The Cake Lady

3561 S Kinnickinnic Ave, St Francis
(414) 294-4220

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kait Schmidt Thabet I Celebrait by Kait

The Cake Lady is amazing! Delicious treats and gorgeous design. As a Wedding Planner, we certainly recommend Cecilia. Photos by Meghan Lee Harris

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ashley O

I’ve had nothing but great experiences with The Cake Lady. Communication and process is effortless. And the cake tastes out of this world!! So delicious. Would highly recommend her for all of your sweet treat needs and wants 🥰

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Melissa Khalil

Cannot say enough about how blown away I was by the cake that was delivered for my coworker’s bridal shower!! Her talent is incredible, all I sent was a photo reference of what I wanted the cake to look like & she just made it happen, no problem. She could not have made it easier as well, the customer service was top notch. If I could give TEN STARS I would!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alex Paulsen

We used The Cake Lady for our wedding cakes. She did a cutting cake for the head table and cupcakes for our guests. The cake was beautiful and delicious! She had great flavor, serving recommendations, and was easy to work with throughout our planning process. We can't wait to eat our top tier at our 1-year anniversary!

Marco Bonacquisto

These cakes are DELICIOUS!! I had one of their gluten free cupcakes once and it was literally the best cupcake I've ever had in my life.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Makenzie Wydra

Cecelia is an amazing baker—her flavors are unique, and the cake is so moist. We chose two different flavors, but the lavender cake with strawberry buttercream was the perfect touch for our June wedding. We had multiple guests tell us that it was the most delicious wedding cake they have ever had!

Rachel M

I've ordered from the Cake Lady twice - both times were excellent. She did cupcakes for one birthday and a smash cake and full sized cake for another birthday. Excellent communication, easy pick up, but most importantly gorgeous, delicious cakes. Couldn't be happier

Rachel

Cecelia was so easy to work with when ordering a cake for my daughters birthday! She designed it exactly how I wanted and it tasted great!! Everyone mentioned how good it was. I’ll definitely order a cake here again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Megan G

I recently hired The Cake Lady to bake my wedding cake and I can't recommend them enough! We really enjoyed the tasting and talking to Cecelia about all of the flavor/decoration options. The cake arrived to our venue on time and was exactly as planned. I got rave reviews from our guests about how delicious it was. If you're in need of a cake (for any event!), make sure to check out this fantastic local bakery.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Delaney Smith

I recently ordered a cake from The Cake Lady with a tight deadline of just one week. While I appreciated the urgency, the final product didn't quite match the picture I provided. Although the cake looked similar, the details were lacking - specifically, the flowers that were a key part of the design. Unfortunately, they were barely noticeable, which was a bit disappointing.

On the plus side, the cake tasted great! However, the lack of attention to detail was a significant letdown. Given the importance of visuals for special occasion cakes, I expected more.

Due to this experience, I won't be ordering from The Cake Lady again. While I understand that urgent orders can be challenging, I believe a bit more focus on details would have made a big difference. Perhaps next time!

Chris Adamczyk

Cecelia did a fantastic job creating our wedding cake! The cake was equally as beautiful as is was delicious, and I'm very excited to have my second tasting on our first anniversary. Before we ordered, Cecelia provided a tasting of various different cake flavors and fillings and helped guide us in choosing a combination of different layers of filling that worked together. She also used our wedding cake inspiration photos to design a cake that perfectly fit the overall wedding venue and theme. We ultimately chose to order the lavender cake with lemon curd and custard filling, which was amazing :)

Acirra Robinson

I Purchased a Cake for my Daughter’s 4th Birthday, Communication was Great, easy to contact and the cake was delicious, Everyone loved it. I would definitely recommend.

Mallory Rossiter

The best cookies!! The three kinds I’ve tried have all been amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kyle Mckibben

We were looking for a small cake to include at our wedding! The process was super simple and easy for us! We were stuck between two flavoring options for our cake and Cecelia gave us some great input! Payment and pick up were also very easy and the cake was exactly what we were looking for!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Liz Grade

Cece made our wedding cake this past weekend and it far surpassed my expectations! Not only was it the most beautiful cake I’ve ever seen, it was so delicious. Many of our guests went out of their way to tell me how gorgeous and tasty the cake was. Thank you, Cece 🩷🩷

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...