Scully’s Restaurant

107 S Cogswell Dr, Silver Lake
(262) 586-7004

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Butterfly19 L

Sam is a great server. Awesome service and delicious farm fresh food.

Mike Paulson

The dinner was absolutely incredible. Highly recommend it will absolutely be back.

Michelle Young

My husband Kailen, and myself have been here on several occasions. Everything we have tasted thus far including breakfast, lunch and dinner was great!! The food was very fresh and tasty. The waitress Sam brings a lot of energy to the table and she is amazingly joyous and efficient… The cook consistently prepares delicious mouth watering meals. We travel from Chicago, to Lake Geneva at least four times a year, and we are headed that way now. We will definitely be going there this weekend.😉 Scully’s is our go to either coming into Lake Geneva or departing. 😊❤️

Brett Nicol

Great food and great, family run business.

Jackson Nicol

Great bar, slightly bias but it’s fine, Nutella PBJ is amazing, LJB2028

Nancy Vettese

Food was great & our service was super cute & friendly.

Mary

You won’t be disappointed. Awesome food. A little on the noisy side because it is small but who cares? The food is great and Amber is a wonderful server and makes a mean Old Fashioned.

Shannon D

great food and even better service by Holli!

Scott Stillman

So glad we finally stopped in! We will be back!!

Allen Vermeulen

Outstanding breakfast! One of if not THE best in the area. Don't pass on them. Can't wait to get dinner there.

Heide Gauerke

Delicious breakfast! Wonderfully seasoned hashbrowns. I will have to come back again for lunch and a fish fry.

Ed Holden

Maddie (age 7) gives the Fried Nutella Sandwich a 100 out of 10.

Everything is fresh and made from scratch. Fantastic.

John Mathewson

Chef/Owner Nick makes the best food around here - amazing, And Sam the waitress is the best........ this wonderful place is a must stop if you are anywhere nearby

Becky Kroncke

Don't drive too fast or you'll pass this jem by. It might look small but the flavors were huge! We can't wait to come back and experience more of what they have to offer.

Reeping Fear

Sully's is truly amazing. Just a spectacular experience all around. The food is hot, fresh, and locally sourced. To have the choice of store bought eggs or farms fresh... What, who offers that .. Scully's does.

Service was equally amazing 🤩. Quick, polite and professional. Thank you so much for such an excellent experience!

Loading...