Sugar River Pizza Co. - New Glarus
700 Railroad St, New Glarus
(608) 527-5000
Customers' Favorites
Fried Ravioli with Pesto & Sriracha Mayo
Margherita with Balsamic Vinaigrette
Kickapoo Taco Pizza
Baked Potato Pizza
Pulled Pork Nachos
Pepperoni Pizza
Beer Selection
Cheese Curds
Cheese Bread
Steak Pizza
Menu
Photos
+53 photos
+52 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
This place was fantastic. What made it a greater experience was our amazing waitress Sierra. Friendly, professional, and efficient. The two pizzas the 4 of us shared on 9/06 along with apps were great. The apps were a little over the top with breading but the pizzas were definitely made by someone that knew what they were doing. Great pesto margarita pizza!!!
Giving them three stars because they do have quite a few menu options, including a couple that are gluten free. The scores are low because of a couple of issues:
1) I ordered a gluten free sandwich for my child. Not only did it come out burned, but the (same) server also walked over and plonked down a GLUTEN cookie next to the gluten-free sandwich I’d just ordered. If my child’s allergy had been severe, handing her a gluten cookie to go with her gluten-free meal could...
1) I ordered a gluten free sandwich for my child. Not only did it come out burned, but the (same) server also walked over and plonked down a GLUTEN cookie next to the gluten-free sandwich I’d just ordered. If my child’s allergy had been severe, handing her a gluten cookie to go with her gluten-free meal could...
As a person who has had a LOT of pizza, I'm always taken aback by just how good the pizza here is. Get the house blend cheese (I believe that's the default), then go with whatever crust you prefer. Delicious.
Only reason I dropped a star for atmosphere is that the indoor portions of the place have low ceilings, and more than once I've run into noisy tables that make it hard to even have a conversation with your own group (have even seen people...
Only reason I dropped a star for atmosphere is that the indoor portions of the place have low ceilings, and more than once I've run into noisy tables that make it hard to even have a conversation with your own group (have even seen people...
You May Also Like
Fat Cat Coffee Works - 606 Railroad St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, American, Coffee, New American
Puempel's Olde Tavern - 18 6th Ave
![]()
Bar & Grill, Bar, Pizza, Pet Friendly
Dirty Dog Taphaus - 101 6th Ave
![]()
Pubs, Brewpubs, Pet Friendly