Paula's Mexican Kitchen

143 Main St, Sullivan
(262) 582-3133

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Isabella Staszak

Overall not the best experience, the first time we went there during their grand opening it went amazing! But we went tonight with family and I understand we’ve got a big family but the service wasn’t that good considering we had two waitresses. I asked 3 times for my drink while everyone got refills and new drinks and once I finally got my drink it was made so strong and with the wrong type of alcohol. Not to mention they advertise a $1.50 taco deal but when we received the “menu” (a piece of printer paper that had just been copied) it did not mention any of their daily specials so when we ordered we were expecting the deal we were told but to find out it’s only for “American style tacos”. Overall just not the best experience, in my opinion wasn’t worth the $57…sadly will not be returning.

Michael Muenks

Excellent service and food. Enjoyed!

Lisa Larsen

I definitely will go back. Friendly, clean,& delicious food.

Jody Orchel

Very Authentic Food ?

Ruth Z

Love this restaurant , fantastic food and service!!

Jennifer Warford

First 2 times were great. 3rd time not so much. Restaurant was empty at 5pm. We wanted to eat at the bar and the bar was dirty. Considering the place was empty and the staff was sitting around when we walked in I would think the bar would be spotless. Food was good but service, ambiance and cleanliness not. I have seen many restaurants close and I don’t see this place lasting if they can’t get it together when it’s not even busy. The music in the restaurant was more for the staff then the customers. It looks like they are collecting empty patron boxes above the bar and had some tacky dollar store margarita glasses in the glass rack with the stickers on the bottom of the glass stem. Pay attention to details in your restaurant. I don’t see us going back sadly to say!

April Kaiser

Great Tuesday taco deal....great food....1st time there and was very satisfied

Tom Graham

Food was fresh and crispy, fried beans better than most also.

Matt Karrels

I have traveled around the country and eaten at many Mexican Restaurants. Paula's is my favorite! Fast friendly service great food at great prices.

Dawn Herman

Just ate dinner there for the 1st time, We will be going back! The Chimichanga was delish, they had white Queso cheese on top, pleasant surprise.

Brett Knepprath

Not many people in there , super long wait to get food, order was messed up, people are not very friendly.

Debbie Schaefer

We love the nachos, salsa and service at Paula's. Love the fireplace table and friendly vibes.

DnD Rodenkirch

We went here last year and was told there would be a credit card fee which I understood. The food and service was good that's why we were going to return. They reduced their hours which I'm glad I looked on their site to find out. When we pulled up to their door we saw a sign saying chips and salsa isn't free anymore. We understand that prices are increasing but with all their changes and no cars in the parking lot, we went elsewhere.

Jay Rodriguez

Food was really not that great I don’t like the fact they put my chimichanga on top of my beans so it got soggy and the ground beef was really salty I don’t think I will ever go back

Patty Sevenz

Stopped here for dinner instead of the usual fish fry. Amazing good food and "refried" beans!! (not your average tasteless bean mush.) Everyone was pleased with their dinner. Service was friendly and good too. Food seemed much more authentic than your run of the mill Mexican food. Definitely will return.

Loading...