It is great, it is tiny if you are dining in, but the cheese and marinara sauce are great.
Jesse
Always good across the board .
Kim Mucha
Thank you for the delicious Mother’s Day pizza!!! It was perfect and hit just right! Absolutely love the old school bag for carry out.
Marcela De La Rocha
Check the ingredients of the actual pizza! They do not even use real cheese!?!? It was so so disappointing to find they use an artificial cheese product. Unbelievable.
Martin Aubol
Great pizza.
Molly Schultz
So we stopped in at 6:40 Sunday night. We were the only people eating at the time. We placed our order for 1 pizza. Now I realize they are also making a good amount of pick up orders, so we anticipated a bit of a wait, but after almost an hour we finally got our pizza. It was not the same as it used to be. The little bit of sauce had no flavor and the cheese was not the same. But worst of all, after eating a couple pieces, I found a long black hair between the crust and the topping of my piece. I don’t like to complain, but I went up to tell the owner, she took my plate and said I’ll take half off your bill. Then she proceeded to tell me that she wiped the hair off and it was a very fine blond/grey hair, insinuating it was my own hair that I somehow baked into the pizza. Very disappointing experience all the way around.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mr. Darl Lunde
Excellent pizza. This particular pizza/Italian food is our favorite. The staff/owner is super caring! I highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Amanda Schlitz
Who doesn't love...
Parking: Stairs to interior
Kid-friendliness: Handful of games and coloring for kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Pizzas
Peter Sackett
Still the best in Rhinelander. I've heard rumors it was sold to a new owner with the same recipes. I can confirm that the pizza is just as great tasting as it was 20 years ago. It was packed when we arrived on a Monday at 5pm to pick up our order. Every table was nearly full, and there were 9 cars in the parking lot. When we were leaving three more cars were pulling in. This is a go to place if in Rhinelander.
Was told that this was the place to get real pizza. They did not disappoint, I tried the pepperoni supreme + sausage, and it was PERFECT. Even with all the toppings, the crust was still crispy and delicious. These people obviously love what they do and they do it well. THANK YOU!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Appetizers, Pizzas
eric tidemanson
Did not correctly make the pizza I requested for carryout even with repeating my order back to me. Going elsewhere.
I see your response and for you to reply in this manner is despicable. When I walked back into the restaurant that evening and said there was no sausage on my sausage, pepperoni, and extra cheese pizza the woman at the register at first told me that the sausage was under the cheese. Obviously it was not. I showed her the ticket on which was written only pepperoni and extra cheese. She then admitted her mistake. She offered to make another pie, but I could not wait another 45 minutes. I left the pizza on the counter and started walking away, she asked about refunding the money, I said forget it and left. Your shop's inaccuracy ruined my meal that Saturday night. Your dishonesty (read creative storytelling), however, makes my day now that I have returned from vacation. As your waitress cannot admit to her mistakes and you choose to lie in your response, you have no hope to improve.
Service: 1
Joe
bad experience...bad pizza.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Simply Starry
This pizza place has always been a very popular legend in Rhinelander. So after 2 years I decided since I was visiting to stop in and get one of the famous pizzas. The unfortunate thing is there's new ownership and when I got the pizza home that evening it was completely overcooked and basically unedible. I don't complain but I was so disappointed because whoever took it out of the pizza oven it was quite obvious it was overcooked they should have just started over but somebody made a bad decision in the kitchen. The next day I called the owner she had remembered me from the previous night and she was very apologetic which was good. But she offered first just to give me another pizza at half price I guess I was surprised because the whole pizza was ruined I don't know if she understood that. So I said you know I'm not here to complain but then she made a comment saying. " well you are complaining though". And that surprised me . I guess I was confused because the pizza was burned I thought s remedy would be obvious...a free pizza to replace the burnt one? P so I'm the one who had to mention that and I guess she was surprised but she did say that was okay so within an hour I was able to come and get another Pizza that day since it was my last day. But here's the other unfortunate thing when I arrived there were two young girls who were working. They were waiting on a lady who had ordered a vegetarian pizza and unfortunately they had gotten the order wrong.i overhead the conversation and offered to pick off the veg that didn't belong... Which didn't seem like a good solution The customer stated this happened last week She wasn't happy On the way out after I got my replacement pizza I talked to get and she started she could always g go somewhere else.... It wasn't worth it to her anymore And my replacement pizza.. Sadly subpar☹️
best pizza ive ever had. like always.
