Golosi Gelato Cafe

My girlfriend (both of us are from out of town) has been talking about this place for years, and now that she finally got to take me here I loved it! super cute interior and great gelato!

Enjoyed our stop here! Don't sleep on the lemon mint ginger gelato. It is outstanding. We ended up buying a couple pints because they had freezer bags for purchase. The gelato didn't melt at all on our 1hr drive back home.

We love this place and frequent it often. However, 20 minutes before close on a Thursday night and they won’t give a sample to my wife because of “covid and teenage boys who abuse the privilege of tastings” is a bit silly. Know your clientele. There’s no one in your place 20 minutes before close, we are middle-aged people who want to buy something. My wife passed and I had something. Missed a sale there. Too bad.

So bummed they no longer do samples, I had no idea they stopped that. Service was ok, not friendly today. While they have a great flavor selection, we will likely go to Whelans or Mullins in the future instead.

Fantastic experience; nice staff/owner/ great gelato 👏

Absolutely delicious gelato. Fantastic staff. Espresso and Amaretto are our favs!

First time here, super friendly owners, loved the atmosphere, cute shop, the gelato was AMAZING, I had ordered the two scoop option and tried the baileys and cake batter super delicious! I definitely will be back to try more!

Delicious, and lovely costumer service

This girl was rude when asking for the potty spoon.

An absolute DELIGHT! Thank you for the wonderful gelato, sorbet (gluten-free) and espresso!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We have lived in Oconomowoc for several years now and this place lives on the fact that they are the only Gelato in the near area. It was the go to place for my family but year after year the owner has clearly decided that it's quantity over quality both in service and flavor. How is it that year after year you raise your prices and decide that the customer experience doesn't matter. Like tonight I came in saw a flavor I'd never tried before asked for a sample and was denied. Of my kids were not there and looking forward to it I would have taken my money somewhere else. You wage making a profit on the fact that you are greedy. I spent $50 dollars in your establishment tonight on what maybe $10 in product at most. And like I said if my kids weren't w me.you would have lost out on that $50 sale. Not to mention in all.of my years coming to your establishment I've never seen the same employees which tells me that you care very little on how you treat them. For anyone reading this go back and look at the negative reviews that actual got posted the owner is nothing but responsive. Long story short today was the last day I spend money in your establishment and I urge others to do the same

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

This is our new family favorite! Amazing Italian gelato that tastes authentic. Great options if you are dairy free. The service is friendly and feels family run. It’s a great place to go and get amazing gelato and walk around the downtown.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Affogato Caffe, Gelato

The workers are friendly, the ice cream is amazing, and the decor is great! I’ve been going to this place for years and I honestly adore it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Gelato

After just returning from Rome a week earlier, we were on the hunt for authentic gelato like we had in Italy. Unfortunately, this was missing the delicious creaminess of the gelato we experienced at every gelato shop in Rome. We were always offered samples in Rome, and had I been allowed a sample of the gelato I chose, I would have chosen something else. I was also surprised there was no regular chocolate flavor. The hunt continues.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

I don’t often leave online reviews but my first impression of this place was poor enough that I am taking the time to write this. My family and I stopped here this evening (our first time here) and the staff member asked us if we had been there before to which we replied no. My husband asked for a sample of one flavor and the staff member gave it. Then my young daughter asked for a sample of the same flavor and the staff member said “well, we can’t give too many samples,” thus denying a child a sample and turning away paying customers. The staff member seemed more interested in chatting with her coworker/friend than in serving customers. As a family in the food service and hospitality industry, we were frankly appalled and left without buying anything and probably won’t be back.