Reynold's Pasty Shop
3525 W Burleigh St, Milwaukee
(414) 444-4490
Customers' Favorites
Fresh N Hot Pasty with Beef Gravy Add On
Pasty by the Dozen Day-Old Dozen
Carrot & Onion Mix
Fresh N' Hot Pasty
Spicy Whole Pickle
Par-Baked Pasty
Pecan Pie Slice
Frozen Pasty
Lemonade
Menu
Photos
+11 photos
+10 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This has been one of my favorite places to eat when visiting Milwaukee. The fresh savory ingredients in the perfect pastry. Great service fast and friendly. I have enjoyed eating pasties for at least 50 years. I had to buy a bunch taking some back to Georgia. Yum.
The UP of Michigan is known as the home of the Pasty. I’ve had several while visiting up there, all good. Reynold’s brings that flavor, quality and tradition to Milwaukee. I only wish I had found this place sooner! I was in and out in about 4 min with a hot Pasty that was more than enough for lunch! Highly recommend Reynold’s!
You May Also Like
Taqueria los Tuxtla Mexican Food Truck - 3111 N 36th St
![]()
Mexican, Tacos, Food Trucks
KFC - 3440 W Fond Du Lac Ave
![]()
Chicken, Fast Food, Chicken Wings, Chicken Shop
A lot of time, gas, and patience in busy traffic for nothing.