Sugar River Pizza Co. - New Glarus

700 Railroad St, New Glarus
(608) 527-5000

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Fried Ravioli with Pesto & Sriracha Mayo

Margherita with Balsamic Vinaigrette

Kickapoo Taco Pizza

Baked Potato Pizza

Pulled Pork Nachos

Pepperoni Pizza

Beer Selection

Cheese Curds

Cheese Bread

Steak Pizza

Photos

+55 photos

+54 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Doordash

Heartland

Recent Reviews

We got overcharged on a carry out credit card transaction. Someone gave themselves a 36% tip. My husband went in person twice. He was first told to come back another day. He did so and was told it would be reimbursed within 2 days. It never was so I called. When I called, I was told the owner was "doing a bunch of them today" but it's been almost a week and still nothing. After 3 attempts, I am letting it go but feel the experience and lack of follow through is...

May 2025

This place was fantastic. What made it a greater experience was our amazing waitress Sierra. Friendly, professional, and efficient. The two pizzas the 4 of us shared on 9/06 along with apps were great. The apps were a little over the top with breading but the pizzas were definitely made by someone that knew what they were doing. Great pesto margarita pizza!!!

September 2024

Giving them three stars because they do have quite a few menu options, including a couple that are gluten free. The scores are low because of a couple of issues:
1) I ordered a gluten free sandwich for my child. Not only did it come out burned, but the (same) server also walked over and plonked down a GLUTEN cookie next to the gluten-free sandwich I’d just ordered. If my child’s allergy had been severe, handing her a gluten cookie to go with her gluten-free meal could...

August 2024

More Reviews

Restaurants in New Glarus, WI

Sugar River Pizza Co. - New Glarus

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Sugar River Pizza Co. - New Glarus