Very friendly neighborhood bar. Every time we go in everyone is so nice. And they sell lotto tickets!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Tim
What a pleasant surprise of a bar. Love the wheel spin, cold beer and plenty of tvs. Will be back to watch some Brewers games.
Kirsten Olson
The bartenders here are the best! Always open late for night owls like me!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
carly lein
Great prices on drinks and even better company. And how much fun is Bingo on Mondays! Cori and Shari always make sure a good time is had. Pro tip - try the garlic bread or the Alfredo pizza when you need a little snack. Right off the freeway for everyone to enjoy the perfect neighborhood bar.
Gilly Rose
Mortimer’s is an absolute hidden gem! The atmosphere is warm, welcoming, and full of good energy. The bartenders—Mandy and Sherry—are fantastic. They make you feel like a regular the moment you walk in. And Jim, the owner, is just as wonderful, so kind, friendly, and clearly cares about creating a space where people can relax, laugh, and connect. And the chicken Alfredo pizza? Unreal. This is one of those rare places where you come for a drink and end up leaving with new friends. Can’t recommend it enough!
Holly Gallant
Friendly neighborhood small & affordable bar. Most of bartenders do a really good job. They just added larger tv’s. Pool tables with leagues. Darts, gaming machines, Sat music bingo which is pretty fun. Also keep an eye out on some Saturdays for Horse races with Pony Boy extra fun. They do have pizza but just make sure to order ahead if bar fills up because only one pizza oven.
Matthew Cruz
Great atmosphere, great bartenders, took 1 star off cuz their speakers are blown and when someone plays the wrong song it can sound brutal
Wally Blatz
They're always glad to see you when you walk through the door.
Derek Pranke
I was looking for a friendly neighborhood bar to work on my billiards game and stumbled across Mortimers. First, Wendy and Sam are some of the most attentive and welcoming bartenders I’ve experienced at similar establishments. The patron group is friendly and welcoming as well, drinks are fairly priced considering Milwaukee, and I really feel like I’ve found my new favorite local spot. Would strongly encourage dropping in on a weeknight and striking up conversation, feels safe, friendly, and welcoming. I’ll be a new regular here
Becky Buzdum
Super fun bar, great bartenders & regulars make you feel at home!
Very friendly neighborhood bar. Every time we go in everyone is so nice. And they sell lotto tickets!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
What a pleasant surprise of a bar. Love the wheel spin, cold beer and plenty of tvs. Will be back to watch some Brewers games.
The bartenders here are the best! Always open late for night owls like me!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Great prices on drinks and even better company. And how much fun is Bingo on Mondays! Cori and Shari always make sure a good time is had. Pro tip - try the garlic bread or the Alfredo pizza when you need a little snack. Right off the freeway for everyone to enjoy the perfect neighborhood bar.
Mortimer’s is an absolute hidden gem! The atmosphere is warm, welcoming, and full of good energy. The bartenders—Mandy and Sherry—are fantastic. They make you feel like a regular the moment you walk in. And Jim, the owner, is just as wonderful, so kind, friendly, and clearly cares about creating a space where people can relax, laugh, and connect. And the chicken Alfredo pizza? Unreal. This is one of those rare places where you come for a drink and end up leaving with new friends. Can’t recommend it enough!
Friendly neighborhood small & affordable bar. Most of bartenders do a really good job. They just added larger tv’s. Pool tables with leagues. Darts, gaming machines, Sat music bingo which is pretty fun. Also keep an eye out on some Saturdays for Horse races with Pony Boy extra fun. They do have pizza but just make sure to order ahead if bar fills up because only one pizza oven.
Great atmosphere, great bartenders, took 1 star off cuz their speakers are blown and when someone plays the wrong song it can sound brutal
They're always glad to see you when you walk through the door.
I was looking for a friendly neighborhood bar to work on my billiards game and stumbled across Mortimers. First, Wendy and Sam are some of the most attentive and welcoming bartenders I’ve experienced at similar establishments. The patron group is friendly and welcoming as well, drinks are fairly priced considering Milwaukee, and I really feel like I’ve found my new favorite local spot. Would strongly encourage dropping in on a weeknight and striking up conversation, feels safe, friendly, and welcoming. I’ll be a new regular here
Super fun bar, great bartenders & regulars make you feel at home!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great service from Wendy...local bar to chill, talk, and outside has the best Brewers toss game. Plus, there is a cool spot to sit and take photos.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Bartenders wend y. Holly and when I see Mandy are the best
Definitely loved the environment and the back patio area..
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 4
Not much for food service, but the bartenders are attentive & friendly.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Wonderful staff and relaxed environment. No loud music or obnoxious customers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...