They no longer deliver, ok but when I arrived for my pick up order, its was twenty mins later than they told me. Then when I got home 2 of the 3 pizza’s were made incorrectly. After waiting an hour and getting home to eat with hungry teenage boys at home - there was no way I was driving back or waiting again for my dinner. I called to discuss this with them and there was no apology. I told them I didn’t want to drive there again and they told me that they don’t do refunds but would make the pizza again and that was my only option. I was just going to suggest they give me a partial credit on my account for next order but the guy was short and made it clear that they weren’t doing anything else and basically sounded like he could care less. To make it even worse, the tips on the machine START at 18% and I wasn’t going to do custom because then I look rude and it was busy in there- So almost $8.00 tip for a $42.00 pick up order that was twenty mins late and 75% of my order was wrong. Never ordering from there again.
Joey Larson
The best food you can get in Wisconsin recommend the pull apart breadsticks and also the Joseph’s berry flute
William Karpus
I’m going to start with the good. Lobster ravioli was great. The meat sauce on the tortellini was good. The wine was good and at a good price. The bread was warm. Now the bad. The service was poor. They sat us at our reservation time, but were so focused on takeout pizza, we did not get attention or water for 15 minutes. House salad was all lettuce and few bits of vegetables. When entrees were served, we were asked if we would be needing boxes and if we were going to order dessert. Tortellini meat filling was tasteless and appeared not to be made on site and not tossed in the sauce. Crème brûlée was half cold and half warm and the custard was broken. The cannolo shell was crisp but the filling had 4 chocolate chips and no pistachios. I have been to this restaurant at least 6 times and the best description would be wild inconsistency. My advice is order the lobster ravioli or go to the Olive Garden.
Stacy Wilk
From pastas to pizza to salads The food is great!
Jacob Z
Small town comfort despite the growing pressure around it. The cooks still walk pies out from the back warming on the oven as opposed to some chain that leaves it cold on the shelf. They cater to the cute old locals for early dinner. Despite an influx of rich grumps from California and Texas or wherever else this place remains relaxed and delicious for affordable pizza. Judging by the regular grey hairs early in the evening I would wager taking a date here wouldn't be a miss for flavor. Glad the shop has remained in operation despite the patriarch passing away.
B C
Amazing little authentic Italian restaurant in the tiny Town of Oregon. They also have a small grocery store next door. Check the hours because they are a bit limited.
Pheasant Nuts
Small quaint atmosphere. Good food. Don't be in a hurry. It's all made to order.
dbcs
Great gluten free pizza
Ellie Gibson
After waiting over 2 hours and fifteen minutes for dishes I could only describe as extremely tiny. We had checked previous reviews. Before deciding… We saw photos of the food others had experienced and were shocked by the comparison. It appears the consistency of their dishes and efficiency of their kitchen are certainly not their top priorities. One chicken fettuccine alfredo with runny sauce. With thin sliced and flattened chicken. One shrimp gluten-free, fettuccine alfredo, with five tiny shrimp had thick sauce. Which was made with gluten-free spaghetti noodles. It was also painfully clear they were entirely focused on take out orders, instead of those six tables dining in. Two dishes and two waters, cost us $ 54….Terrible first experience. Will Not be returning.
The meatballs/sauce are so deliciously tender. The perfectly seasoned lasagna w/warm bread is true comfort food. Thank you, Cathy and staff, for a relaxing and wonderful evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cathy's Salad, Lemon Cake, Great Pizza, Meat Tortellini
Patricia M Marks
I just love this place! Whenever I’m there the staff makes us feel so welcome. And the food….it’s delicious?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tahjeanna Clark
Very clean very good service will be back the food is delicious love it !!!
Amazing authentic quality to everything they do. Best pizza I've found in Madison area. The butternut squash ravioli is superb. Don't forget to save room for a cannoli! (The one issue is they're a little unorganized so a 35 minute wait probably actually means an hour. Build in some timing flexibility but it's well worth it.)
