Foolery's on Okauchee Lake

Outstanding!!!
Waterfront with indoor and outdoor seating.
Service was polite, attentive and prompt.
Excellent food!!!!

Wait time totally unacceptable, food was just alright. Restaurant was not busy on a Sunday, took 30 minutes to order, 70 minutes for food, and another 20 waiting for check

Edited: Wow—didn’t realize ordering a turkey sandwich required a dissertation on crowd control. If the bar, deck, and slips were slammed, maybe tell your staff to communicate that instead of vanishing for over an hour. And for the record, I never got the “great sandwich,” but glad you enjoyed imagining it for me. Have yourself a great day.

Waited over an hour for a turkey sandwich at 3PM on a slow Sunday. Our waitress vanished and never came back. We ended up walking out. Won’t be returning.

Very busy on the deck!

Sunday afternoon. Took 90min to get food after ordered.

Food was very disappointing. Tacos were cold, soggy and greasy. Mahi sandwich was under seasoned. Cheeseburger was like a McDonald’s Quarter Pounder. French fries were soggy and cold. Waited over an hour for the food to arrive at noon on a Saturday.

Pack some patience if you want to eat a meal. Service was very slow. When we got there, it wasn’t very busy. We sat outside on a beautiful day. It took almost an hour to get our food (a simple order too). The waitress did not check on us much and didn’t seem to care that we were waiting so long. Not good.

I have an honest question for the owner(s). I've been here three times with my family and love it. My daughter is interested in working here. It appears that the bartenders and servers are models. Do you have to submit a portfolio when you apply? Also, how old do you have to be to be a server? She's not old enough to bartend.
Thanks.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I stopped in with my wife and a few friends a couple of weeks ago, for our wedding anniversaries. We ordered a couple of appetizers, then order of their lunch menu. WOW! outstanding food, Foolery's really delivered there. The service was pretty good as well. We were greeted with a friendly hello and a smile. However, I was a little bummed out the old fashion didn't hit it mark. Something was a little off there. My only suggestion would be to improve with the mixers.

thank you, Foolery's Staff, for the enjoyable dining. Hope to visit again soon.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Prime Rib Dip

We love the food here but it was impossible to order a fish fry to go. We didn’t find it in the online menu, and no one would answer the phone. Very disappointed.

Friend had the monster burger and got the shirt!! All the food was delicious and the service was spectacular!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The bartender was very friendly. Nice roomy place with beautiful outdoor lakeside seating.
Food was way better than most bars similar to it, with a nice menu selection.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Sandwich

Food is mediocre. Atmosphere is too cold.
I dislike walking into a freezing cold bar in the middle of summer. Service is fabulous though. Waitstaff that is. Bartenders are average.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 3

Food was incredible. Met the owner on the way out. He’s a total family man - love this guy ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Foolery's is awesome!! We had a large group of 12 and were in town for a golf trip over Labor Day weekend. We were able to rent a boat and dock it right at Foolery's. The bartenders and servers were able to bring us food and drinks directly on the boat and it was a blast.

We then hung out at the bar for hours as we enjoyed the great atmosphere, drinks, and snacks! The bartenders really took care of our large group and were very accommodating to whatever was needed. As the day turned into night, there was a great DJ and a nice little dance floor to tear up!

We enjoyed Foolery's so much we came back the following night after playing Erin Hills for more drinks and dinner. I would recommend this family owned business (great people!!) to big groups, smaller ones, and definitely families with younger children! Hope to be back soon!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5