Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Sun Prairie

Haven't ordered from here in a while but glad to see the food is still amazing keep it up

Really good pizza, great crust on the regular crust pizza, get a Boris Karloff, it's awesome!

The only reason I’m giving two stars instead of one is because I’ve had previously good experiences here, and the location and atmosphere are decent; however, the pizza has been pretty horrible the last few times we’ve ordered it. I always give a pass when I’m disappointed the first time (every establishment can have an off day) but this time was extra disappointing.

We ordered for carry out with the intent to sit outside and eat at a park near our house. Unfortunately, the pizza was doughy and undercooked, had practically no sauce on it and was covered in thick, rubbery cheese despite having ordered lite cheese. Seems like they instead went heavy on cheese and lite on sauce - same exact mistake they made on my previous order. So we had to head home to pop our pizza in the toaster oven, pull a bunch of the cheese off and open a jar of our own pizza sauce so we could choke down our mediocre pizza.

It makes me sad to write this review because we loved GN enough to have it at our wedding two years ago, but sadly it’s just not going to be our go-to anymore.

We hosted our daughter’s graduation party here and it was fantastic. Kimmy helped us with all the details and checked in frequently to ensure all was cared for. The pizza was excellent, the room was clean and ready for us and there was a lot of flexibility offered to meet our needs. I highly recommend GNP Sun Prairie and encourage you to check out their meeting space room.

Worst place to ever eat,they dropped food on the floor and still gave it to a customer,they use expired food,can can cause nothing is fresh as they say, dough, expired but they still use, salad and subs don't bother getting, they suck , fried food better off making your own,saldes have worms,they don't wash hands,poor place to still be in Sun prairie, overpriced for food,never order pasta,or anything from it,it frozen and heated in a microwave, not fresh at all , chicken Alfredo is frozen noodles not even a fresh produce in sights, you are getting charged what you could make at home,this place may act like they care but honey money.
.id never ever pay for a pizza that takes under 10$ to make... and if you wondering what it's like working there,long hours no insurance no breaks unless you smoke pot no set schedule cause very bad cleaning before this store ,rude people that are in charge, no skills at food safety

I enjoyed a hand tossed pizza which was delicious, and the sausage was about the size of a ping pong ball. I believe it was a 14 inch, so I also enjoyed some leftovers.

Excellent pizza.

Great food and people are cool

Sun P location definitely spanks the other. Fantastic work. I ate it so fast im gasping and burping at the same time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sauce

I hadn’t had Glass Nickel Pizza in years and was looking forward to having it for my birthday. We walked into the Sun Prairie location, and all of the tables were dirty. There was one group of ladies there who looked like they had been served. We heard voices in the back, but saw no staff. Another couple came in & sat down. After several minutes, they rang the bell at the counter. We waited about 20 total minutes and still saw no staff, so we left and came back to Janesville. Very disappointed ☹️

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Go pizza, quick friendly service

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Salads

We ordered a pizza for takeout last week. We live 15 minutes north of Sun Prairie location. When we got the pizza home it was not the pizza we ordered. The box had the correct order on it but the pie inside was not ours. We did eat that pizza instead of driving back to town and waiting for a new one and the one we ate was likely a hand tossed crust (we usually eat thin crust). There was not enough sauce or cheese on the pie and it was dry. We threw half of it away.

Food: 3

Service: 3

Ordered a pizza and it wasn't what I ordered but they corrected the pizza and got me a new one. They were super kind and I really appreciate them fixing the order! 10/10.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The indoor seating is fairly slim, but a large bay door opens to the outside. Atmosphere is pleasant, service was fast, food was pretty good. Seasoning was really lacking on the pizza.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

The pizza was really good, but it's the service that was outstanding for me.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5