Keen's Sweet Treats

1218 Neenah St, New London
(920) 538-4531

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Amber Michels

Amber is easy to work with and does a wonderful job at making your ideas come to life! Her cookies are DELICIOUS! 10/10!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rebecca Ream

We couldn’t be happier with the strawberry-themed birthday cookies we ordered from Keens Sweet Treats for our daughter’s first birthday! 🍓 From the moment we opened the box, it was clear these cookies were something special — Amber absolutely knocked it out of the park with the design. Each cookie was like a tiny piece of edible art: sweet little strawberries, number ones, and even custom cookies with her name — all perfectly decorated with soft pinks, reds, and just the right amount of sparkle.
Not only were they stunning to look at (seriously, almost too cute to eat!), but they tasted amazing too — buttery, fresh, and just the right amount of sweetness. Our guests couldn’t stop talking about them, and they were a total highlight of the dessert table.
These cookies added such a perfect touch to our daughter’s berry sweet celebration, and we’re so grateful for the love and detail that Keens Sweet Treats put into every single one. Highly recommend for anyone looking to take their party to the next level!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carly Seefeldt

Had a great time learning how to decorate cookies 🍪 10/10!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Holly Eckhart

I picked up some of the huge chocolate chip salted Carmel cookies and let me tell you, they did NOT disappoint. They were absolutely delicious!! I will definitely get more of the big chunky cookies again. Soooo good!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michelle Allard

I can honestly say the cookies I ordered were amazing! I asked for a specific theme and sent pictures, not knowing exactly what I was gonna actually receive. She did wonderful, they were on theme and delicious!. Cookies were ready when I said I'd be there to pick them up. I'd 100% order cookies again and can't wait until the next occasion to do so.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Barbie Truszynski

I ordered cookies from Keens Sweet Treats LLC for my son’s first birthday party, themed "The Spooky One," and they were a hit! Not only were they beautifully decorated, but they also tasted amazing.

Keens was so easy to communicate with—super friendly and kind. Everyone at the party was asking where the cookies came from, and all the kids wanted to taste test them! I highly recommend her for any special occasion. Thank you! ☺️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Becca Beschta

Loved ordering cookies with Keen's Sweet Treats! I was able to order adorable baby girl cookies for a gender reveal. Amber was very kind and flexible to work with when I needed the cookies. The cookies were absolutely delicious ? and such a good gender reveal treat! I will be ordering from her again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Decorated Cookies

Ashley Nelson

She did my daughters graduation/birthday cookies and everyone loved them!!!!! Everything is done in a timely fashion and tastes so good!!!! Even my kids at work had fun doing the decorate your own cookies that she put together for me!!!! Hands down best cookies ever!!!!!

Loading...