Excellent restaurant. The food, prices, and service were top-notch. The breakfast was great. The eggs were cooked to perfection. Visited for dinner, and the burger was fantastic. Nothing fancy, but the meat was fresh and tasty. Honestly, it's one of the best I've ever had (and I consider myself a bit of a burger snob lol). The service staff were attentive and friendly. I visited 3 times and consistently had a great experience. At first glance, this place just looks like a standard hotel restaurant, but don't judge the book by the cover! Check this place out. You will not be disappointed! I will definitely visit again when I'm in the area!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Russell W.
While the restaurant is nice, the value for cost is just not there. They have great wraps and sandwiches, but the very limited and niche menu isn't very enticing. If you are a Friday fish fry person, there are better places especially for the price.
Greg B.
I stopped at Allgauer's to get some menu pictures and decide if I was eating a fish fry alone or if my family was going to come and meet me based on their non-fish options. Apparently I haven't been to Allgauer's in forever because it's February 2024 and they stopped doing the all you can eat fish fry around April 2023. What a shame cause it was pretty good and there are so few all you can eat places left. The hostess joked with me that the restaurant was empty when I got there because of that change, but there was a lot of honesty in what she was saying because I was the only one there at 5:20pm when it used to be packed right after opening. They did have something my picky kid would eat, so the family ended up meeting me for dinner. I ordered the half pound of beer battered lake perch with two pieces of fried cod for an extra $3 charge each, my wife got and older kid got cheeseburgers, and the picky kid got a kid's grilled cheese. My youngest liked his grilled cheese because we specifically asked for American cheese on it. The hostess believed it came with cheddar and we knew he wouldn't eat that. The older kid and my wife were impressed by the cheeseburgers. They weren't anything fancy, but they had really good flavor and were cooked medium-well like they wanted. I didn't love the cod, but the perch was fantastic. The pieces were small so I was given nine instead of the five I was told I would normally get for a half pound. That's okay cause I'd rather have more small pieces than fewer large pieces if the small ones taste like lake perch should and aren't bland. We all got crinkled fries, which isn't my favorite, but they weren't bad as far as crinkle fries go. By the time we left almost an hour later close to a dozen other people had come in. Certainly not the hopping place it was when they had the all you can eat fish fry, but not empty either. Even without the AYCE, we'll probably come back.
Ryan Beres
Hair in food, potatoes cold and steak seasoning was full of salt.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Catharine Schmadl
Dietary restrictions: Good with gluten-free fish
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips
Michael Shortt
Great fish fry!Dietary restrictions: Girlfriend has gluten and soy restrictions and she still enjoyed it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Friday All-You-Can-Eat Fish Fry
Lisa Taylor
Clam chowder seemed old. Microwaved and still not hot. Clumpy congealed. fish fry small and no flavor. Rye bread was stale. Not worth $20. Never again
Dan M.
Look - this place doesn't have so much but is well rounded. I recommend the burger (believe it or not) med rare. Wings are good - pricey for 7 - ask for them crispy. And wonton cheese stix are a bonus. Wish they bring back the caprese salad - please! Breakfast however has changed and between dry toast and not so great morning service id choose elsewhere. They need to get the act together with the team at hilton garden. Noone has time to sit and order breakfast then wait around for it to come to your table. Do they? I dont. Just sayn
Sheri Zetting
We have been going here for years for the Friday night fish fry buffet and it was wonderful. A few weeks ago when we went, they discontinued the buffet and now have fish entree. 2 small pieces of fish with French fries and dried rye bread is not worth $18. Won't be returning.
*No more fish fry buffet. Food is okay. Service is friendly. Without the buffet, there’s not much to make it stand out. Disappointed.Great all-you-can eat fish fry buffet! It includes salads, soup, baked & fried fish, potato pancakes, & rye bread.
Nicole Hutcherson
I love there Friday fish fry and the staff is always so friendly and nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chowder
kam2057
One of the best burgers I ever had!
Weston P.
