Prime Time Bar And Grill

1150 Valley Rd, Menasha
(920) 734-4413

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Karen Tritt

Great staff

Jeff Huss

Great pizza and poppers

Carol Buss

We have been looking for a good Friday fish fry. We have found it! Especially like I can get a half order of broiled haddock.

Von Critique

Closed on a Saturday afternoon???

Justin Schultz

Great place for a quick drink. Bartenders we kind an quick to serve, food was excellent

Shane Thoms (Darkwing Duck)

04/10/25 - At the end of trivia, don't bring a bill. That tells people to leave! You worked hard to get them in the place.
11/25/24 - Still good food and great service. However they allow vaping in the bar, even though it's posted otherwise.
2017 - Nice classic Wisconsin bar.

Sam Gaines

Just had a fantastic burger/brat combo sandwich. truly exceptional. wonderful staff. 5 stars Sammy

Scott Ebel

The fish fry was amazing I’m not a tarter sauce guy but it was delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brenda Blair

Friendly staff, food was ok. Nice neighborhood stop.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Djon Man

Wow!

I heard the fish was great, but so was everything else on my plate.
Hot flavorful fries…try all 3! Sweet potato fries with honey mustard, beer battered, or waffle fries. I never eat coleslaw or rye bread, but both of these were fresh and tasty!

Shared Walleye and haddock…both served hot, tender and juicy. I prefer real butter to dip the fish…but hey, can’t have it all.

Service was friendly, fun, personal and efficient. Atmosphere is eclectic, colorful and energetic. And not too loud for conversation.

I never write reviews, but just had to after this wonderful Friday night existence!! Can’t wait to return.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

jason hazuga

Friday night fish fry was amazing! Service was prompt. Food came fast, hot and delicious. The honey mustard is to die for. Tammy is an outstanding waitress with such a fun personality. Would highly recommend checking this place out. Will be back for sure!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Doug

Wow!

I heard the fish was great, but so was everything else on my plate.
Hot flavorful fries…try all 3! Sweet potato fries with honey mustard, beer battered, or waffle fries. I never eat coleslaw or rye bread, but both of these were fresh and tasty!

Shared Walleye and haddock…both served hot, tender and juicy. I prefer real butter to dip the fish…but hey, can’t have it all.

Service was friendly, fun, personal and efficient. Atmosphere is eclectic, colorful and energetic. And not too loud for conversation.

I never write reviews, but just had to after this wonderful Friday night existence!! Can’t wait to return.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Doug Manderfield

Wow! I heard the fish was great, but so was everything else on my plate. Hot flavorful fries…try all 3! Sweet potato fries with honey mustard, beer battered, or waffle fries. I never eat coleslaw or rye bread, but both of these were fresh and tasty! Shared Walleye and haddock…both served hot, tender and juicy. I prefer real butter to dip the fish…but hey, can’t have it all. Service was friendly, fun, personal and efficient. Atmosphere is eclectic, colorful and energetic. And not too loud for conversation. I never write reviews, but just had to after this wonderful Friday night experience!! Can’t wait to return.

Jason Hazuga

Friday night fish fry was amazing! Service was prompt. Food came fast, hot and delicious. The honey mustard is to die for. Tammy is an outstanding waitress with such a fun personality. Would highly recommend checking this place out. Will be back for sure!

James Whitmore

Friendly owners and bartenders (especially Jamie - she did a great job taking care of us at Table #15) - fair and reasonable prices - and the food was great!

Loading...