Classic Slice
2797 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee
(414) 238-2406
Customers' Favorites
Spinach and Cheese Pizza Slice
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Mac N Cheese Pizza Slice
Slice of Sausage Pizza
Detroit Pepperoni 8x10
Vegan Mke Pizza Slice
Pizza and Garlic Knots
Meatball Sandwich
Gluten Free Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Menu
Photos
+29 photos
+28 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I'm originally from NY, and this is the closest to NY style pizza I've found out here. Very authentic Brooklyn style. Tastes delicious, great service and very reasonably priced.
Went there yesterday 9/25/2025 with a friend and I fall in love with the marina meatballs. The flavor super good. Pizza delicious, garlic knot oh my God everything was delicious. Even the lemonade from the machine was tasty. 10/10. My friend thank me. Oooh and that big chocolate chip caramel cookie😋😋😋
The absolute best Pizza in Milwaukee especially if you just want a slice and especially to take out of town friends to or a cheap cute date. Just don't tell them the slice is going to be bigger than their head and watch the surprise on their faces when they get this freaky big slice of the tastiest NY style pizza outside of actual New York. My favorite is the Meatalica.
You May Also Like
Patti's Power Plant - 2800 S Kinnickinnic Ave
![]()
Bar, Dive Bar, Music Venues
Happy Dough Lucky Donuts + Arcade - 2691 S Kinnickinnic Ave
![]()
Donuts, Caterers, Coffee & Tea
No. 1 Chinese Restaurant - 2678 S Kinnickinnic Ave
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian