Jimmy John's

1845 Park Ave, Plover
(715) 344-1642

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+39 photos
+38 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This is broken into two parts from two different experiences at two different times of the day.
Decided to try it to see for myself if the other reviews were true.

Day 1 (Morning)
Ordered on the app for pickup. Got a Jimmy Cubano and customized it with tomatoes, Jimmy Peppers, and onions.

Sandwich was made strangely fast, so that was off putting. Opened the sandwich, and it was a basic Jimmy Cubano. No extras, almost as if...
Everytime I order my food it's done fast and correctly, they messed up my drink once but the person taking my order seemed new still so I wasn't upset just was surprised it was lemonade instead of mellow yellow. Other then that it was still good food.
Stopped in for a quick lunch with my daughter. We both ordered Little John combos, her's was a ham and cheese, mine a turkey tom. The cashier was kind enough to bring them to us because we sat down the second they were ready. We opened them and they were both ham. I asked the cashier if I had actually ordered the turkey, he said yes, and I showed him the sandwich in case I was mistaken and it was turkey, he confirmed it was ham, and had the other teenage boy remake it. Up...

More Reviews