Classy Girl Cupcakes

825 N Jefferson St, Milwaukee
(414) 270-1877

Recent Reviews

Kristina L Pagel

All I can say is that there was a hair in our gluten free cupcake. Gross. No seating to eat there, or we would have complained.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Zola Yi

Classy Girl Cupcakes is amazing! My office has ordered from them multiple times over the past two years for staff birthdays, and are always impressed with the quality, aesthetic, and professionalism. We have requested some unique custom cakes (such as a Sephora Bag, Pancakes Cake, Giant Sushi Roll, and a Leapfrog cake), and the Classy Girl Cupcakes team always promptly responds to ensure that our needs are met and that we can craft the right order! Aside from the great service, the cakes are not only really pretty and meticulously designed, but also taste very good with a variety of flavors.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Dana Parr

We used Classy Girl Cupcakes for our wedding cake and cupcakes in November! Morgan was SO helpful with my indecisiveness! We had such a hard time choosing flavors because they are all so good! Almond is hands down my favorite! Classy Girl was so great to work with & had great communication! I highly recommend them for anyone looking for their wedding dessert or other special occasions!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sara B.

Great customer service with short notice orders! Very accommodating to personalize cupcakes for special occasions.

Austin Baldwin

I ordered a beautiful rainbow birthday cake for a birthday party and, on top of how amazingly beautiful the cake was, it was also very delicious and lasted for days after the party. Highly recommend!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Megan Tylock

Classy girl cupcakes did an amazing job on my daughter's birthday cake for her golden birthday party today! We were very grateful that they could deliver it to the birthday party site for a small fee. There were two tiers each with a different flavor and she absolutely loved it! The cake was moist and delicious and I would definitely use them again.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Ashley Junkins

Classy Girl Cupcakes were such a treat at our wedding in Sept 2023. The cupcakes were SO delicious, and our guests raved about them! We added take home boxes for our guests and the cupcakes were still great days later.My husband and MIL are also lactose intolerant, and they have great and delicious allergy-free options :)Erica was also so easy to work with and communication was great. The price was extremely reasonable, and we decided to pay a little extra for full set-up and pick-up/takedown. It was so worth the ease and peace of mind!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chelsea Lawell

I really don’t understand the hype of this place. I recently ordered three dozen cupcakes from here for a work function because word around the office was that they were a newer bakery in the area. I paid $78 dollars and I was handed mini cupcakes!!! Their “regular” cupcakes are actually mini-sized and their “jumbo” cupcakes are actual normal-sized! I walked out and had to catch my breath for a moment in the car to process what I had actually received. I was just shocked at the value. I went back in to order a “jumbo” cupcake of confetti and confirmed they were indeed what you’d expect of regular sized cupcakes once I opened the bag! Now I haven’t been there prior to this or know if they were in business before inflation but it makes me wonder if they’ve downsized or cut back due to inflation. I was so embarrassed to bring these to work! I promised my team cupcakes and they were mini. I am still flabbergasted if I’m completely honest. I kept thinking the whole way to work that I could have made the exact same normal-sized cupcakes for a quarter of that price, probably way less. For professional cupcakes I was so disappointed. By the time I arrived at work some of them had started to crumble on the sides and deflate. At first I thought I liked them (got the confetti and red velvet) but as I took a second or third bite I realized the frosting was so thick and had a weird aftertaste that sort of tasted like some type of chemical or plastic. I’m not sure if they store their frosting in plastic or if it’s made with some type of additive chemical but I couldn’t bare to eat the frosting after three bites. I had to stop. I was so utterly embarrassed at the flop of ordering those cupcakes. I would rather make my own or buy from Sam’s or Costco before I’d come back. Attached are the pictures of the “jumbo” cupcake in confetti flavor with seafoam green frosting as well as the “regular” cupcakes which were red velvet flavor. You can decide for yourself but if it were me, I just wouldn’t.

Food: 2

Sarai Romero

Ordered a custom cake for my 5 year old back in October. My son wanted Pokémon but also Halloween so we had to get something custom and this cake was my son’s favorite.We got an Oreo cake and it was super delicious. The cake itself felt fudgy like a brownie and was a huge hit. Definitely looking forward to the next cake.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Christine Lynn

We ordered a Little Monster and Zoo cake for two different dates for our son’s 1st birthday. They were even more beautiful than we could have imagined - just perfect! And they tasted even better! We had the second one delivered because we had family coming over that day - delivery was flawless. THANK YOU for helping his 1st birthday such a great experience for us all!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Hailey Mathée

We recently used Classy Girl Cupcakes for our wedding desserts (mini cupcakes and cheesecakes) and they were an absolute hit! The customer service was great all throughout the planning process, the desserts were delivered exactly on time and as discussed, and the staff then came back at the end of the night to retrieve the rented display pieces. Our guests loved having an arrangement of different flavors and everyone was happy to take extras home at the end of the evening. I would recommend Classy Girl Cupcakes for any gathering!

Caileigh

I ordered 260 Halloween themed cupcakes for a corporate party and even had them delivered to our building and everything was perfect. The cupcakes themselves were amazing. The frosting wasn’t too sweet and the actual cake part was so tasty. I will definitely be ordering from Classy Girl again. Their decorating skills are perfect!

Jason A.

Cupcakes appear to have been frozen? We did a walk in and grabbed (4) filled cupcakes from their walk in menu. This was around 1 pm and was asked if we would be eating them that day. We said yes and were told to leave them out since they had been refrigerated. Which we did and had them as a birthday treat around 8:30 pm. Unfortunately they were dry to the point we almost did not even eat them. The 4 of us split each one to try since they all looked delicious. The place seemed nice, staff were nice but for a $8 cupcake I was underwhelmed. Maybe a custom order would be the way to go in the future?

Charlie Gallagher

For our wedding last year, Classy Girl made us a gorgeous wedding cake, and delivered it with care.My wife and I just celebrated our 1st wedding anniversary. We pulled out the carefully frozen last 1/3 of the top tier of our gluten free wedding cake (it was so big we took a piece out for each of our birthdays!) and enjoyed it and the memories of our big day. I want to thank Classy Girl for making that celebration all the more sweet. Your Strawberry Champagne filling is the flavor of our happy memories.Now that we've finally enjoyed all of that cake, we'll certainly be back for more as special occasions come up!

Katherine F.

Erica and her team are truly wonderful to work with. Our wedding had to be postponed last year due to a positive covid case on the day of the rehearsal and Erica was incredibly accommodating and kind in her response to our unfortunate situation. Luckily, our rescheduled wedding took place and we finally got to share their delicious cupcakes with our friends and family. They turned out beautiful and we are so grateful for the above and beyond level of service and care Erica and her team showed us throughout the process. We can’t recommend Classy Girl Cupcakes enough.

Load More