Outlaw Oyster

6517 W North Ave, Milwaukee
(414) 897-7453

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+13 photos
+12 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We checked out Outlaw Oyster (located in Crafty Cow) after seeing a video about it by another food reviewer and decided to go during their late “Yappy Hour” (8:30–10 PM). The vibe was laid-back, the deals were great, and the food was definitely memorable.

We ordered the “Let’s Get It All” platter for $50, which included lobster claws with hot butter, smoked whitefish dip, shrimp cocktail, tinned fish with crackers and lemon crème, octopus aguachile,...
Really wanted to love this place, but…we didn’t. While the oysters and smoked white fish were tasty, the rest of the food was overcooked and it was all overpriced. The octodog was beyond chewy and there was not $20 more lobster in the XL lobster roll than in the lobster sliders. PLUS, the lobster roll wasn’t even served with real butter (for almost $50). They were out of several items including staple items. Social media really over-sold this place. Wauwatosa though is a...
It's hard to find fresh seafood in the Milwaukee area, but this place has it and you wouldn't expect it. Stop by and gove it a whirl, you won't be disappointed unless you don't enjoy seafood.

More Reviews