They no longer deliver, ok but when I arrived for my pick up order, its was twenty mins later than they told me. Then when I got home 2 of the 3 pizza’s were made incorrectly. After waiting an hour and getting home to eat with hungry teenage boys at home - there was no way I was driving back or waiting again for my dinner. I called to discuss this with them and there was no apology. I told them I didn’t want to drive there again and they told me that they don’t do refunds but would make the pizza again and that was my only option. I was just going to suggest they give me a partial credit on my account for next order but the guy was short and made it clear that they weren’t doing anything else and basically sounded like he could care less. To make it even worse, the tips on the machine START at 18% and I wasn’t going to do custom because then I look rude and it was busy in there- So almost $8.00 tip for a $42.00 pick up order that was twenty mins late and 75% of my order was wrong. Never ordering from there again.
The best food you can get in Wisconsin recommend the pull apart breadsticks and also the Joseph’s berry flute
I’m going to start with the good. Lobster ravioli was great. The meat sauce on the tortellini was good. The wine was good and at a good price. The bread was warm. Now the bad. The service was poor. They sat us at our reservation time, but were so focused on takeout pizza, we did not get attention or water for 15 minutes. House salad was all lettuce and few bits of vegetables. When entrees were served, we were asked if we would be needing boxes and if we were going to order dessert. Tortellini meat filling was tasteless and appeared not to be made on site and not tossed in the sauce. Crème brûlée was half cold and half warm and the custard was broken. The cannolo shell was crisp but the filling had 4 chocolate chips and no pistachios. I have been to this restaurant at least 6 times and the best description would be wild inconsistency. My advice is order the lobster ravioli or go to the Olive Garden.
From pastas to pizza to salads
The food is great!
Small town comfort despite the growing pressure around it. The cooks still walk pies out from the back warming on the oven as opposed to some chain that leaves it cold on the shelf. They cater to the cute old locals for early dinner. Despite an influx of rich grumps from California and Texas or wherever else this place remains relaxed and delicious for affordable pizza. Judging by the regular grey hairs early in the evening I would wager taking a date here wouldn't be a miss for flavor. Glad the shop has remained in operation despite the patriarch passing away.
Amazing little authentic Italian restaurant in the tiny Town of Oregon. They also have a small grocery store next door. Check the hours because they are a bit limited.
Small quaint atmosphere. Good food. Don't be in a hurry. It's all made to order.
Great gluten free pizza
After waiting over 2 hours and fifteen minutes for dishes I could only describe as extremely tiny. We had checked previous reviews. Before deciding… We saw photos of the food others had experienced and were shocked by the comparison. It appears the consistency of their dishes and efficiency of their kitchen are certainly not their top priorities. One chicken fettuccine alfredo with runny sauce. With thin sliced and flattened chicken. One shrimp gluten-free, fettuccine alfredo, with five tiny shrimp had thick sauce. Which was made with gluten-free spaghetti noodles. It was also painfully clear they were entirely focused on take out orders, instead of those six tables dining in. Two dishes and two waters, cost us $ 54….Terrible first experience. Will Not be returning.
Great pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Phenomenal pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza, Pizza
The meatballs/sauce are so deliciously tender. The perfectly seasoned lasagna w/warm bread is true comfort food. Thank you, Cathy and staff, for a relaxing and wonderful evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cathy's Salad, Lemon Cake, Great Pizza, Meat Tortellini
I just love this place! Whenever I’m there the staff makes us feel so welcome. And the food….it’s delicious?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very clean very good service will be back the food is delicious love it !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Butternut Squash Ravioli, Pizza
Amazing authentic quality to everything they do. Best pizza I've found in Madison area. The butternut squash ravioli is superb. Don't forget to save room for a cannoli! (The one issue is they're a little unorganized so a 35 minute wait probably actually means an hour. Build in some timing flexibility but it's well worth it.)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...