Jolly Roger's Pizzeria

We have been going to Jolly Roger's for years & years, we have always enjoyed their food, however, the last 3 times have been TERRIBLE! To the point that time #3 we threw it all away. No point in calling to complain....all teenage kids there and it does no good. Not sure if we will ever return. 3x burned was enough to know it will not change. Very sad, this place used to be phenomenal! Please come back guys.....New London needs you!

Never ever had a bad thing. Pizza is done to perfection, wings are always tasty and the cheesy garlic bread is to die for. Friendly staff and all around amazing place

Our favorite pizza joint. Excellent food, good drinks. Easy on the wallet.

Go Enjoy some delicious pizza and the service was great

We had great pizza and salads and cheesy breadsticks. Good place to eat. Alittle alow though on the service.

These guys are the bomb! Really great locally owned and operated restaurant, my favorite has to be the BBQ Chicken pizza!!

Excellent pizza every time, bartenders are quick and friendly

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

I placed an order for delivery on a Friday night around 6:00 pm. I figured it was busy and would probably take about an hour to get out to my house. I was about 2 hours later and my pizza did not deliver to my house yet. I called and asked what the status was on my pizza. The first girl I talked to said it was not in the building so it must have been out for delivery. So we waited about 20 more minutes and nothing had arrived yet. So I called them back to check and the next girl I talked to said the pizza was there for pickup. I went to go pick it up and get they still charged me full price. I figured I would get a discount because of how long we had to wait for our pizza and we never got a call. I am very disappointed that they never asked for my I address when I placed the order. And I am also very upset that the first girl I talked to on the phone said the order was out for delivery when it was not. This was a very bad experience for me and my family and I don’t want anyone else to experience it.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Best pizza around, my family gets pizza a couple times a month. My favorite is meatlovers thick crust and extra sauce. Can't go wrong with a thin crust chicken bacon ranch either.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fun atmosphere. Friendly staff always smiling and positive attitude. Food was delicious. Reasonable prices

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Ordered the Monday special for carryout. Both pizzas were exactly as ordered, and as usual, were just delicious! It's our favorite pizza joint, and we've been to a lot of pizza joints!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Awesome service and stellar pizza. Thanks guys!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Great food and amazing workers

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Perhaps the most ridiculous customer service I have ever received. We ordered delivery, everything was mediocre (incredibly greasy, in no world could that "thin" crust be considered thin) but passable enough that we decided to order again a few nights later while we were in town because it's one of the few places that delivers.

On our first order, they bundled the salad together with pizza so the lettuce was wilted and warm to the touch. We didn't complain and tipped well.

On our next order, I asked for the salads packaged separately as last time they were warm. Her reply: "I don't think we can do that." I was truly stunned. I said, "You can't put our salads separate so we don't have warm salads?" She replied, "Usually we just put everything together in one bag."

This should never have even had to be requested in the first place. I cancelled the entire order.

Food: 3

Service: 1

I'm sorry, but the pizza was not good at all. Poor crust, greasy pizza can not be recommended.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4