Scordato Bakery Inc

5011 W Howard Ave, Milwaukee
(414) 327-8555

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Rice Balls Available Daily
Chocolate Biscotti Cookie
Calzones Available Daily
Holiday Cookie Tray Red
Gourmet Italian Cookies
Apricot Fruit Cookie
Cinnamon Raisin Bread
Apricot Tea Cookie
Peanut Butter Pie
Rainbow Cookies

Traditional Italian Cookies

1 lb. Holiday Cookie Tray (Green)
Includes an assortment of our most popular holiday cookies.
1 lb. Holiday Cookie Tray (Red)
Includes our most popular holiday cookie assortment.
Chocolate Bon Bon Cookie
Chocolate butter cookie topped with white chocolate and sprinkles.
Limoncello Cookie
Soft Cookie with lemon flavor covered with a light icing.
Mocha Crunch Cookie
1.00 Lbs.
Anise Toast Cookie
Anise flavored cookie toasted until crunchy.
Napolitane Cookie
Cookie with candied fruits and walnuts toasted to perfection. 1 pound.
Pipatelli Cookie
Crunchy almond filled cookie with a light hint of spice. Price per 1 pound.
Chocolate Biscotti Cookie
Chocolate Butter Star Cookie
Chocolate butter cookie with a raspberry center. Price per 1 pound.
Vanilla Butter Star Cookie
Vanilla butter cookie with a raspberry center. 1 pound.
Apricot Fruit Cookie
Butter cookie topped with apricot jam. Price per 1 pound.
Italian Macaroon Cookie
Gluten free almond paste cookie with citrus fruit and raspberry center
Amaretti Cookie
Delicious gluten free almond paste cookie. Price per 1 pound.
Chocolate Cookie Sandwich
2 chocolate butter wafers with a raspberry center. 1 pound.
Vanilla Bon Bon Cookie
Vanilla butter cookie topped with dark chocolate than sprinkled with jimmies. 1 pound.
Fig Cookies
Soft cookie stuffed with figs, dates, walnuts, chocolate, orange zest and brandy.
Mexican Wedding Cake Cookie
Butter cookie rolled in powder sugar. Price per 1 pound.
Biscotti Cookie
Cake like cookie with vanilla flavor and a lemon icing. 1 pound.
Rainbow Cookie
3 layers of delicious almond sponge cake filled with raspberry jam than topped with dark chocolate.

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: nextdoor
+66 photos
Photo credit: google
+65 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Living in northern Ozaukee, I don't get down here all that much but when I do always make sure I stop here and buy a lot of cookies and the Sicilian pizza if available. Stopped yesterday but the store was closed and was disappointed as was the other customer that came also.
Hope nothing is wrong, looked the store up and saw closed all this week. Surely could have eaten some pecan fingers and turtle cookies yesterday and today.
June 2025
Outstanding customer service. The young man offered to package items for my mom separately. He even opened the door for me because I had so much stuff. The only reason I gave the food 4 start is because I wish they had a wider selection of donuts. The ham and rolls were delicious. Well done, Scordato's!!
May 2025
Amazing! Excellent treats and I had a sandwich for lunch! I will definitely be going back, can’t wait to try the Lasagna.

The owner is super helpful, Italian family with her mom helping in the kitchen. Great place to check out and to support local!!!
February 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Cousins Subs - 5121 W Howard Ave
Sandwich Shop
China Hut - 5114 W Howard Ave
Chinese
Tacos la Fiera - 6015 W Forest Home Ave
Fast Food, Burgers, Mexican

Scordato Bakery Inc

5011 W Howard Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53220
(414) 327-8555