Food was cold and lack favor. The restaurant has transitioned to a buffet. The servers were wonderful.
shaun w
Excellent food staff fantastic Sunday carvery beautiful plus you can still order off main menu also on a Sunday
Awesome, just
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent restaurant. The food, prices, and service were top-notch. The breakfast was great. The eggs were cooked to perfection. Visited for dinner, and the burger was fantastic. Nothing fancy, but the meat was fresh and tasty. Honestly, it's one of the best I've ever had (and I consider myself a bit of a burger snob lol). The service staff were attentive and friendly. I visited 3 times and consistently had a great experience. At first glance, this place just looks like a standard hotel restaurant, but don't judge the book by the cover! Check this place out. You will not be disappointed! I will definitely visit again when I'm in the area!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
While the restaurant is nice, the value for cost is just not there. They have great wraps and sandwiches, but the very limited and niche menu isn't very enticing. If you are a Friday fish fry person, there are better places especially for the price.
I stopped at Allgauer's to get some menu pictures and decide if I was eating a fish fry alone or if my family was going to come and meet me based on their non-fish options. Apparently I haven't been to Allgauer's in forever because it's February 2024 and they stopped doing the all you can eat fish fry around April 2023. What a shame cause it was pretty good and there are so few all you can eat places left. The hostess joked with me that the restaurant was empty when I got there because of that change, but there was a lot of honesty in what she was saying because I was the only one there at 5:20pm when it used to be packed right after opening. They did have something my picky kid would eat, so the family ended up meeting me for dinner. I ordered the half pound of beer battered lake perch with two pieces of fried cod for an extra $3 charge each, my wife got and older kid got cheeseburgers, and the picky kid got a kid's grilled cheese. My youngest liked his grilled cheese because we specifically asked for American cheese on it. The hostess believed it came with cheddar and we knew he wouldn't eat that. The older kid and my wife were impressed by the cheeseburgers. They weren't anything fancy, but they had really good flavor and were cooked medium-well like they wanted. I didn't love the cod, but the perch was fantastic. The pieces were small so I was given nine instead of the five I was told I would normally get for a half pound. That's okay cause I'd rather have more small pieces than fewer large pieces if the small ones taste like lake perch should and aren't bland. We all got crinkled fries, which isn't my favorite, but they weren't bad as far as crinkle fries go. By the time we left almost an hour later close to a dozen other people had come in. Certainly not the hopping place it was when they had the all you can eat fish fry, but not empty either. Even without the AYCE, we'll probably come back.
Hair in food, potatoes cold and steak seasoning was full of salt.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Dietary restrictions: Good with gluten-free fish
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips
Great fish fry!Dietary restrictions: Girlfriend has gluten and soy restrictions and she still enjoyed it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Friday All-You-Can-Eat Fish Fry
Clam chowder seemed old. Microwaved and still not hot. Clumpy congealed. fish fry small and no flavor. Rye bread was stale. Not worth $20. Never again
Look - this place doesn't have so much but is well rounded. I recommend the burger (believe it or not) med rare. Wings are good - pricey for 7 - ask for them crispy. And wonton cheese stix are a bonus. Wish they bring back the caprese salad - please! Breakfast however has changed and between dry toast and not so great morning service id choose elsewhere. They need to get the act together with the team at hilton garden. Noone has time to sit and order breakfast then wait around for it to come to your table. Do they? I dont. Just sayn
We have been going here for years for the Friday night fish fry buffet and it was wonderful. A few weeks ago when we went, they discontinued the buffet and now have fish entree. 2 small pieces of fish with French fries and dried rye bread is not worth $18. Won't be returning.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
*No more fish fry buffet. Food is okay. Service is friendly. Without the buffet, there’s not much to make it stand out. Disappointed.Great all-you-can eat fish fry buffet! It includes salads, soup, baked & fried fish, potato pancakes, & rye bread.
I love there Friday fish fry and the staff is always so friendly and nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chowder
One of the best burgers I ever had!
Food was cold and lack favor. The restaurant has transitioned to a buffet. The servers were wonderful.
Excellent food staff fantastic Sunday carvery beautiful plus you can still order off main menu also on a Sunday