Foolery's on Okauchee Lake

N52W35091 W Lake Dr, Oconomowoc
(262) 567-1940

Recent Reviews

Kevin Carlson

The bartender was too caught up in conversations to pay attention to the bar, so it took forever to order. Then, it took the kitchen forever to get the food out, and I ended up having to get it to go. It was a wrap, and they didn't bother cutting it, which made it impossible to eat. The owner was there, but he didn't seem to care.

Kyle Schneider

Great service and food. Excellent view and porch area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ryan Hernandez

Honestly I came in to visit from Boston and Foolery’s is by far the best bar I have been to since moving here. Shout out to Rex, Harley, and everyone else at the spot

Food: 5

Shannon Hammer

I haven’t been here in awhile due to some bad staff which I believe was the owners daughter. I decided to give it another try tonight and I couldn’t be happier with the food and especially the service! The bartenders and wait staff were very accommodating and paid attention to simple details. Not just some of the staff but everyone who worked there. Special thanks you to Harley and Paige! We will definitely be back because of their incredible attitudes and service!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Monster, Sour Cream and Chive Fries

Jim Paolo

Foolery’s patio/deck is the best! Great service. Great food!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Taylor Vetuschi

Amazing vibes, wonderful views, impeccable food, service is the best! 100/10 recommend!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lindsay Tierney

Amazing atmosphere! Drinks and food were so good. Definitely recommend!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hailey Tierney

This place is amazing. Paige is even better. I love it here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alaina May

Great food, great service, great lake views! Paige is the best! Definitely recommend coming to foolerys!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Emmaleigh Zietlow

Excellent food and drinks and even better service!! Paige is the best!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Curds

Madison Harrington

We came in on a Saturday afternoon for lunch and were able to be seated right away. However, it took a long time before our initial interaction with the server before we could order. After our order was placed, it took a long time again until our food arrived. When it finally came, it was the wrong food and had to be remade. Nearby, we heard of two other tables that had mix-ups with their orders as well. However, when we got our right order out, the food tasted good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 2

Kathy Hoover

Wow. This was the worst food I've had in years! The crab rangoon, onion rings, and french fries were not only fried in the same fryer, but the grease was also very old. As a former restaurant owner, I know food, and they were disgusting.The swiss cheese on the cheeseburger was not even melted, and the med-rare (as ordered) burger was overcooked to medium. The bun was greasy on top, so much so, that my friend only ate half of half of her burger alone, with no bun. My filet mignon was extremely overcooked and tough (on "Steak Night"), and my onion rings were greasy and burnt and everything had this weird smell to it. I even asked the server to smell a fry, cause it smelled rancid. Even the server said she had just had some fries and they were not good.They took my steak charge off of our bill, but fully charged us for the nastiest burger and fries I've seen in awhile. The crabmeat rangoon, when cut open, had a grayish tint to the filling, and the filling was very "thick on the tongue." For $14, it should be excellent. We were both starving but could only choke down one rangoon each! They tried to reinvent the wheel with their version of crab rangoon. Hint: If it's not broke, don't fix it!We never received a physical check with which to review our charges. The server just came up at the end of the meal, announced all of the food we were served but didn't eat, told us the price, and that it was the amount that we had to pay. Our bill was sight unseen. It is VERY suspicious, for obvious reasons, when a restaurant doesn't produce receipts for their patrons.This was a VERY bad experience. The server said it was because it was during the week, and that we didn't get "The weekend cooks!" The bill, even without my steak charge, was still $49 plus tip! For bad food, and in my case, a completely inedible meal. I did have two tall drinks with my meal, but they were single shot vodka drinks, and my friend just had lemonade. So that can't be the reason the bill was so high. But again, a patron can't know if they never receive a bill to review!I want someone to call me tomorrow about this. The server said she talked to the manager on duty, but no one ever even came over to talk to us. And how do you decide to charge a patron for a completely unacceptable burger? You can't say we didnt complain. We did. So please do not disrespect me with excuses or accusations. Just make it right. I have emailed you as well, where I gave you my phone number to call me ASAP. Thank you.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

tm3389

Great location, plenty of space, good drink menu, summers on the deck are really cool.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Michelle

We wanted to go somewhere for lunch to celebrate a girlfriend’s birthday that was comfortable, we could take our time, and maybe get a view of the water. What we found was so much more. The atmosphere was perfect the food was delicious and our service was excellent. Abby was fabulous!! Very attentive but we never felt rushed, So kind and went above & beyond to make our birthday lunch special. We will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

AJ Ritschke

Great place. Friendly staff. Can't wait to try the food

Load More