health Food, Health Markets, Cosmetics & Beauty Supply