Eric's Hand Tossed Pizza & Subs

Very disappointing pick-up order last night - pizza so overbooked & dry - going in trash. Wings also overcooked/dry. Also ordered mild -suspect they were Hot.

First time ordering here. We carried out a supreme and a Hawaiin with a turkey sub. The sub was good and big but needed more mayo spread evenly. Pizza was tasty if a bit greasy. Lots of melty cheese. Triangles would be better than squares so you don’t fight for the edge pieces

This is the best pizza in lake country! Amazing customer service as well! One mistake on a pizza in 5 years and they delivered a new one without hesitation and wouldn’t even take a tip.

It's the crust, stupid! That's my mantra when reviewing any pizza place. There are other important things about a pizza besides the crust. However, without a solid crust recipe and bake that's never been frozen, we can't really move on to any potentially positive review.

So it goes without saying to say that my five star rating states that the crust here is absolutely top-notch.

The fresh ingredients and attention to detail during the bake, as told by how well things are caramelized but not burnt...

I live in Chicago but I visit my dad in Oconomowoc and I like to check out spots around there that I might be surprised by. This spot fit the bill.

This is the best thin crust pizza imo bar none especially in the area

My kids love the Mac n Cheese pizza. My wife and I enjoyed our specialty pizza very much.

Thanks Eric. It’s always great!

Hands down the best pizza in Oconomowoc.

My son has celiac disease, and Erik’s has the best tasting, safe, gluten-free pizza! Their regular pizza is great, too. Always friendly and great customer service. Thank you, we are grateful for you!

Picked up a thin crust pizza. It was great.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered garlic bread and a pizza for a delivery at 7:30pm. Understand times will vary. We live 1 mile from the shop and we were anticoagulant delivery timing for when we arrived home. Order was delivered at 7pm. We were home. Garlic bread was hard, without the sauce ordered. Pizza was greasy and chewy. Fine, we ate it, just probably won’t be going back.

The young lady behind the counter was sarcastic and condescending. Not a good first impression. Food was good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Garlic Cheese Bread, Garlic Bread, BBQ Chicken

It is a take out place. Not really meant for sit down. But best pizza I have had in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread

What a hidden green in the area. I got the meatball sub and it was fantastic. The bread was light and buttery, the marinara sauce was great, and the meatballs had a great taste. I would love to go back to try all the sandwiches and pizzas as well. All of this at a reasonable price.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Don't miss out on this one, Pizza quality is always excellent, Deliver was on time and hot. Always do delivery so I dont really know what the inside looks like. but its a great pizza joint so who cares. :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Our favorite pizza! Is it pricier over other places? Maybe a little, but it's worth it. All the ingredients are fresh and they put a lot of toppings on the pizza.