Bartolettis Restaurant

976 County Rd N, Niagara
(715) 589-4270

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Curt Gerard

First time. I had the Italian Combo. We had a short wait since we were a party of 6. The hostess was friendly, the bartender was friendly and so was our waitress. Everything on my platter was homemade. Definitely a 5 out of 5. I will be back!!!

Ryder Joyce

I finally understand why people leave long reviews. Worst experience since I moved to the area. We called for reservations as this was for our anniversary. The lady on the phone didn't ask for a name for the reservation and when I asked she said "we'll be able to fit in a party if 2 easy". Well Saturday comes and they tell us it's going to be a 45 minute wait, and that they don't do reservations under 10 people. Well that's funny because as we were waiting at the bar, we heard the bartender take a call and say they don't do reservations for under 6 people. Anyways we finally get seated and we ordered the pretzel sticks appetizer. When it came out, two of the sticks you could tell were reheated from earlier as they were a totally different color than the third one. Then we order the chicken parmesan with Alfredo on the side and they bring us two chicken tenders on a pile of pasta smothered in Alfredo sauce. When we said we didn't want to eat that meal, they took it because "the back won't take it off the receipt without the food returned". We then waited 15 minutes with nothing, no communication, no one came back to our table. So we just left. Never going back, and you shouldn't either.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kelly Clark

Maybe I’m spoiled because I’m from the Chicago area and also now live near Kenosha, WI which has excellent Italian food. I rarely write reviews and never send my food back uneaten to the kitchen, but this was the worst “Italian” food I’ve ever seen. First the salad came out which consisted of iceberg lettuce and a single onion slice on top of it..umm what? Then the food comes out and I ordered chicken Parmesan gnocchi. The chicken reminded me of something that you might see in a microwave dinner- just really low quality, and the gnocchi just was not gnocchi. This was a $20 entree, which seemed extremely overpriced. I took two bites and sent it back- I was trying to be very polite and just stated that I didn’t want to eat that.
The owner then came and asked what was wrong, and I said it just wasn’t good. He got defensive and said “do you know how much gnocchi we sell?” No, and I don’t care.
They didn’t charge me for it.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Kara Green

Not impressed . Came from out of town trying something new. Waited a half hour which was fine . Hostess came and walked us in and stood and pointed to a table across the room and said there’s your table . We all ordered steaks and a medium steak came out the rarest I’ve ever seen one but with a burnt top . Ordered my steak smothered and the mushrooms come whole in a side bowl and onions on a plate which was odd . All of steaks were very bland and dripping in butter sauce . Mushrooms were not good . Waitress was fine at 1st but got non caring after we started having issues . We were told that we could order loaded potatoes without the chives because the cook refuses to change an order and just not put them on . The missed a $5 up sale and the waitress was honest and said she’s not lying for the cook anymore . It was an experience, and it was a $28 not worth it meal

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lana Frye

Amazing food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Niki Ford

The last two times I walked out of there. Wait for over 45 mins and when we asked how much longer the hostess. The one that is always the hostess older lady. Well she is just rude all around rude. She is unorganized and than makes everything g else unorganized as well. But the rudeness that we got from her was just uncalled

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Deb Hesebeck

Nice birthday treat!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

don donathan

Tried it out against my better judgement, as the outside doesn't look inviting. Was told it was fantastic inside. Service was terrible and slow. Atmosphere is dingy and tight and the food left me hungry and headed for burger king afterwards.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Collin Gehde

Decent tenderloin but canned mushrooms…

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Bink Bink

Super good food. Had a 30 min wait for a table which wasn't bad steaks were excellent. Fish platter was good but the perch was small. Overall I'll go again. Want to try Monday all you can eat chicken and spaghetti.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish Platter, Steak

Leah Dee

The glasses were dirty they had an unacurit

Food: 3

Service: 2

whiterook 51

Service was excellent. I had the Combination Platter, filled with their Italian samples. They were all well-prepared with a flavorful Marinara sauce. Others in our party had the 6oz tenderloin and said it was delicious and prepared to their liking. We’ll be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Gnocchi, Homemade Cheese Ravioli, Salad, Steak

s Mitchell

Good Friday night fish fry . We all had seafood , the portions are large and the prices reasonable . They serve coleslaw & beans with a side of potato for your dinner. Service was slow but they did have some large tables ahead of us . The place has a large bar but the place really could use some TLC .

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Fish Platter

Trentan Rea

Worse service ever was told was a 45 minute wait to be seated not a big deal but then ended up waiting for an hour and a half then when we got back there there was 5 open tables. Also apparently they don't ask what you would like to drink anymore. Absolutely garbage will probably never come back here would rather drive an hour to go somewhere else

Service: 1

Debra Hickey

Very good food, service and nice atmosphere. Truly enjoy a great dinner at a very reasonable price again!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salad, Sunday Special 6oz Tenderloin

Loading...