Maiden Lake Supper Club

15649 Maiden Lake Rd, Mountain
(715) 276-6479

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Ribeye and Scallops with Mixed Vegetables
Prime Rib and Dill Carrots
Tenderloin and Walleye
Blue Cheese Tenderloin
Walleye and Tenderloin
Handbreaded Walleye
Prime Rib Sandwich
View of the Lake
The ml Platter
Walleye Bites

Menu

Appetizers
Duck Strips
Breaded strips of duck served with a spicy plum sauce.
Deep-Fried Lobster
5 ounces of chunked African rock lobster hand-breaded in our signature house breading and served with drawn butter.
Shrimp & Crab Parmesan Dip
You have to try this one. A creamy blend of shrimp and crab served with chips.
The ML Platter
The king of appetizers. A combination of shrimp cocktail, onion straws, and spinach cheese dip.
White Cheddar Cheese Cubes
For the cheese lover in all of us. Lightly breaded and served with marinara sauce.
Onion Straws
Slivered onions battered to perfection and served with ranch dressing.
Chips and Spinach Cheese Dip
A perfect duo.
Deep-Fried Brussel Sprouts
Fresh deep-fried sprouts served with a honey citrus pepper dipping sauce.

Steaks and Ribs
Ribeye
A 13-14 oz cut of the steak lovers steak. USDA choice certified Angus beef and aged to perfection.
Tenderloin
Center cut tenderloin in your choice of king or queen cut.
Gorgonzola Tenderloin
Center cut beef tenderloin topped with aged Italian blue cheese.
Barbecue Ribs
Meaty bay back pork ribs slow roasted and smothered in sweet baby ray's barbecue sauce.
Fin & Filet Combo
Center cut tenderloin served with a filet of our signature walleye.

Seafood Dinners
Tomato Cream Shrimp the Sergio
Signature hand-breaded shrimp in a tomato cream sauce on a bed of rice.
Perch
Lightly breaded and deep-fried.
Seafood Supreme
A seafood lover's dream come true. Broiled lobster, sauteed scallops, and shrimp de Jonghe.
Shrimp
Maiden Lake Combo
A terrific combination of walleye and scallops lightly hand-breaded. Try this combo with broiled walleye and sauteed scallops.
Alaskan Salmon
HC baked wild Alaskan sockeye salmon.
Sea Scallops
Slowly roasted to perfection. We highly recommend you try them hand-breaded in our seasoned house breading.
Shrimp de Jonghe
Sweet shrimp sauteed in garlic butter topped with seasoned bread crumbs.
HC Atlantic Cod
North Atlantic cod is mild and flaky. Choose from broiled or hand-breaded.
Walleye
A maiden lake favorite for decades. Pin-boned and served either hand-breaded or broiled.
Seafood Alfredo
Lobster, scallops, shrimp, and pasta. Served in a rich and creamy Alfredo sauce.

Maiden Lake Favorites
Chicken Ultimate
Tender chicken sauteed with shrimp, mushrooms, and pasta in a white wine cream sauce.
Roast Duck
Slow roasted Hudson Valley ducks with a raspberry lime citron sauce and served over rice.
Chicken Alfredo
Tender strips of chicken breast sautéed with pasta in an Alfredo sauce.
Bourbon Bacon Chicken
Boneless chicken breast with bacon and onions lacquered in a sweet bourbon sauce. Topped with cheddar jack cheese and served over rice.
Wild Mushroom Ravioli
Wild mushroom ravioli tossed with roasted red peppers in a lemon basil cream sauce. Complemented with shredded parmesan cheese and asparagus spears.
HC Feta Bruschetta Chicken
Boneless chicken breast sauteed in olive oil with fresh bruschetta garnished with feta cheese served over multi-grain pasta.

Lite Fare
Open-Faced Steak Sandwich
5 oz center cut tenderloin. Includes cheese and relish tray.
ML Burger
All-natural wagyu beef burger topped with onions, chopped bacon, and creamy gorgonzola cheese. Includes cheese and relish tray.
Shrimp
Five lightly hand-breaded or baked stuffed shrimp. Includes cheese and relish tray.
BBQ Ribs
9-10 oz of our slow-roasted baby back pork ribs. Includes cheese and relish tray.
Perch
5 oz lightly hand-breaded. Includes cheese and relish tray.
Walleye Medallions
5 oz of lightly breaded skinless pieces of Maiden Lake's favorite walleye. Includes cheese and relish tray.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+50 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+49 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

Long wait, but that was expected; and well worth it. Wait staff and bartenders were fantastic. The food was amazing. Only complaint is the multiple negative interactions with the manager. From making comments about the time we came in and the size of our party, to making snide comments to someone in our group who wasn’t satisfied with their meal. Overall the only blemish on our family get together was the mangers crappy attitude and personality.
August 2025
We had a very nice experience at the Supper Club. The food was excellent. The ribeye was especially good and cooked perfectly everyone was happy with their meals and we especially loved the liver pate appetizer that they give you for free. The Lakeview is a definite plus and we have cocktails out on the water while we waited for a table. Highly recommended
August 2025
Best supper club in the area. Long waits but well worth it and with an excellent patio to kill time (and a few brandy old fashioneds). The lake view is unbeatable, and even with a busy crowd the nature is so serene. Always love coming back here.
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Mulligans Sports Bar & Grill - 16707 WI-32
Bar & Grill, Sports Bar, Tex-Mex, American
Hunt Brothers Pizza - 15236 WI-32
Pizza
Bailey's Pour Haus - 15297 WI-32
Bar & Grill, Pubs, Sports Bar, Burgers

Maiden Lake Supper Club

15649 Maiden Lake Rd, Mountain, WI 54149
(715) 276-6479