place has a cozy atmosphere. the staff are very polite. Occasionally the place gets very busy in the evening and there is a bit of a wait but the staff do a good job of estimating how long it will take to get to your order. Possibly one of the best tasting pizza's out there. certainly the best pizza in the valley.
Gerry Grundman JR
Hours are 3 pm to 1 am Saturdays door was locked at 8:15 and people inside just shook their head. Odd
Wally Rogers
Delicious pizza. Cozy place.
Juan Cruz
Great pizza!!!
Ken Schimmel
Great choice for pizza in Neenah
Katie Driggers
This place was awesome. Best tasting pizza in Neenah. Menu is simple and not over complicated. And who can beat free ice cream sandwiches with your meal?! Prices are so affordable. We will be back!
Nicole
Always great pizza!
Stephen Willis
Ordered a large pizza for delivery, guy who took order was great! Told me 45 minutes and I swear it came in under a half hour, And the delivery person was super friendly as well. Be hard to order from anywhere else when in the area.
Kathy Deren
Been going for years always good!!!
Lisa Rank
Great family friendly place,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread with Cheese, Pineapple Pizza, Canadian Bacon Pizza, Garlic Bread
Great family run business best thin crust pizza in the area by far.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: House Special Pizza, Sausage Pizza, Garlic Bread
Kellie Kaufman
Their hours are not correct. When you call at 7pm and they say they are open until 1am its a lie
Pamela Marrache
Delicious pizza at reasonable prices. I’m picky about my pizza, but this place is perfect. I use them primarily for takeout. Yummy!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza, 14 Sausage Pizza
Kristy Wilson
I was eager to try this local place that has been open so long, but I was disappointed. Perhaps it's the lack of variety, but my primary complaint is that the website tauts fresh ingredients and the mushrooms were obviously from a jar. I'll stick to Broken Tree as my Neenah pizza go-to.
Andrew Wilson
First time trying Sammy's. Unfortunately, The pizza lacked flavor and had way to many black olives. Living in Wisconsin your cheese should be good. Nope, no flavor. I have never had canned mushrooms on a pizza ,and I understand why now.
place has a cozy atmosphere. the staff are very polite. Occasionally the place gets very busy in the evening and there is a bit of a wait but the staff do a good job of estimating how long it will take to get to your order. Possibly one of the best tasting pizza's out there. certainly the best pizza in the valley.
Hours are 3 pm to 1 am Saturdays door was locked at 8:15 and people inside just shook their head. Odd
Delicious pizza. Cozy place.
Great pizza!!!
Great choice for pizza in Neenah
This place was awesome. Best tasting pizza in Neenah. Menu is simple and not over complicated. And who can beat free ice cream sandwiches with your meal?! Prices are so affordable. We will be back!
Always great pizza!
Ordered a large pizza for delivery, guy who took order was great! Told me 45 minutes and I swear it came in under a half hour, And the delivery person was super friendly as well. Be hard to order from anywhere else when in the area.
Been going for years always good!!!
Great family friendly place,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread with Cheese, Pineapple Pizza, Canadian Bacon Pizza, Garlic Bread
Restaurantji Recommends
Great family run business best thin crust pizza in the area by far.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: House Special Pizza, Sausage Pizza, Garlic Bread
Their hours are not correct. When you call at 7pm and they say they are open until 1am its a lie
Delicious pizza at reasonable prices. I’m picky about my pizza, but this place is perfect. I use them primarily for takeout. Yummy!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza, 14 Sausage Pizza
I was eager to try this local place that has been open so long, but I was disappointed. Perhaps it's the lack of variety, but my primary complaint is that the website tauts fresh ingredients and the mushrooms were obviously from a jar. I'll stick to Broken Tree as my Neenah pizza go-to.
First time trying Sammy's. Unfortunately, The pizza lacked flavor and had way to many black olives. Living in Wisconsin your cheese should be good. Nope, no flavor. I have never had canned mushrooms on a pizza ,and I understand why now.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Loading...