De Marinis Pizzeria

Went for a pizza on Sunday night around 7:30pm. We’ve been going to DeMarini’s for years and this will probably be last time. We sat at a table in the bar area. Server was nice. We ordered a couple of Sprite’s an order of garlic bread and a pizza. Garlic bread was slightly burnt but edible. The pizza came out in about 15 minutes and I asked for a refill on my soda. The waiter told me he had to charge me for another beverage if I wanted a refill. The glass was packed with ice, so there wasn’t much room for the soda they are charging $2.50 for. The biggest issue was the fact the bartender had given control of the sound system to what appeared to be a customer and he was playing music off his phone. I think there were 4 or 5 military chanting songs that were played and a rather loud volume level. We’ve never had an experience like this here before. It was very disappointing.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 4

Love this place. Great food. Classic atmosphere

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A.Y.C.E spaghetti was bland and meatball had no flavor. I was disappointed.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

ordered take out yesterday. pizzas are smaller than what is advertised. ordered a mix of chicken wings. half spicy and half not. they put them all together. couldn't tell which was which. pizzas were not cooked long enough. Not as good as it used to be.

Easily my favorite pizza place. I get takeout pizza often here, and it’s always done on time and done well. I’ve never actually sat at the bar or been served in the restaurant area, so can’t comment on that, but their pizza takeout is easily the best in the area. Pizza Hut? Nasty. Dominos? Expensive. Toppers? Overrated.

Demarinis? Awesome.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We probably should have gotten the pizza, but we ordered the mostaccoli with meat sauce and spaghetti with meatballs. The pasta and sauce were very bland with little flavor. The chicken parmesean was good, but I don't recommend getting the non pizza food items to go. It was packaged poorly in either Styrofoam or shoved in plastic cylinders. We had tried Pepino's up the road prior and it was hands down better. If you're in the mood for authentic pasta and flavor. I recommend up the road instead.

Awful food my pizza was horrible I wish I could show my pictures of the pizza

Very incredible pizza. Ordered extra sauce and well done as we always do, and to our surprise, .... Extra sauce and well done! WTG staff. Very friendly and fast server! Reasonable price as well

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered take out. Pizza was just okay, but did not seem fresh. Cheese curds seemed very old and dry like they had been under a heat lamp for hours.

Food: 3

Best pizza in Menomonee Falls by far! We’ve been coming here for years and highly recommend!

Great food.

Pizza not the best, but their other food is fantastic!

Eggplant 🍆 was very good and pizza 🍕 is very good with a great sauce. ( The thing I love someone makes a shitty review and show photos and the pizza is 75% gone come on they'd make it over if you have a concern. Awesome place staff to owners care about it. You want a pizza with eggplant and a drink with amazing customer service you got it 💯😎🍆🍕❤️

The pizzas always delicious and the egg plant was delicious too.

Has anyone working at your restaurant ever had a good pizza to at least set a baseline? First suggestion START OVER with a new recipe. The crust should be outlawed. The sausage should be sent to Italy for remedial flavor training. Sauce ? What sause? Cheese? try some from Wisconsin. Not even a slight hint of Italian seasoning in any of it. Onions as a topping?... minced and hard to find. Umm... Try Zaffiros or even Jack's and start over.