It is great, it is tiny if you are dining in, but the cheese and marinara sauce are great.
Always good across the board .
Thank you for the delicious Mother’s Day pizza!!! It was perfect and hit just right! Absolutely love the old school bag for carry out.
Check the ingredients of the actual pizza!
They do not even use real cheese!?!?
It was so so disappointing to find they use an artificial cheese product.
Unbelievable.
Great pizza.
So we stopped in at 6:40 Sunday night. We were the only people eating at the time. We placed our order for 1 pizza. Now I realize they are also making a good amount of pick up orders, so we anticipated a bit of a wait, but after almost an hour we finally got our pizza. It was not the same as it used to be. The little bit of sauce had no flavor and the cheese was not the same. But worst of all, after eating a couple pieces, I found a long black hair between the crust and the topping of my piece. I don’t like to complain, but I went up to tell the owner, she took my plate and said I’ll take half off your bill. Then she proceeded to tell me that she wiped the hair off and it was a very fine blond/grey hair, insinuating it was my own hair that I somehow baked into the pizza. Very disappointing experience all the way around.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Excellent pizza. This particular pizza/Italian food is our favorite. The staff/owner is super caring! I highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Who doesn't love...
Parking: Stairs to interior
Kid-friendliness: Handful of games and coloring for kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Pizzas
Still the best in Rhinelander. I've heard rumors it was sold to a new owner with the same recipes. I can confirm that the pizza is just as great tasting as it was 20 years ago.
It was packed when we arrived on a Monday at 5pm to pick up our order. Every table was nearly full, and there were 9 cars in the parking lot. When we were leaving three more cars were pulling in. This is a go to place if in Rhinelander.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Extras, Pizzas
Restaurantji Recommends
Was told that this was the place to get real pizza. They did not disappoint, I tried the pepperoni supreme + sausage, and it was PERFECT. Even with all the toppings, the crust was still crispy and delicious. These people obviously love what they do and they do it well. THANK YOU!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Appetizers, Pizzas
Did not correctly make the pizza I requested for carryout even with repeating my order back to me. Going elsewhere.
I see your response and for you to reply in this manner is despicable.
When I walked back into the restaurant that evening and said there was no sausage on my sausage, pepperoni, and extra cheese pizza the woman at the register at first told me that the sausage was under the cheese. Obviously it was not. I showed her the ticket on which was written only pepperoni and extra cheese. She then admitted her mistake. She offered to make another pie, but I could not wait another 45 minutes. I left the pizza on the counter and started walking away, she asked about refunding the money, I said forget it and left. Your shop's inaccuracy ruined my meal that Saturday night. Your dishonesty (read creative storytelling), however, makes my day now that I have returned from vacation.
As your waitress cannot admit to her mistakes and you choose to lie in your response, you have no hope to improve.
Service: 1
bad experience...bad pizza.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
This pizza place has always been a very popular legend in Rhinelander. So after 2 years I decided since I was visiting to stop in and get one of the famous pizzas. The unfortunate thing is there's new ownership and when I got the pizza home that evening it was completely overcooked and basically unedible. I don't complain but I was so disappointed because whoever took it out of the pizza oven it was quite obvious it was overcooked they should have just started over but somebody made a bad decision in the kitchen. The next day I called the owner she had remembered me from the previous night and she was very apologetic which was good. But she offered first just to give me another pizza at half price I guess I was surprised because the whole pizza was ruined I don't know if she understood that. So I said you know I'm not here to complain but then she made a comment saying. " well you are complaining though". And that surprised me . I guess I was confused because the pizza was burned I thought s remedy would be obvious...a free pizza to replace the burnt one?
P so I'm the one who had to mention that and I guess she was surprised but she did say that was okay so within an hour I was able to come and get another Pizza that day since it was my last day. But here's the other unfortunate thing when I arrived there were two young girls who were working. They were waiting on a lady who had ordered a vegetarian pizza and unfortunately they had gotten the order wrong.i overhead the conversation and offered to pick off the veg that didn't belong... Which didn't seem like a good solution
The customer stated this happened last week
She wasn't happy
On the way out after I got my replacement pizza I talked to get and she started she could always g go somewhere else.... It wasn't worth it to her anymore
And my replacement pizza.. Sadly subpar☹️
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Good pizza
Loading...