Really cute coffee shop, friendly owners. The cherry scone was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ben Brill
THE BEST COFFEE of my life!!! At the first sip of their Columbian Medium roast (with just a touch of cream and sugar), I froze in my tracks. Time stopped. I was overcome by the astonishingly satisfying flavor and balance. I forgot about all of my problems, for just a moment, and sunk into that perfection of their roast. It's rare for me to find that perfect balance of flavorful and bold without being overly acidic or bitter, while also not being watery or too weak, and THIS was it.
After that first sip, I had to tell someone, so I told Robert who was working behind the counter, just how much I loved this coffee. Robert was, from the start, so incredibly friendly and helpful, and a real pleasure to talk to. Robert warmly thanked me and said he'd pass my compliment to the owner.
For the next hour, I sat in the small, but very comfortable seating area, and began what I came for: To get on WIFI and work on my laptop and try to get something meaningful done. Not only did I get it done, I basically redesigned my worklife. I attribute my success in this (which I'd wanted to do for months) to the positive energy of that Columbian medium roast, the friendiness of Robert, and the warmth and optimism of the guests and staff that came in.
As if this wasn't already an amazing morning, Robert also introduced me to the owner, Sean, who told me a little about his roasting process (this has been his passion for 20 years!) One by one, really friendly people and staff came through the doors, and Robert introduced me to basically everyone that would be good for me to know in the local arts and music community, of which I am a new member.
I left Pinky Promise and went on to have probably the most productive and satisfying day I can recall in probably the past 5 years.
Thank you Sean, thank you Robert, thank you Pinky Promise!
Amos Grünebaum, MD
Wonderful place. They roast their own coffee fresh with so many options. BEST coffee we had in Wisconsin. What a great place, worth driving a long distance!!!!! We took home 3 different bags of coffee to grind at home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Seth Mangan
Is now my go-to for coffee in Sturgeon Bay. My Iced latte was great, as was the service. Love the little chill coffee shop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Lemerond
Pinky Promise Coffee in Sturgeon Bay is an absolute gem! The coffee is fantastic – rich and flavorful. The space itself has a really cool and inviting vibe, making it the perfect spot to relax or catch up. To top it all off, the owners and staff are incredibly friendly and welcoming. Five stars all the way!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Brittany Gallegos
Absolutely charming ! Wonderful staff! So many options! Cute inviting lounge location! Will be back
Drake Friesen
Amazing coffee!
Everett Lee
Service is great, no waiting, quiet and awesome people very nice and helpful. Oh and the coffee they will make just the way you like it. 👍
Andy Galvin
I just ordered drip coffee, but it was probably the best I’ve ever had. The right temperature, smooth, very full body and tasty.!
Molacko Wescott
Great little downtown Cafe. They have a pretty good size menu so anyone should find something they like. The staff was friendly. I can also tell this place who knows coffee because they sell a lot of Fellow equipment like their vacuum sealed canisters and grinders. I bought a small bag of whole bean coffee. I haven't tried it yet but I'm sure it'll be delicious.
Stopped in and got a Cortadito and a Chai. Owner was great to chat with, educating us on different types of coffees around the world. Atmosphere was great as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Tyler Nellis
Best cappuccino in Door County! Friendliest staff and quality product.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Levi Brunette
they bought a cyber dumpster
Kaitlyn Jacobsen
friendly staff and a great cold brew!
Ashley Campbell
WOW. We were really impressed. The owner and staff were warm, welcoming, and knowledgeable. The owner even showed us their in-house roasting set up! The mod bar set up is unreal, and the resulting coffee tasted incredibly balanced. This is a not-to-miss stop if you’re visiting the Door!
Really cute coffee shop, friendly owners. The cherry scone was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
THE BEST COFFEE of my life!!! At the first sip of their Columbian Medium roast (with just a touch of cream and sugar), I froze in my tracks. Time stopped. I was overcome by the astonishingly satisfying flavor and balance. I forgot about all of my problems, for just a moment, and sunk into that perfection of their roast. It's rare for me to find that perfect balance of flavorful and bold without being overly acidic or bitter, while also not being watery or too weak, and THIS was it.
After that first sip, I had to tell someone, so I told Robert who was working behind the counter, just how much I loved this coffee. Robert was, from the start, so incredibly friendly and helpful, and a real pleasure to talk to. Robert warmly thanked me and said he'd pass my compliment to the owner.
For the next hour, I sat in the small, but very comfortable seating area, and began what I came for: To get on WIFI and work on my laptop and try to get something meaningful done. Not only did I get it done, I basically redesigned my worklife. I attribute my success in this (which I'd wanted to do for months) to the positive energy of that Columbian medium roast, the friendiness of Robert, and the warmth and optimism of the guests and staff that came in.
As if this wasn't already an amazing morning, Robert also introduced me to the owner, Sean, who told me a little about his roasting process (this has been his passion for 20 years!) One by one, really friendly people and staff came through the doors, and Robert introduced me to basically everyone that would be good for me to know in the local arts and music community, of which I am a new member.
I left Pinky Promise and went on to have probably the most productive and satisfying day I can recall in probably the past 5 years.
Thank you Sean, thank you Robert, thank you Pinky Promise!
Wonderful place. They roast their own coffee fresh with so many options. BEST coffee we had in Wisconsin. What a great place, worth driving a long distance!!!!! We took home 3 different bags of coffee to grind at home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Is now my go-to for coffee in Sturgeon Bay. My Iced latte was great, as was the service. Love the little chill coffee shop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pinky Promise Coffee in Sturgeon Bay is an absolute gem! The coffee is fantastic – rich and flavorful. The space itself has a really cool and inviting vibe, making it the perfect spot to relax or catch up. To top it all off, the owners and staff are incredibly friendly and welcoming. Five stars all the way!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely charming ! Wonderful staff! So many options! Cute inviting lounge location! Will be back
Amazing coffee!
Service is great, no waiting, quiet and awesome people very nice and helpful.
Oh and the coffee they will make just the way you like it. 👍
I just ordered drip coffee, but it was probably the best I’ve ever had. The right temperature, smooth, very full body and tasty.!
Great little downtown Cafe. They have a pretty good size menu so anyone should find something they like. The staff was friendly. I can also tell this place who knows coffee because they sell a lot of Fellow equipment like their vacuum sealed canisters and grinders. I bought a small bag of whole bean coffee. I haven't tried it yet but I'm sure it'll be delicious.
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped in and got a Cortadito and a Chai. Owner was great to chat with, educating us on different types of coffees around the world. Atmosphere was great as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Best cappuccino in Door County! Friendliest staff and quality product.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
they bought a cyber dumpster
friendly staff and a great cold brew!
WOW. We were really impressed. The owner and staff were warm, welcoming, and knowledgeable. The owner even showed us their in-house roasting set up! The mod bar set up is unreal, and the resulting coffee tasted incredibly balanced. This is a not-to-miss stop if you’re visiting the Door!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...