Toasty Oven Bake Shoppe

W2360 Kiel Rd, New Holstein
(920) 894-1776

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jason Mueller

They sell Amish food it is so fresh and good very friendly and fast they don't open till may

chuck williams

They have the greatest apple pies and pastries in the area. It is definitely worth a trip

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

El Chopo

Sweet tooth and lots more

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeff Hibbs

I am very grateful for knowing the family of this bakery. They work very hard to produce a wide variety of baked goods. The ingredients they use are either made from scratch at the bakery or are of a more all natural ingredient that proves to be more on the healthier side, compared to thise found in store bought baked goods.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hannah Cozzens

tons of options, and everything is delicious! well priced and something for everyone!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Liz Grunert

I’m just in love with the sugar cookies! They take me back to being a little kid and baking Christmas cookies with my grandma. Everything I’ve had from here is delicious, and very well priced.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David Hoban

Delicious bakery. Fresh breads are a favorite. Turnovers and donuts are a yummy treat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

kim Schick

Love the apple hand pies!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Philip Mast

Great little country bakery with good food and friendly ownersIf for any reason you are not happy with your purchase be sure to let them know and they will gladly try to make things rightSatisfaction

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Susan Spielvogel

Our granddaughter had their turnovers at her wedding instead of cake or cupcakes. The turnovers were awesome and we also took 3 home. We will be visiting their store this Friday.

Nikkole Gonzalez

This bakery is amazing. Huge family favorite. Prices are reasonable. Very friendly. Helpful. Everything tastes amazing. From donuts to turnovers to bread and cookies its all delicious. They do open the 1st week in april cant wait.

Jim Hoffman

They make the very best glazed doughnut I have ever had. And I've had my share at dozens of places in my life.I first had it at the Sheboygan Farmer's Market and it was so good, we went directly to their farm shop to buy more.They have a good variety of baked goods at their Sheboygan Farmer's Market stand, and while they didn't have tons of variety in the walk-in shop, the doughnuts were tremendous and worth the drive.I understand they also take pre-orders for all their baked goods, which is a smart idea.

Donald J Gruenke

If I've learned anything the Amish people are terrific bakers.

Nikkole Mccollum

This bakery is amazing. Huge family favorite. Prices are reasonable. Very friendly. Helpful. Everything tastes amazing. From donuts to turnovers to bread and cookies its all delicious. They do open the 1st week in april cant wait.

Araeya

Wonderful Amish bakery!

Loading...