Owl's Nest

617 E North St, Poynette
(608) 635-2298

Recent Reviews

Brad Holly

Reheated prime rib, no salad, no veggies. Best part of the meal was the bread which wasn't good either. Will not go back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Kim Meisel

First off, our waitress was awesome! We looked up the menu & prices before we got there, so we were ready for a good Friday Night Fish Fry!* To be honest, we were a little disappointed. The prices were nowhere near what was documented online!!5 piece shrimp dinner $24.3 piece fried cod was $24.It was good, but way overpriced!! We even got charged a couple of dollars more for a "service fee" ?‍♀️➡️ I don't think we'll be coming back here ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Vicki Rowlett

Was hoping for a salad bar like it says online. Was not crazy about my drink a whiskey sour. It was all whiskey. The food was very good and service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Lacey Falk

We went here for the first time tonight for Prime. Got the king, it was amazing. Cooked to perfection. Low key, relaxed place. Everyone working was so nice. We definitely will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julie Schwark

Honestly, Owls Nest had been my favorite for fish fry previously. I was looking forward to a good WI fish fry and was sadly disappointed this trip. It was a to go order and was missing tarter, lemon, & silverware. The cheesy potatoes were hard and not hot, the beans were too hot, the fish was over battered, overcooked, and barely warm. Finally, it was $20 for 2 smaller pieces of fish.Very disappointing. Culver's offers a better Friday fish fry.

Food: 1

Service: 3

Renee Manthe

Went to use a gift card and had to wait over an hour, watched people who came in after us get their food before us. Finally walked out after waiting for food and waitress and host had nothing to say.

Roxann Brue

First time, very expensive for what we got for Friday night fish fry.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 2

cathy waterstradt

First time visiting and probably the last. Service was not stellar and prices high for quality. Husband and son ordered perch, but are positive they were served cod.

Robin Wendt

My food was very good, although very expensive but others In my party were not impressed with the

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Mariah Kohl

The menu online does not depict what they offer or current pricing. 2pc cod was $22, with a choice of potato, no beans, coleslaw or any of that. The deep fried cod was good, the salad bar was good, my son’s mac n cheese was hard and not edible, and my broiled cod was not good. For the price, in my opinion it was not worth it. I’d love to support a local business but until they improve their quality, especially with paper menus with the price … we won’t be back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Carolyn Mcgowan

LOVE the fish fry!?

Tim Fell

We stop there for dinner only to be told that there was a $10 cover charge for the music. We stated we were there for dinner only to be told they were not serving dinner. No where on their website stated there was no dinner. So you better call before you go.

Terry Hanneman

Went for fish dinner and was surprised when I saw the prices. I have never been charged that much for so little amount of food. I will never go back for any reason. If I could give this place a zero that would be a good choice

Tamra

Hadn’t been since new owners and decided to give it a try. Won’t be making that mistake again.Showed up to pick up my to go order and paid for it. When the order arrived I was very disappointed with the tiny serving size. For $22 an order I expected more than the included pictures

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Thomas Darling

Great food, great owners and great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More